The MLP Arena

Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: freezestime on March 05, 2019, 09:59:36 PM

Title: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 05, 2019, 09:59:36 PM
Hi friends!

I was browsing eBay again and saw someone listed a MIB Sweet Scoops, knowing that it's rare I click on it to view it.

This person seems to have a outback garage of MIB G1 toys.

And while I can't really afford much of them, I wanted to share this find with you guys incase you need something that they have!

Their name is "family-love-peace-happiness.priceless" if this isn't allowed, let me know and I will pull it down/edit it.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SpaceButtPonies on March 05, 2019, 10:26:22 PM
Ooh I saw that listing, apparently it was a friend of hers who bought a storage unit and it happened to have all these G1 MOC/MIB ponies!

What are the odds?!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 05, 2019, 11:04:24 PM
Ooh I saw that listing, apparently it was a friend of hers who bought a storage unit and it happened to have all these G1 MOC/MIB ponies!

What are the odds?!

I know! It's a super amazing miracle! AAAAAAAAA

Post Merge: March 05, 2019, 11:14:09 PM

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: bladed on March 06, 2019, 12:00:07 AM
if that was me, i'd move into that storage unit!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Shy Violet on March 06, 2019, 12:07:11 AM
 :dropjaw: Wow. Just wow. That is the find of a lifetime.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Minty_Magic on March 06, 2019, 12:38:18 AM
 :dropjaw: oh my gosh, it’s like a museum! I really really wish that collection could stay together. what an incredible bundle of history! I doubt we’ll ever see a collection quite like that again. If I won the lottery I’d take them all in!

At the same time it makes me kinda sad, like why was the unit abandoned in the first place? :( It seems clear that this was a passionate pony lover... I hope that they’re okay and it’s nothing too sad!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SpaceButtPonies on March 06, 2019, 12:43:53 AM
At the same time it makes me kinda sad, like why was the unit abandoned in the first place? :( It seems clear that this was a passionate pony lover... I hope that they’re okay and it’s nothing too sad!

I thought the same thing!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: BlushingBlue on March 06, 2019, 12:52:45 AM
Oh, this hurt my heart to see... :sad: To think of all the time and money and care put into that collection. Lost to time, like tears in rain... :cloud: I can only imagine what could have befallen the original owner to have their belongings sold off in such a callous way. I hope having to forfeit their storage unit didn't cause them any more pain.

I suppose one can take comfort in the fact that the ponies are making their way back into collector hands instead of ending up in a landfill. I've told my family that when I die they can take my entire collection to the thrift store, so maybe someday my ultimate misfortune will be someone else's super amazing miracle.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on March 06, 2019, 03:50:38 AM
yeah with a large MOC collection like that, the community probably KNOWS the collector... which is sad.
Or it's Lexi's collection and we can be happy the ponies are liberated!  ;)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 06, 2019, 05:35:46 AM
Wow!  :dropjaw: :dropjaw:  So many beautiful MOC/MIB G1 ponies  I also wonder how the original owner lost possession of the storage unit as it looks like whoever the original owner was took great care to store them carefully.


It looks like there are a lot of things that we don't see MOC/MIB often. Do I see Greek MOCs also?



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 06, 2019, 06:07:47 AM
Wow!  :dropjaw: :dropjaw:  So many beautiful MOC/MIB G1 ponies  I also wonder how the original owner lost possession of the storage unit as it looks like whoever the original owner was took great care to store them carefully.


It looks like there are a lot of things that we don't see MOC/MIB often. Do I see Greek MOCs also?



Ponyfan

:0! I also spotted MIB Pony Bride and one sweetheart sister (Either Pretty Belle or Sweet Sundrop)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chibiskittles on March 06, 2019, 06:18:46 AM
I dont think they were a passionate collector.  I dont know the story either but the ponies were all found just in giant boxes, not all neat and on display like that.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=7Z3nc8oD13c
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 06, 2019, 06:39:52 AM
I dont think they were a passionate collector.  I dont know the story either but the ponies were all found just in giant boxes, not all neat and on display like that.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=7Z3nc8oD13c

Maybe failed toystore? Bought some boxes from a defunct Toys r us warehouse? Maybe leftover stock? Direct from the factory? There's so many possibilities!

Post Merge: March 06, 2019, 06:50:55 AM

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Harmony on March 06, 2019, 07:05:06 AM
I haven't been active in the community for awhile now, but a friend of mine messaged me with the story about this and my mind is absolutely BLOWN!!! We're each hoping that a MOC of our favorites ends up showing up at some point, because I will claw my way through the fray to get my hands on a MOC SS Twilight!! I'm also drooling like crazy over the pictures of the MIB Dream Beauties, among others. Just...WOW... :shocked:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 06, 2019, 07:08:53 AM
I haven't been active in the community for awhile now, but a friend of mine messaged me with the story about this and my mind is absolutely BLOWN!!! We're each hoping that a MOC of our favorites ends up showing up at some point, because I will claw my way through the fray to get my hands on a MOC SS Twilight!! I'm also drooling like crazy over the pictures of the MIB Dream Beauties, among others. Just...WOW... :shocked:

I'll be keeping a close eye on them so if I find a MOC SS Twilight, I'll let you know!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: StrawberryScoops on March 06, 2019, 07:17:53 AM
Some of my most wanted ponies have been listed already. Some can also be seen in the background pics of the collection. Unfortunately the prices are going higher than I can afford by the time you add on the horrible global shipping program. It’s quite a thing to see so many MOC/MIB ponies in one place. There are clearly a lot of full sets. It doesn’t seem like extra store stock to me though because there appears to only be one of each pony in their packages and no duplicates. It definitely seems like it was once a collectors.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 06, 2019, 07:51:24 AM
Can you imagine buying an abandoned storage unit and finding all that??
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 06, 2019, 08:01:48 AM
if that was me, i'd move into that storage unit!!

That is quite literally my dream.

Although it is true that it's also sad...there are a lot of reasons that it ended up in abandoned storage like that. If the collector is still around, and they needed the money, they'd have sold the ponies. If not, though, and we knew them, then you'd think we'd know. There are a lot of collectors who just collect and then drift on. You also all have to remember that back in the early days MIP ponies were very much cheaper than now. We're talking $30 for MIB newborn twins and $25 for Glory and Medley. There were also a lot more of them around, and a lot less interest in them in general.

They could also have been bought up by an adult during the 1980s and then put in storage and forgotten about, only to be discovered now. Lots of reasons. I think it's sad but it's less sad than them being lost and forgotten forevermore.

My sister will get my collection if anything happens to me and vice versa as it's a shared collection, but I always hope in the long run my ponies will end up in some kind of museum, rather than being sold - so lots of people can take care of them. However I have known at least one pony collector who had plans for her ponies and their distribution after her death which didn't happen at all as she wanted, so who knows.

BUT so awesome that these are all there and preserved after all this time. It's a huge boost for MIP collecting that they do survive and hopefully will now be in the community. Maybe in the long run it will also bring some prices down because of the quantity. We can hope...though doesn't look like that right now.

I wonder if there's a Taffeta in that collection. I see Dawn, but not Taffeta. I still have three from that set I'm looking for MIB, although I really can't afford any of them xD.

I am so happy they're all on US card or I think I would probably implode as I have pretty much zero pony money right now :) Also MIP ponies via the GSP is risky anyway. I think it'd have to be a lower price for me to risk it. But I LOVE looking at all the pics and the listings and realising that yes, more MIP ones still survive!

It is also really interesting seeing which ones are getting the immediate bid attention, too.

Edit - looking at the pics more, there's loose stuff in there too. It's someone's collection.

A LOT of ponypeople have gone from the community who were here in the old days and not all have sold up. Maybe one of them...

