I have an interested party (not from the forum) on my MLP G1 lot.  They have offered me way lower than I think it's valued at, however I know I won't get full value for it all and must sacrifice on price.

What would you reasonably pay (assuming it fit in your budget) for the following lot.  I know I have a few that have good value like 4-speed with all original accessories and a few others that are sought after.

Thanks in advance!  I don't want to ask for too much, but I don't want to lose out too much either.

Long list:

32 original brushes and combs (1 has 1 broken tooth, rest perfect)
5 after market hair accessories (barbie I think)
23 Original Ribbons (some frayed, rest great)

---Party Gift Pack---
5 hats, 5 noise makers, 5 pieces of cake with candles on a platter, 6 plates, 6 cups, party panties in original box, balloon, present, pin the tail on the pony game with all three tails, blanket/banner, extra bowl and basket (not MLP)

---Pony Pretty Parlour---
No parlour, sorry!
Purple saddle, purple bridle, 2 hats, peaches the cat (a bit faded), peaches riding basket, 4 shoes, saddle blanket, 8 name plates


Year Two Outfits (1983-1984)

---Sweet Dreams---
Outfit, cap, 3 curlers

---Pony Royal---
Crown, cape, 4 shoes

---The Tea Party---
Dress, straw hat, 4 shoes

---Best of the West---
Hat, saddle, blanket, bridle

---Parade Pizzazz---
Bridle with feather still attached, saddle blanket, 4 shoes


Year Three (1984-1985)

---Flashprance---
4 shoes, 4 legwarmers, rainbow suit, headband, purse


---Baby Glory Accessories---
Playpen, blanket, necklace, diaper


Pony Wear with Jewelry

---Something Old, Something New---
Wedding dress, veil, garter, 4 large shoes, 4 small shoes, ring & custom box (not MLP)


Baby Pony Wear with Pocket Pals

---Dragon Suit & Sunsuit---
Dragon outfit, lizard pocket pal, sun outfit, sun hat, frog pocket pal


Megan & Pony Wear


---Molly & Pony Ice Princesses Outfits---
Molly has jacket, pants & skates
Regular Pony has Coat & 6 skates (not sure why I have 6!)
Baby Pony has 1 hat & 1 skate


---Country Jamboree---
Megan has overalls, 2 shoes
Pony has dress, hat, 4 shoes



Possibly random outfits?

---Sweet Dreams---
(Not complete)
Sleeper, 4 pink slippers, 1 yellow slipper, night cap


---Cheerleader type outfit?---
Suit, 4 shoes


Various stickers, cut outs from boxes, posters etc.


All G1 Ponies:

Year One 1982-1983

Collector Ponies:

Blossom (my first pony!!)
Snuzzle
Bluebell
2 x Butterscotch (one original, one rescue with a hair cut)
Minty
2 x Cotton Candy (one original, one mail order)



Year Two 1983-1984

2 x Glory (One normal, 1 rescued pony that got a haircut)
Starshine
Moondancer (rescue pony – minor haircut)
Peachy (from Pretty Parlour)
Sprinkles & Duck Soup (Sprinkles won't stand)
Wedding Pony (So-Soft)
Pink Ember
Blue Ember
Lavender Ember


Year Three 1984-1985

Lickety Split
Powder
Sparkler
Gusty
Skyflier
Baby Cotton Candy
Baby Glory
Lily of the Valley (Mail order birthflower)


Year Four 1985-1986

Cupcake
Paradise
Best Wishes (from party pack)
Yum Yum (no wings - from party pack)
Baby Frosting (from party pack – this pony has a strange slick texture and is a bit sticky)
Galaxy
Masquerade
Party Time
Lily (flutterby – have wings, but not attached)
Megan with full outfit
Molly with full outfit
Baby Sundance with Beddy Bye Eyes
Sundance (So-Soft)


Year Five 1986-1987

Locket
Sugarberry
4-Speed with hat and bandana
Lucky with bowtie

Thunderwing - Thank you very much for your detailed response!  I really appreciate it. 

Some ponies are excellent condition, others are a bit dirty and a few have felt pen marks on the bottom of the feet. 

Your description of what you would expect to pay for each type item really helps me figure it out, thank you for taking the time to write it down!!

 


So hard letting something I've held dear to me go for only a couple of hundred dollars, but it totally makes sense.



Anyone else have an approximate price they would pay?  Does that sound about right?

Thanks all!

Thanks actually they have gone to a new home so it could be deleted if you need.  Thanks!