Prom Queen Sweetheart Sister Perfume

[Chrissytree]

Some still smells like flowers... others smell like rancid rat pee!

I've got four bottle sealed in a bag and I was curious if they still smelled. The first one, nothing. Second was nice, very floral and possibly what it was originally. Third (and I have no idea why I opened the third), was a distinctive smell I hadn't experienced since my sister owned three female rats. Now either someone has carefully added rat pee scent to this bottle or its decomposed into that delightful scent. Best news is that I opened the bottles three days ago and the pee is lingering beautifully

[WingsOfMasquerade]

That is really interesting!
I was always curious about how those might smell/never owned a bottle though due to rarity. (Also curious about DB perfume smells, but those were cake/solid perfumes which no one can ever prevent from simply evaporating into nothing, unlike bottles)

If you also own any Perfume Puff ponies:
Is the good-smelling one similar to a PP? Did any of the SHS perfumes smell like any of the perfume ponies?

I LOVE PP smells, all of them smell totally fabulous to me.

But, we do know that smells break down like how sometimes one of the sweetberry ponies especially uh Cherry Treat I think will smell exactly like play doh.
But rat pee...that's a terrible thing to break down to! Maybe ammonia or something resulted? How strange and unfortunate. I wonder if anyone else has any of these SHS perfume bottles left to smell & compare?

[Chrissytree]

If you also own any Perfume Puff ponies:
Is the good-smelling one similar to a PP? Did any of the SHS perfumes smell like any of the perfume ponies

I have all the perfume puff ponies... but I'm afraid to open the wrong bottle of perfume! It was only a faint scent anyway, I'm not sure I could identify it.
I recently put all my Sundae Best ponies in a box. I opened it a couple of days later and it's the best smelling box in the world, ever! So I agree with loving the smells.

Ammonia might be a good call for the smell though.

[Jinxxy]

Plastic bags.... Oh how they marinate!

[Taffeta]

The only SHS perfume I have is MIB with my ChaCha, though I'm glad it's there and from the look of it I wouldn't want to open it any time soon even if I could. I suspect it's a highly dangerous substance now.

My Cherry Treats still smells of sickly sweetness, though I think playdoh would be an improvement.