I guess there's a chance of a Mimic being among them. Albeit she's not half as rare MOC as some other ponies, her price is mostly thanks to it being mimic and the idiocy of the past...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: tailrustedtealeaf on March 06, 2019, 08:36:47 AM
It's an amazing find, but I feel bad about it.  :(
I do hope the ponies find good new homes, though!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Sora on March 06, 2019, 09:42:44 AM
That is one of the most awesome hauls I've seen in a long time.

And I see Sweet Stuff MOC.... May keep an eye out for that one!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 06, 2019, 10:40:01 AM
From what the seller said, the owner has passed away. Its so sad that all those ponies are going to split, they deserve to be all together in a museum.

To be honest, I'm amazed and its like a mystery to me all that stuff locked in that place. And I wonder if it really was the owner's intention to leave them that way or maybe some other circumstances (for example, family members who kept everything in there and forgot about them). I think it will be very difficult for us to know what happened  :(
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: brightberry on March 06, 2019, 11:05:54 AM
The way they're organized, I think whoever put them in there cared a lot their ponies.

It is very sad the person has passed.  But maybe they would be happy to know that the proceeds will help the family.

I don't know if I will bid.  There are a few that I'd like to have but, I also like having them out of the box.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 06, 2019, 11:31:40 AM
The way they're organized, I think whoever put them in there cared a lot their ponies.

It is very sad the person has passed.  But maybe they would be happy to know that the proceeds will help the family.

I don't know if I will bid.  There are a few that I'd like to have but, I also like having them out of the box.

The seller reorganized the place like we can see in the pictures but when he bidded the place looked like a mess, you can see it in the 4:28 minute of the video:

https://youtu.be/7Z3nc8oD13c?t=268 (https://youtu.be/7Z3nc8oD13c?t=268)

They also uploaded a video only for the MLP stuff.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P18TO_rmq_w&t=190s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P18TO_rmq_w&t=190s)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: buddyboymama on March 06, 2019, 11:45:20 AM
This is the most amazing thing I’ve ever seen! He’s saying there are five behind each one he shows ... so I wonder if this may be the complete run of G1 ponies. Wow! Thanks for sharing.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Bibinettepony on March 06, 2019, 11:55:37 AM
 :shocked: :shocked: what an amazing story!!! I am divided between: waouh so sad for the owner who passed away  :cry: :cry: and waouh what an amazing find (I am thinking about the person who bought it and find what was inside :blink:)

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: bladed on March 06, 2019, 12:14:22 PM
I wonder if there's a Taffeta in that collection. I see Dawn, but not Taffeta. I still have three from that set I'm looking for MIB, although I really can't afford any of them xD.
there is, you can see her in the video linked above :)
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

(the guy pronounces it as taffetia  :lol: )
she likes starbucks i guess :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 06, 2019, 01:28:03 PM
This is the thing that pony dreams are made of!! Sooo lucky that things like this are still turning up after 35 years. Also it looks like leftover store stock to me not a collection but either way, IT’S AWESOME!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 06, 2019, 01:46:32 PM
I think it might be a complete MOC/MIB US G1 collection along  with the loose ponies in the cases.  I’ve never seen a MIB Soft Sleepy Newborn before and all those MOC Petite Ponies. :wow:  Swing that MIB Lullabye Nursery reminds me how much I miss mine. I hope these ponies end up in loving homes.

I’m sorry to hear that the owner has passed away. :sad:

Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Khayman81 on March 06, 2019, 02:06:41 PM
How amazing is this. Still on eBay most of the ponies are already gone for crazy prizes. Maybe in some time it will make them go down. In the pictures you can see sooooo many of them.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 06, 2019, 02:13:08 PM
Are we all screenshotting photos of these for wiki pages? We should get permission from the seller. Especially as some of these have never been seen MIB/MOC are may not be seen again!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Eternia on March 06, 2019, 02:19:14 PM
I’m so interested in this story! It looks like a complete MOC collection
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on March 06, 2019, 02:56:19 PM
I've got permission to use them for my site so I don't think they'd have a problem sharing with the wiki too.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on March 06, 2019, 02:57:27 PM
Heres the short story: The original owner of the storage locker passed away and the locker went up for sale, a person who buys storage lockers for a living happened to buy it for 300$. Inside were all the ponies you see plus tons of transformers, hotwheels, comics etc. I don't think it was a collector, perhaps just a man who liked to horde toys. You can see the locker here before the buyers cleaned it out:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


The ponies were being kept all piled together in huge cardboard shipping crates like this:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


The pictures from the auctions with the ponies all lined up nicely on shelves were set up so by the seller.So I don't think the original owner was a collector in the manner we are.

Everyone is going crazy on these auctions, the prices are going way high for sure. Good luck everyone who is bidding Baby Moondancer is already 710$  :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 06, 2019, 03:11:04 PM
Someone has bid over $2,0000 for Baby Firefly  :ack:



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: brightberry on March 06, 2019, 03:22:07 PM
Someone has bid over $2,0000 for Baby Firefly  :ack:



Ponyfan
That's madness! Wow.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 06, 2019, 03:24:43 PM
Someone has bid over $2,0000 for Baby Firefly  :ack:



Ponyfan
That's madness! Wow.


Oops :blush: I meant $2,000 Still a lot of money though.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: brightberry on March 06, 2019, 03:39:17 PM
Yes... I went back and saw $2,000  :blush:  I can only think that person really wants her.  But even so, doesn't that mean that someone had to bid them up?  I thought Ebay did automatic bidding?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Gonatcha on March 06, 2019, 03:42:15 PM
Also MIP ponies via the GSP is risky anyway. I think it'd have to be a lower price for me to risk it.

What is the Global shipping programme and why is it risky?

/Swedish collector being out of the loop for a looong time ;-)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: brightberry on March 06, 2019, 03:53:05 PM
Quote
Heres the short story: The original owner of the storage locker passed away and the locker went up for sale, a person who buys storage lockers for a living happened to buy it for 300$. Inside were all the ponies you see plus tons of transformers, hotwheels, comics etc. I don't think it was a collector, perhaps just a man who liked to horde toys. You can see the locker here before the buyers cleaned it out:

That's a really lucky find! That guy must have liked ponies somewhat.  The mail order ponies are there too.  Plus, loose ponies. Maybe they came from garage sales.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 06, 2019, 04:12:28 PM
Yes... I went back and saw $2,000  :blush:  I can only think that person really wants her.  But even so, doesn't that mean that someone had to bid them up?  I thought Ebay did automatic bidding?

Someone had  to put a max bid in at the current price  but Baby Firefly jumped from $500 to $2000 within 3 bids.

A couple of the others are starting to skyrocket in price too.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on March 06, 2019, 04:18:40 PM
Quote
Heres the short story: The original owner of the storage locker passed away and the locker went up for sale, a person who buys storage lockers for a living happened to buy it for 300$. Inside were all the ponies you see plus tons of transformers, hotwheels, comics etc. I don't think it was a collector, perhaps just a man who liked to horde toys. You can see the locker here before the buyers cleaned it out:

That's a really lucky find! That guy must have liked ponies somewhat.  The mail order ponies are there too.  Plus, loose ponies. Maybe they came from garage sales.
Yes it would be great to know how/why he collected all those ponies!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Cottononi on March 06, 2019, 04:28:53 PM
Like many others have said, this is an amazing find. So glad to see that something like this can still pop up and give something for the community to admire.

What I'm curious about is that is there a list of ponies that no-one has as MOC/MIB and if there is, are any of those ponies seen here?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PinkRosedust on March 06, 2019, 05:17:20 PM
Nooo these pictures are too much for me to handle, take them away! :faint:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 06, 2019, 05:43:25 PM
Alright so. The person who shot Baby Firefly up to $2,000 is also the person who's in the lead on Sweet Scoops and Yum Yum. They're the highest bidder on 23 of these ponies total and if that's not extremely sketchy, I don't know what is. I did the math and they'd owe $5,104.17 to the seller if they won them all at the current prices, before shipping of course. They've either gotta be a non paying bidder, or they're bidding purely for the sake of raising the prices.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: JazzMatazz on March 06, 2019, 05:53:09 PM
Alright so. The person who shot Baby Firefly up to $2,000 is also the person who's in the lead on Sweet Scoops and Yum Yum. They're the highest bidder on 23 of these ponies total and if that's not extremely sketchy, I don't know what is. I did the math and they'd owe $5,104.17 to the seller if they won them all at the current prices, before shipping of course. They've either gotta be a non paying bidder, or they're bidding purely for the sake of raising the prices.

Or the very minimal chance they are just loaded with $$$$$  :money:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 06, 2019, 06:06:20 PM
Alright so. The person who shot Baby Firefly up to $2,000 is also the person who's in the lead on Sweet Scoops and Yum Yum. They're the highest bidder on 23 of these ponies total and if that's not extremely sketchy, I don't know what is. I did the math and they'd owe $5,104.17 to the seller if they won them all at the current prices, before shipping of course. They've either gotta be a non paying bidder, or they're bidding purely for the sake of raising the prices.

I hope this doesn’t turn bad. Everyone was so excited to see what looks like a US G1 complete collection MOC/MIB but I do find it suspicious that one person would be the higgest bidder on that many of the auctions. The bidding on Baby Firefly doesn’t make sense. The plastic is yellowed and the piece of tape at the back of the box is barely holding the box closed.  I know that’s possible with toys that are that old but I still find it hard to believe anyone would be willing to pay $2000 for a MIB Baby Firefly in that condition. Also the bids jumped high amounts not in smaller increments like I would expect in a bidding war.

Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lady_lemondrop on March 06, 2019, 06:22:01 PM
Oh. My. God. That is like nothing I have ever seen before! Pity they can't stay together I agree..
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Sunset on March 06, 2019, 07:35:51 PM
Wow!  This is so crazy.  Very much like actual dreams I’ve had except I always wake up before actually getting to posses the ponies.   I was hoping that I might get to snag a couple of these for decent prices with the market basically being flooded at the moment.  But the Baby Firefly thing is concerning :/  and I just looked and it looks like that bidder only has 1 feedback.  Very scetchy....
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 06, 2019, 07:56:29 PM
Wow!  This is so crazy.  Very much like actual dreams I’ve had except I always wake up before actually getting to posses the ponies.   I was hoping that I might get to snag a couple of these for decent prices with the market basically being flooded at the moment.  But the Baby Firefly thing is concerning :/  and I just looked and it looks like that bidder only has 1 feedback.  Very scetchy....

I actually messaged them on eBay and informed them about our suspicions, they responded with the fact someone had informed them earlier of the "trickster" so they're gonna change the rules next pony batch.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Honeycomb on March 06, 2019, 08:46:21 PM
I haven't been drooling that much in ages ..... Wow!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Skylar on March 06, 2019, 10:44:44 PM
Such an exciting find! Its like Pony Heaven! Is it terrible that I am so jealous of the person who found it??
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Beldarna on March 06, 2019, 11:29:59 PM
I'm kind of teary eyed and has goosebumps allover. This is a find one dreams of. I wish I had the funds to bid on these (heck now I wish I had en ebay account). I hope the lucky winners take good care of the ponies.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 06, 2019, 11:40:05 PM
Such an exciting find! Its like Pony Heaven! Is it terrible that I am so jealous of the person who found it??

You're not alone!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 06, 2019, 11:49:24 PM
Also MIP ponies via the GSP is risky anyway. I think it'd have to be a lower price for me to risk it.

What is the Global shipping programme and why is it risky?

/Swedish collector being out of the loop for a looong time ;-)

In short, the seller pays ebay to do the sending to your country via their agent - the risks are:

1*  very expensive for you as a buyer (you pay extra shipping for the agent service PLUS import duties)
2*  the packing agents see something in a box (MIB) and de-box the item so it fits in their packing boxes.  :shocked: :shocked: :shocked:
3*  Or they bend your items in such a way that they are no longer considered mint.  >_< >_< >_<

so, not a popular shipping choice for those worried about the quality of the care of their purchases!

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 12:09:27 AM
I messaged the seller about GSP and they said the next batch won’t be sold via GSP. I also asked if I won an auction and pay can they just NOT send it through GSP and they said yes.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 07, 2019, 12:26:19 AM
Also MIP ponies via the GSP is risky anyway. I think it'd have to be a lower price for me to risk it.

What is the Global shipping programme and why is it risky?

/Swedish collector being out of the loop for a looong time ;-)

In short, the seller pays ebay to do the sending to your country via their agent - the risks are:

1*  very expensive for you as a buyer (you pay extra shipping for the agent service PLUS import duties)
2*  the packing agents see something in a box (MIB) and de-box the item so it fits in their packing boxes.  :shocked: :shocked: :shocked:
3*  Or they bend your items in such a way that they are no longer considered mint.  >_< >_< >_<

so, not a popular shipping choice for those worried about the quality of the care of their purchases!


I messaged the seller about GSP and they said the next batch won’t be sold via GSP. I also asked if I won an auction and pay can they just NOT send it through GSP and they said yes.

If GSP is bad, is there an alternative?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Barnacle_lady on March 07, 2019, 12:45:24 AM
Sometimes I watch these storage auction tv shows and hoping to see something like this. :) Very cool this.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Bibinettepony on March 07, 2019, 01:24:08 AM
they already sell on Ebay? did not watch the items?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: NightGliderSA on March 07, 2019, 02:13:32 AM
Wow, just imagine if a collector HAD bought this container - how happy would that person be right now this minute? Myself as a random example... it's sad that the collection is being split up, but at the prices the ponies appear to be going for we can probably guarantee that they are going into collector hands. Which is something at least.

(goes away to hide in a corner and eat a lot of chocolate)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 03:14:26 AM
Also MIP ponies via the GSP is risky anyway. I think it'd have to be a lower price for me to risk it.

What is the Global shipping programme and why is it risky?

/Swedish collector being out of the loop for a looong time ;-)

In short, the seller pays ebay to do the sending to your country via their agent - the risks are:

1*  very expensive for you as a buyer (you pay extra shipping for the agent service PLUS import duties)
2*  the packing agents see something in a box (MIB) and de-box the item so it fits in their packing boxes.  :shocked: :shocked: :shocked:
3*  Or they bend your items in such a way that they are no longer considered mint.  >_< >_< >_<

so, not a popular shipping choice for those worried about the quality of the care of their purchases!


I messaged the seller about GSP and they said the next batch won’t be sold via GSP. I also asked if I won an auction and pay can they just NOT send it through GSP and they said yes.

If GSP is bad, is there an alternative?

Yes just normal international shipping.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 07, 2019, 04:29:28 AM
Also MIP ponies via the GSP is risky anyway. I think it'd have to be a lower price for me to risk it.

What is the Global shipping programme and why is it risky?

/Swedish collector being out of the loop for a looong time ;-)

In short, the seller pays ebay to do the sending to your country via their agent - the risks are:

1*  very expensive for you as a buyer (you pay extra shipping for the agent service PLUS import duties)
2*  the packing agents see something in a box (MIB) and de-box the item so it fits in their packing boxes.  :shocked: :shocked: :shocked:
3*  Or they bend your items in such a way that they are no longer considered mint.  >_< >_< >_<

so, not a popular shipping choice for those worried about the quality of the care of their purchases!


I messaged the seller about GSP and they said the next batch won’t be sold via GSP. I also asked if I won an auction and pay can they just NOT send it through GSP and they said yes.

If GSP is bad, is there an alternative?

Yes just normal international shipping.

Is that more expensive?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 07, 2019, 04:35:24 AM
Is anyone else having trouble getting the 2nd page of ponies on Ebay to load? I can see the first page just fine but the 2nd page doesn’t show the ponies on it. I can still find them by searching by individual pony names but not by clicking the 2nd page on “See seller’s other items.

 Sweet Scoops is almost $900 now. :wow:

Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 07, 2019, 04:40:01 AM
Re GSP -all the horrors are real :/ But if the seller is willing to ship internationally without GSP they should take the option off the listings. Admittedly that would a really mundane task, but if they are fine about international shipping they are risking losing a lot of custom by locking it into that system.

Re the prices - it can be. But international postage with or without tracking offers additional benefits such as the possibility to combine items (if the seller is willing). It also offers the option of having door to door insurance (whereas GSP consider dumping a parcel under a bush to be a delivery, even in the rain). The risk is you pay customs charges at your border - but frankly, I'd rather pay customs charges to my own country's agents, as annoying as I find the British govt and their systems, than pay it to Ebay and pay inflated estimations of what they think the custom duty is. Having seen it be almost 3x as high on GSP as it would be in regular post...no thanks.

For me the safety of the item is paramount. I will risk loose ponies via GSP. I won't risk MIP ones. Esp not G1.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 07, 2019, 04:45:50 AM
Is anyone else having trouble getting the 2nd page of ponies on Ebay to load? I can see the first page just fine but the 2nd page doesn’t show the ponies on it. I can still find them by searching by individual pony names but not by clicking the 2nd page on “See seller’s other items.

 Sweet Scoops is almost $900 now. :wow:

Ponyfan

I'm not having any issues with the second page. Weird.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Avea2006 on March 07, 2019, 09:30:53 AM
Wow!  This is so crazy.  Very much like actual dreams I’ve had except I always wake up before actually getting to posses the ponies.   I was hoping that I might get to snag a couple of these for decent prices with the market basically being flooded at the moment.  But the Baby Firefly thing is concerning :/  and I just looked and it looks like that bidder only has 1 feedback.  Very scetchy....

I actually messaged them on eBay and informed them about our suspicions, they responded with the fact someone had informed them earlier of the "trickster" so they're gonna change the rules next pony batch.

But wouldn't the most likely cause of this be shill bidding? Where the seller is artificially raising prices? Because I can't think of any reason for a normal bidder to inflate prices like that...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 07, 2019, 09:41:00 AM
Wow!  This is so crazy.  Very much like actual dreams I’ve had except I always wake up before actually getting to posses the ponies.   I was hoping that I might get to snag a couple of these for decent prices with the market basically being flooded at the moment.  But the Baby Firefly thing is concerning :/  and I just looked and it looks like that bidder only has 1 feedback.  Very scetchy....

I actually messaged them on eBay and informed them about our suspicions, they responded with the fact someone had informed them earlier of the "trickster" so they're gonna change the rules next pony batch.

But wouldn't the most likely cause of this be shill bidding? Where the seller is artificially raising prices? Because I can't think of any reason for a normal bidder to inflate prices like that...

Shillers are usually a lot more clever than that and manage to integrate their bidding so that it's hard to detect. I remember we used to stalk a few suspect shillers in the old days and you could eventually root out a pattern but it was one done over time (and then you could see the full name of the bidder as well, which made it easier). The thing is that to profit from shilling, you have to push other bidders up to that price else you don't make a sale. So going too crazy doesn't achieve anything.

It also takes 2 bidders to reach a crazy price on ebay. It may be that there's someone with a crazy high bid on every auction. We only would see that if someone else started bidding them up.

It might be a crazy newbie bidding obsessively. Or someone going rogue with an account that isn't theirs. Lots of potential reasons. Someone really loves baby firefly? I dunno.

There's also a bidder shilling tactic in this that could be included, though. Which is that two bidders work together, bidding it way up so nobody else gets involved. Then one retracts the bid near the end and the auction falls to the price of the other bidder who then wins. I have seen it a couple of times. It's highly disgusting behaviour. But I would be more suspicious of that (if it isn't a crazy person) than the seller shilling.  The fact we're discussing it now as suspicious is counterproductive to the seller who wants to make a good sale and doesn't really need shilling help to do that - so I think if something is going on, that's more likely.

On another note, I think Twilight's bubble has been retaped at the top. It looks like discoloured tape.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on March 07, 2019, 09:46:57 AM
I also thought of shill bidding as well, but like Taffeta said it's not always that easy. it could just be a petty person who likes ruining things for others.There are people who will go out of their way just to be nuisances.

 Apparently the person who's doing the listing on eBay isn't the one who bought the locker. On one of the pony FB groups there's been a couple threads about this and on the first one a person asked the seller if they'd take offers. The eBay seller replied "HE ALREADY HAD OFFERS TO SELL THE ENTIRE STORAGE, BUT HE JUST LIKES TO WATCH THE ACTION ON EBAY."

I'm just going to sit back and watch what happens. I've been able to get several mib ponies for good prices here, on FB and from local collectors so I'd rather not overpay because of a frenzy.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 07, 2019, 09:50:49 AM


I'm just going to sit back and watch what happens. I've been able to get several mib ponies for good prices here, on FB and from local collectors so I'd rather not overpay because of a frenzy.

Me too. And I genuinely have no space for more MIP items anyway :/

The fact they are in US packages makes me quite relieved because if they were UK packaged ponies I'd lose my mind. There are only a few US packaged ponies I'd be interested in and most of them are above my budget level now so it's become a spectator sport.

It is interesting to see how things go in sales like this. Sometimes massive lots like this up prices, sometimes the opposite happens. I guess we'll see after this. The last time I saw so many sets of newborn twins go up at the same time MIB several of them topped $500...but in normal times on their own they don't usually cost more than $150. I am wondering if that will happen again this time.

What I hope will happen is that this glut will inspire anyone who knows they have ponies in the attic mip to put them on ebay as well, so we have way more ponies to buy from and prices overall go down. ;)

Quote from: Noasar
Are we all screenshotting photos of these for wiki pages? We should get permission from the seller. Especially as some of these have never been seen MIB/MOC are may not be seen again!

Second getting them on websites wherever possible, with permission of course! MIP items are absolute prize sources for accessory intel.

What has never been seen MIP before though? I haven't seen anything yet that hasn't been on ebay in the past at one point or another?

They're US carded ponies, which are much more common than MOC packages from any other place, probably due to the size of the country. There's some really rare stuff in there, but nothing that hasn't come up before. (I want to emphasise that before anyone sells their soul to buy a pony xD)

Even Taffeta (Taffetiah xD) has come up at least five or six times in the past. I just can't afford her :/

Edit to add: BY THE WAY...according to ebay's GSP calculator, to buy Baby Firefly at that price would cost an additional $554.34 on customs fees on top of the final price. I strongly suspect even HMRC would balk at that fee.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 10:45:12 AM
Quote
What has never been seen MIP before though? I haven't seen anything yet that hasn't been on ebay in the past at one point or another?

They're US carded ponies, which are much more common than MOC packages from any other place, probably due to the size of the country. There's some really rare stuff in there, but nothing that hasn't come up before. (I want to emphasise that before anyone sells their soul to buy a pony xD)

Admittedly I'm far from being the font of all pony knowledge but I personally have never seen a MOC BH Dazzleglow or SSSN in boxes so it was nice to see them on card. I know that many of them have been seen before, and people already probably own many of them MOC :)

If there are any photos missing from Wiki pages now would be the time to add them, whether or not they've been seen before!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 07, 2019, 10:58:58 AM
Quote
What has never been seen MIP before though? I haven't seen anything yet that hasn't been on ebay in the past at one point or another?

They're US carded ponies, which are much more common than MOC packages from any other place, probably due to the size of the country. There's some really rare stuff in there, but nothing that hasn't come up before. (I want to emphasise that before anyone sells their soul to buy a pony xD)

Admittedly I'm far from being the font of all pony knowledge but I personally have never seen a MOC BH Dazzleglow or SSSN in boxes so it was nice to see them on card. I know that many of them have been seen before, and people already probably own many of them MOC :)

If there are any photos missing from Wiki pages now would be the time to add them, whether or not they've been seen before!

Blue heart MOC Dazzleglow's pictured on my website O.o.

It's true the SSN haven't come up MIP for a very long time. They are super rare MIB. They have been up before but it's probably been more than ten years, now I think about it. Like with the Dream Beauties - in the early 2000s there were loads of those MIP but now they hardly come up. That's why I suspect this collection was put together then rather than now, when those things were more available.

I think it's sad thinking how much we took for granted and didn't save in the past that now is not seen as much as it was then. I know there were several big MIP collections back then, and I strongly suspect when the Delaneys sold Helen's stuff and then their own stuff most of these items came up including the ones you mention. The good thing about that is that there are other examples xD And that we have an opportunity to fill those gaps on the other sites that do still exist to include them.

It's the UK and European ponies that are the problem. There are sole surviving examples of those and some we've never seen MIP yet.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 11:41:16 AM
Quote
Blue heart MOC Dazzleglow's pictured on my website O.o.


I have to confess I've never been on your website Taffeta! Clearly I'm missing out!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on March 07, 2019, 11:48:12 AM
I've got permission to use the photos for the Wiki :)

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Reaperfox on March 07, 2019, 12:33:38 PM
They did say there were two boxes didn't they? Isn't there a chance the other one has Euro/Non US ponies in it? I just find it difficult to imagine a collector with this much passion (and money) doesn't own ANY non-US ponies? (I think I saw NSS Magic Star there maybe).

Hello I have risen from the grave XD
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 12:36:38 PM
Brilliant! Well done Chrissy!

I think the general consensus is that it’s not a collector, it’s old shop stock. Welcome back Reaperfox!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 07, 2019, 12:49:10 PM


On another note, I think Twilight's bubble has been retaped at the top. It looks like discoloured tape.


I noticed the extra tape also. I think her bubble must have fallen off or been about to fall off and someone retaped it. Her bubble is also cracked open in a few places.



Blue heart MOC Dazzleglow's pictured on my website O.o.

It's true the SSN haven't come up MIP for a very long time. They are super rare MIB. They have been up before but it's probably been more than ten years, now I think about it. Like with the Dream Beauties - in the early 2000s there were loads of those MIP but now they hardly come up. That's why I suspect this collection was put together then rather than now, when those things were more available.

I think it's sad thinking how much we took for granted and didn't save in the past that now is not seen as much as it was then. I know there were several big MIP collections back then, and I strongly suspect when the Delaneys sold Helen's stuff and then their own stuff most of these items came up including the ones you mention. The good thing about that is that there are other examples xD And that we have an opportunity to fill those gaps on the other sites that do still exist to include them.

It's the UK and European ponies that are the problem. There are sole surviving examples of those and some we've never seen MIP yet.



The Soft Sleepy Newborns were the first things I noticed that I hadn't seen MIB but I came in really late to collecting ponies so by the time I really starting collecting them the days of cheap MOCs/MIBs were long gone.


I noticed there were some Greek MOC ponies in the pictures but not sure if there are more non US ponies there.

I've got permission to use the photos for the Wiki :)




Yay! I love looking at MOC/MIB ponies pics. I'm really happy they will be on the Wiki :)


One thing I've been wondering about is how all of the ponies were so carefully preserved if they were just stacked in a box? Wouldn't the MOC pony bubbles get smashed?


Ponyfan


Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 07, 2019, 12:52:44 PM

I think the general consensus is that it’s not a collector, it’s old shop stock. Welcome back Reaperfox!

Shop stock with mail order ponies? And from what it seems, each one of the ponies of all sets/years, no doubles? I really have doubts about that. I think it was a person who just bought the stuff back in the day (and thats why they dont have non US ponies either).
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 12:55:46 PM

I think the general consensus is that it’s not a collector, it’s old shop stock. Welcome back Reaperfox!

Shop stock with mail order ponies? And from what it seems, each one of the ponies of all sets/years, no doubles? I really have doubts about that. I think it was a person who just bought the stuff back in the day (and thats why they dont have non US ponies either).

That’s true! But what about all the other 80s toy stock that was in there? Very varied for a toy collector although I know people can (and do) collect in more than one area.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 07, 2019, 01:08:47 PM
They did say there were two boxes didn't they? Isn't there a chance the other one has Euro/Non US ponies in it? I just find it difficult to imagine a collector with this much passion (and money) doesn't own ANY non-US ponies? (I think I saw NSS Magic Star there maybe).

Hello I have risen from the grave XD

*prods*. Oi, Sel, did you just say NSS? *grins*

I think it could be a collection acquired back when they were out in stores. There are some examples of that happening. Though it could easily be a collector collecting from back when MIP were cheap (do you remember that? XD) and there weren't huge numbers of UK carded ponies then, let alone ones that were as cheap as the US ones were back then.  I guess we'll see though. I won't pretend I don't want UK ponies to show up (unless they're later year ones. I could live with that xD I am so transparent xD).

I'm glad the pics can go on the Wiki. I think it's important that they do.

@Noasar, you don't have to use my site if you have preferences for others, that wasn't my point at all. Just that it seemed odd to me to say something had never been seen before because it's not on the Wiki. A lot of stuff isn't on the wiki.

My real reason for pulling up your comment though was just to put things in a rational place. All these things have been seen before and probably will be seen again. I remember all the stupid about whether a MOC Mimic could exist and then when the first one appeared it went nuts because everyone was certain it was the Only One Ever. There are currently I think more MOC Mimics than there are the whole of the MB set, but she still sells at around the same price they do. There are also several MIP ponies that sold for much less than Mimic which are the only known surviving examples :/

So yeah, awesome. Rare. But not something that if you miss it now, there'll never be another chance. Especially since it seems there's already one crazy bidder determined to disrupt pony valuation, I wanted to make sure nobody else felt desperate enough to play that game too.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 07, 2019, 01:09:18 PM

I think the general consensus is that it’s not a collector, it’s old shop stock. Welcome back Reaperfox!

Shop stock with mail order ponies? And from what it seems, each one of the ponies of all sets/years, no doubles? I really have doubts about that. I think it was a person who just bought the stuff back in the day (and thats why they dont have non US ponies either).

That’s true! But what about all the other 80s toy stock that was in there? Very varied for a toy collector although I know people can (and do) collect in more than one area.

I know! That confuses me a lot. Maybe they were a couple and they collected several different things, or maybe it was someone who had contacts with the toy companies. We don't know if they storaged the stuff that way or was someone else. Honestly, it kills me we couldn't never know the story behind this  :wonder:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: aero_oceana on March 07, 2019, 01:16:41 PM
I just wanted to pipe in and say... HOLY PONY! Best find I've ever seen. I'm following this closely but doubt I will be able to purchase anything. I think I would have a heart attack if I ever found this haul.

MIP Rapunzel will be fun to watch. :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 07, 2019, 01:32:19 PM
Quote
Just that it seemed odd to me to say something had never been seen before because it's not on the Wiki. A lot of stuff isn't on the wiki.

...I never said anything about it never being seen because it wasn’t on the Wiki? I think I was just excited because I had never seen them before! What can I say, I’m easily pleased and I definitely missed out on the ‘cheap’ MOC days!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 07, 2019, 01:38:50 PM
Quote
Just that it seemed odd to me to say something had never been seen before because it's not on the Wiki. A lot of stuff isn't on the wiki.

...I never said anything about it never being seen because it wasn’t on the Wiki? I think I was just excited because I had never seen them before! What can I say, I’m easily pleased and I definitely missed out on the ‘cheap’ MOC days!

There's a difference between saying what you've seen and what's never been seen before, so I guess I assumed. I mean, she's not on the Wiki :) My apologies if I assumed too much.

What I regret about the cheap MOC days is that I didn't keep all the ones I bought then until now to sell them to pay for my rent and PhD costs :/ I went through a purge of mostly US carded and boxed ones including a dream beauty some ten or twelve years ago. And I don't regret parting with the ponies, but yeah. I wish I had them to sell now...is that wrong?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Goanna on March 07, 2019, 05:43:56 PM
Wow! Just totally amazing!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: maycrestmom on March 08, 2019, 03:45:04 AM
wow yes that is quite the stash

am I reading correctly that most seem to have a Toys R Us sticker?  So yeah, not sure if they were just buying and holding...

not to be a downer but an ebay buyer with a "0" score bidding up alot of the stock has me thinking "shill" bidder...sorry it just seems it would be too tempting for this re-seller given the story and lack of info from the family that lost to just a $300 dollar bid for a storage locker.

Is there anyway to confirm with ebay that there is a legit history for that 0 account-bidder?  I would hate for the MLPcommunity to be taken "for a ride" in the excitement of so many MOC and MIB items when here we are discussing the joy of a more complete wiki upload  and all a reseller is caring is about the biggest bucks by any means possible

anyhow at this time I thank you all greatly  that have contacted the seller for more pics in helping establish a better digital history of these guys :-) love the MLP-family for that archiving spirit :-)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 08, 2019, 04:04:43 AM
I've noticed some of these are going for extremely high prices like Baby Firelfy, Baby Moondancer  Twice as Fancy Yum Yum  and Sweet Scoops while some of the earlier ponies with discolored bubbles and boxes I agree with Taffeta that Twilight's bubble looks like it's retaped.

I'm not sure what to think about the low feedback bidder driving the prices so high. It does seem a little unsual to me due to the fact that the bids suddenly increase by hundrends instead of smaller amounts.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: maycrestmom on March 08, 2019, 05:01:46 AM
exactly... and the fact that this is a reseller and we haven't got a good history on the collector... not that ponies can't be found in the wild and all suddenly we have a ton of "new" MLP like what happened when MLP from bisanti / venezuela was found out

just I have to admit that the evil-bay does not have the best of market reputations so this is where to me I believe our pony community can protect each other when we do see suspicious activity and it can be reported as such for further investigation if need be

I am happy for the seller as that whole storage-wars stuff takes a lot of time for the once-in-a-lifetime jackpot win like this event.  I also just hope that this re-sale ain't playin' with a stacked deck KWIM?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 08, 2019, 05:38:09 AM
I think shill bidding traditionally defined is inflation by the seller with other accounts.

It seems pretty dumb for the seller to go and just put really high bids in like that and be obvious. It's more like trolling rather then schilling.

Also, it's not always about bidders with low feedback. The person who has 169 feedback has a history of retractions, including at least 1 on the ponies.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 08, 2019, 06:05:06 AM
Yeah, I think the seller would have to be extremely dumb to shill bid up to $2,000, especially when it sounds like they did their research.  (Guy in the video mentions what his friend is expecting to get and I believe he said "about $50" or around there . . . He didn't say "around $2,000", lol.)

I think if there IS a scam, it is probably what Taffeta mentioned:  unsavory bidder makes sure they are the high bidder when the prices is $40 or something;  then unsavory bidder creates two puppet accounts and stages a fake bidding war between them, driving the price up so that no one else will bid.  Unsavory bidder then retracts the bids of the puppet accounts at the last moment.  Now their "real" account is the high bidder at $40.

Of course it's also possible real bidders are legitimately going crazy and bidding more than they normally would.  What sounds cooler:  "This is a mint on card pony, I don't know how the seller happened to have it" OOOOOOR "This is a mint on card pony, I got it from a seller who found an insane cache of MOC ponies in a storage locker"?    The second one is just more exciting.  I can understand wanting a piece of this particular set, maybe even for people who normally wouldn't be that into MOCs or nostalgic people who normally don't collect ponies at all.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 08, 2019, 06:16:50 AM
Meme bidding. A 21st century problem.

It used to be much harder to retract and there were strict rules in play. I am pretty suspicious of baby glory and baby firefly both. Less so on some of the others. I feel something bidder related is going on on those two. But it would be so much better if ebay was as transparent as it used to be. I realise showing bidder names brought its own problems but it was so much easier to police scam behaviour by building solid patterns of activity.

I don't suspect the seller of doing anything wrong. I sent a msg to ask about Twilight and he said he was going to ho double check the conditions to be certain...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 08, 2019, 06:21:59 AM
Meme bidding. A 21st century problem.

It used to be much harder to retract and there were strict rules in play. I am pretty suspicious of baby glory and baby firefly both. Less so on some of the others. I feel something bidder related is going on on those two. But it would be so much better if ebay was as transparent as it used to be. I realise showing bidder names brought its own problems but it was so much easier to police scam behaviour by building solid patterns of activity.

I don't suspect the seller of doing anything wrong. I sent a msg to ask about Twilight and he said he was going to ho double check the conditions to be certain...

Yeah, I don't think the seller would really worry about raising the prices too much (unless they're really greedy)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Strandperle on March 08, 2019, 06:28:03 AM
I am so thankful for all those backcard pictures :) I believe this was a collection, maybe put together before the great days of the internet. That would explain why there are no Nirvanas.

But why on earth does he tag the Brush'n Grows with "LGBTQ"?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 08, 2019, 06:33:09 AM
I had Bouquet as a kid and can confirm she is bi.  As for the others . . . well, headcanon accepted.

Probably they got confused by seeing an acronym like PBnG or BNG.  I know the guy in the video was just a friend of the seller, but I wonder if he helped the seller list them.  He did flub a few words, like when he said a playset was the Satan Slipper Sweet Shoppe.  Maybe dyslexic?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PoserBeachball on March 08, 2019, 07:35:27 AM
  He did flub a few words, like when he said a playset was the Satan Slipper Sweet Shoppe. 

Now wouldn't that be a typo-and-a-half if that was actually on the box!!!!!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 08, 2019, 07:51:55 AM
It could come with a special edition devil pony.  Which would definitely be a BBE.  :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 08, 2019, 08:15:24 AM
It could come with a special edition devil pony.  Which would definitely be a BBE.  :P
:lmao:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 08, 2019, 10:03:34 AM
Typos ftw. That would be an amazing one. Though you'd think when they were typing it they'd be like, wow, that eighties "girl's toy" is pretty hardcore...

Though I guess there is the Rainbow of Darkness...

Moving on...

LGBTQ+ is more random but I guess maybe a: to pick up search hits or b: is MLP now a flagship toy for the community because of the rainbow? (Or LM's version, that's fine too). I had legit not noticed that at all till now.

On another note, it's interesting to see that even with the retros there's still interest in the MOC versions of ponies like Glory, etc. I always notice when Glory and Medley come up MOC (and they don't often, and it's usually the y2 one when they do), but this is the first time I've seen ponies from that set listed at reasonable start prices since the retros happened.

Weirdly Braided Beauty is super nostalgic for me. Mine came in a US box from Woolworths, and looking at her on auction I'm like...yep. That's it.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Eowynd on March 09, 2019, 06:03:02 AM
Seems to be having shill bidding on these... Baby Firefly is an exemple lol
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: maycrestmom on March 09, 2019, 07:01:37 AM
I will gladly stand corrected and agree more likely shill bidding...still sucks IMO I don't know much that can be done other than alert the seller to help with blocking and if ebay can check the history

it is really cool to see so many original cards and boxes for the art sake and so much more :-) really neat to read about those memories of remembering when ya got that box in hand the first time

thanks for sharing :-)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 09, 2019, 12:01:24 PM
I have to admit that if my funds weren't so limited right now I'd probably be bidding on a few of these.


I still can't figure out how all of the bubbles and boxed ended up mostly intact if they were just sitting in boxes.


I have a friend that isn't in to ponies at all but when she saw my pic of Basic Fun Moondancer she was really exicted and wanted me to help her get one. I could see her bidding on the MOC Moondancer because Moondancer is the only pony she wants.




Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 09, 2019, 04:46:48 PM
I have to admit that if my funds weren't so limited right now I'd probably be bidding on a few of these.


I still can't figure out how all of the bubbles and boxed ended up mostly intact if they were just sitting in boxes.


I have a friend that isn't in to ponies at all but when she saw my pic of Basic Fun Moondancer she was really exicted and wanted me to help her get one. I could see her bidding on the MOC Moondancer because Moondancer is the only pony she wants.




Ponyfan


It is possible to stack them. I speak of experience, some of mine have been unsuitably stacked in the past due to space without any damage occuring. But I have them much better organised now and with bubblewrap and in smaller doll boxes so they're not all pressed together like they were before. I think it's more of a miracle the glue didn't dry out on more of them. And they aren't more yellowed. Some of them are very clean looking.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: toyjunky on March 09, 2019, 09:44:47 PM
OMG.......I think I might cry.......that is so amazing to see something like that. Almost unimaginable to see so many MIB G1 ponies and playsets.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: plushroo on March 10, 2019, 09:48:40 AM
I'd die if I came across a storage locker like that, lol! Why does it seem all the good pony loot is found on the west coast US if Hasbro is on east coast? Just something I've noticed over the years.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 10, 2019, 01:24:39 PM
I'd die if I came across a storage locker like that, lol! Why does it seem all the good pony loot is found on the west coast US if Hasbro is on east coast? Just something I've noticed over the years.

Why can't some of it show up in the UK o.o *puppy eyes* xD

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 10, 2019, 06:50:53 PM
I used to stack my MOCs, back when I had a lot and couldn't display them all.  They actually stack very nicely if you alternate them.  Like, if you put Twilight in the Tupperware with her feet pointing south, then you put Moondancer in, upside down compared to Twilight, with her legs pointing north.  I hope this makes sense . . .
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 10, 2019, 07:50:39 PM
I have to admit that if my funds weren't so limited right now I'd probably be bidding on a few of these.


I still can't figure out how all of the bubbles and boxed ended up mostly intact if they were just sitting in boxes.


I have a friend that isn't in to ponies at all but when she saw my pic of Basic Fun Moondancer she was really exicted and wanted me to help her get one. I could see her bidding on the MOC Moondancer because Moondancer is the only pony she wants.




Ponyfan


It is possible to stack them. I speak of experience, some of mine have been unsuitably stacked in the past due to space without any damage occuring. But I have them much better organised now and with bubblewrap and in smaller doll boxes so they're not all pressed together like they were before. I think it's more of a miracle the glue didn't dry out on more of them. And they aren't more yellowed. Some of them are very clean looking.






I used to stack my MOCs, back when I had a lot and couldn't display them all.  They actually stack very nicely if you alternate them.  Like, if you put Twilight in the Tupperware with her feet pointing south, then you put Moondancer in, upside down compared to Twilight, with her legs pointing north.  I hope this makes sense . . .




I didn't know you could stack them and not damage them. :) That's good to know if I'm ever lucky enough to add more MOC G1s to my collection.  I keep MOC Blueberry Baskets stored flat in opened box where she fits nicely and the top of the box doesn't touch her bubble.


LadyMoondancer, that makes sense.:)



Wow, Sweet Scoops is up to $1500



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 10, 2019, 11:11:13 PM
Yowzer! Someone must be remortgaging their house!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 11, 2019, 12:22:26 AM
Psst friends, I need help with gauging a fair price (especially if this seller is gonna list them) for MIB/MOC ponies! I'm looking for Bridal Beauty, Pony Bride, Rosy Love, Gardenglow, Flower Burst, Dainty and Flower Dream!

Also the listing quantity has gone down from 90 to 62 (so 28 listings have ended) so has anybody on here managed to buy something from them? (Also Sweet Scoops is over $2000 in Australian coin)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Minty_Magic on March 11, 2019, 02:05:34 AM
I really have no idea about fair prices, I’m not much of a MIB/MOC collector. I am keeping an eye on the auctions though, I kind of want to buy one to say I got a piece of this amazing collection! Not sure if I’ll actually be able to afford anything though. I’m not picky as to who Imbid on if I do bid. :P

It is funny to me that baby firefly is currently more than sweet scoops! :lol: if it’s not a shill bidder or some sort of scam, someone reeeaalllyy wants her!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 11, 2019, 02:43:47 AM
Wow, just totted-up the $$$ from the ponies SOLD so far, a few grand earned there!  :blink: :faint:
Then, looking at the ones still left to go... oh my!!!!  :lol:

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 11, 2019, 03:19:48 AM
I haven't looked at the end prices but I would suggest not using this as a gauge for mip prices!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 11, 2019, 04:22:48 AM
I haven't looked at the end prices but I would suggest not using this as a gauge for mip prices!

Not all of the prices are going to be crazy. But as of right now, it is a gauge of demand, and that's what someone wanted to pay.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 11, 2019, 04:47:08 AM
I haven't looked at the end prices but I would suggest not using this as a gauge for mip prices!

Not all of the prices are going to be crazy. But as of right now, it is a gauge of demand, and that's what someone wanted to pay.

That's why I said not to use it as a gauge. Because this scenario is a one off. It's impossible to value based on something like this, high OR low. I never said anything at all about them all going much higher. More likely some will go out of the ballpark and others will not reach their usual value because of distractions and people deciding what they can afford to bid on.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 11, 2019, 05:40:40 AM
I haven't looked at the end prices but I would suggest not using this as a gauge for mip prices!

Not all of the prices are going to be crazy. But as of right now, it is a gauge of demand, and that's what someone wanted to pay.

That's why I said not to use it as a gauge. Because this scenario is a one off. It's impossible to value based on something like this, high OR low. I never said anything at all about them all going much higher. More likely some will go out of the ballpark and others will not reach their usual value because of distractions and people deciding what they can afford to bid on.


When I said crazy, I was referring to the obvious baby firefly isn't worth $2,000. But the other ones that have ended aren't too outlandish imho.

Like all items, a pony is only worth what people want to pay for it.

Also flooding the market like this is going to keep some of the prices lower potentially. Those who are interested in buying MIB/MOC aren't going to be able to afford all of these in one go.

ETA: it seems like we agree tho. Just worded a different way.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 11, 2019, 05:43:53 AM
I haven't looked at the end prices but I would suggest not using this as a gauge for mip prices!

Not all of the prices are going to be crazy. But as of right now, it is a gauge of demand, and that's what someone wanted to pay.

That's why I said not to use it as a gauge. Because this scenario is a one off. It's impossible to value based on something like this, high OR low. I never said anything at all about them all going much higher. More likely some will go out of the ballpark and others will not reach their usual value because of distractions and people deciding what they can afford to bid on.


When I said crazy, I was referring to the obvious baby firefly isn't worth $2,000. But the other ones that have ended aren't too outlandish imho.

Like all items, a pony is only worth what people want to pay for it.

Also flooding the market like this is going to keep some of the prices lower potentially. Those who are interested in buying MIB/MOC aren't going to be able to afford all of these in one go.

So nobody atm can give a rough estimate?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 11, 2019, 05:47:59 AM
I haven't looked at the end prices but I would suggest not using this as a gauge for mip prices!

Not all of the prices are going to be crazy. But as of right now, it is a gauge of demand, and that's what someone wanted to pay.

That's why I said not to use it as a gauge. Because this scenario is a one off. It's impossible to value based on something like this, high OR low. I never said anything at all about them all going much higher. More likely some will go out of the ballpark and others will not reach their usual value because of distractions and people deciding what they can afford to bid on.


When I said crazy, I was referring to the obvious baby firefly isn't worth $2,000. But the other ones that have ended aren't too outlandish imho.

Like all items, a pony is only worth what people want to pay for it.

Also flooding the market like this is going to keep some of the prices lower potentially. Those who are interested in buying MIB/MOC aren't going to be able to afford all of these in one go.

So nobody atm can give a rough estimate?

As I said. There's a lot of demand -- therefore the prices are going to be higher with these auctions. But that doesn't mean they are going to be off the charts either.

You'll have to make your judgement on what YOU want to pay. Because who knows the next time they are going to pop up for sale.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 11, 2019, 06:22:52 AM
It's really always a case of what you are willing and able to pay. Value is really subjective with pony stuff :/
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Khayman81 on March 11, 2019, 07:16:09 AM
This auction is going off crazy. Some prices are just absurd... Then again I suspect some people are willing to pay 1800 a pony. But still it is kinda weird.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 11, 2019, 09:54:47 AM
It looks like the first batch of the auctions have ended/are ending.  I guess now we'll find out it the crazy prices were due to a bidding war or something else. 


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 11, 2019, 10:10:24 AM
I’m going to bid on a few but I definitely have a set limit in mind but I think most of the auctions are going to go way out of my reach.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 11, 2019, 10:16:05 AM
With ponies that come up MIB very rarely, it's just really hard to gauge.  With more common MOCs (if a MOC can be common, ha ha) like the TAF ponies or Glory etc, you can kind of see a baseline.  But if it's a once-in-a-blue-moon pony . . . it really just depends how many individuals see it / want it when it's for sale.

Sorry, this is super unhelpful, I know!

I guess an example would be if three people want Pony X very badly and they all bid accordingly, Pony X might sell for $200.  The next time she comes up, she might sell for $100 . . . but NOT because $200 was overpriced for her, but because last time three people were bidding for her, and this time only two people are bidding for her.

If it's a pony you haven't seen around in forever, or maybe ever, in MOC / MIB condition, then if it were me . . . I would just go crazy.  (I mean, without getting irresponsible and spending food or rent money obviously, lol.)  I would stalk that auction on the last day, on the last hour, wait until the literal last minute, and I would put in an absurdly high snipe.

Be sure to snipe (bid in the last minute), it can save you a LOT of money because a lot of people don't accurately gauge how much they're REALLY willing to spend on a pony.  If you bid two hours before the auction ends, the other bidders have the chance to hem and haw and justify spending more.  Never give them this opportunity, lol.  Bid in the last minute and drink their bitter tears.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 11, 2019, 11:06:56 AM
Well I’m not sure what that one person is up to but they put a bid in on a NIB pony I’ve been watching since the first time it was listed, was listed a couple of times. They won her on March 24th and now she was just re-listed. Not sure if I can post the picture or not so I won’t. But something is off in my opinion.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 11, 2019, 11:17:53 AM
Quote
  Bid in the last minute and drink their bitter tears.

Best advice ever XD XD XD XD XD
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 11, 2019, 11:26:32 AM
Be sure to snipe (bid in the last minute), it can save you a LOT of money because a lot of people don't accurately gauge how much they're REALLY willing to spend on a pony.  If you bid two hours before the auction ends, the other bidders have the chance to hem and haw and justify spending more.  Never give them this opportunity, lol.  Bid in the last minute and drink their bitter tears.

I'd like to add on, just because someone snipes, doesn't mean they will win. Highest bid wins. So, while this is a good strategy, it doesn't always win auctions (on board with everything until "drink their bitter tears" because those tears can be your own).
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Khayman81 on March 11, 2019, 11:35:44 AM
I love the last 5 sec bids. And I don't cry if I lose them cause I always bid at that moment the maximum amount I consider the pony costs. So if I lose it is just fair for me. But I reckon that it has saved me a lot of money. That is a great advice.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 11, 2019, 11:49:09 AM
I love the last 5 sec bids. And I don't cry if I lose them cause I always bid at that moment the maximum amount I consider the pony costs. So if I lose it is just fair for me. But I reckon that it has saved me a lot of money. That is a great advice.

Exactly! If your max is £250 and it goes for over that then...that’s fair enough otherwise you’d just keep going and going. And their top bid could be £400+ Which if they’re willing to pay - go for it! But my max bids really are my max bids. They’re not to block other people out of bidding or drive it up to crazy prices, otherwise you could end up paying wayyyy more than you can afford.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 11, 2019, 01:00:44 PM
Oh yeah, you can totally lose when you snipe.  You really REALLY have to grill yourself on "what's the max am I willing to spend on this--really?"  I do find it less stressful than 'regular' bidding, though, even when I lose.

Another way to figure out your 'true maximum bid' is:  "Would I pay this at a flea market?"  Because that takes "would OTHER people pay it?" out of the equation. Pretend you see the pony in that situation and the price isn't some $5 bargain, but is expensive.  How expensive would it have to be before you walked away and left her there in real life?  Hope this mental exercise helps a little. :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Pokeyonekenobie on March 11, 2019, 01:25:58 PM
It could come with a special edition devil pony.  Which would definitely be a BBE.  :P

Well now I want to make a custom playset...maybe if we get a retro version of the sweet shoppe...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: aquamarinemolly on March 11, 2019, 01:59:35 PM

But why on earth does he tag the Brush'n Grows with "LGBTQ"?


SAME QUESTION!  :cool:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 11, 2019, 05:14:18 PM
So far there are 2 people buying a majority of these, with some people being able to beat them out or they just aren’t interested in that particular pony. Like holy goodness let someone else have some too lol. Anyone here lucky enough to grab any of them? There’s a group I definitely have my eye on that hasn’t been listed yet, but if this trend keeps happening with 2 crazy buyers I probably won’t have any luck.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 11, 2019, 05:55:07 PM
So far there are 2 people buying a majority of these, with some people being able to beat them out or they just aren’t interested in that particular pony. Like holy goodness let someone else have some too lol. Anyone here lucky enough to grab any of them? There’s a group I definitely have my eye on that hasn’t been listed yet, but if this trend keeps happening with 2 crazy buyers I probably won’t have any luck.

ETA: As of sunblossom:

So.
There's 25 unique winners (as of when I was bored and checked).

20 people have won 1 auction.
2 people won 4 auctions
2 people won 3 auctions

and our two heavy hitters.
17 auctions  -- tends to snipe in last few seconds, so that's believable.

and 15 auctions <-- and that is the one I'm kinda eh about because of firefly and bidding on SO many, very oddly, and the current winning totaling up to $5,507ish. ( obviously not including still live auctions like 1,998 for sweet scoops or other auctions with a current high bid.).

I may have missed something along the way. I'm thinking theres troll bidding and it has me annoyed.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Shaymin568 on March 11, 2019, 07:22:30 PM
Just found the Ebay listings! Holy moly are the photos of the organized collection stunning! I'm waiting for the next set of listings to go up...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 11, 2019, 07:23:24 PM
So far there are 2 people buying a majority of these, with some people being able to beat them out or they just aren’t interested in that particular pony. Like holy goodness let someone else have some too lol. Anyone here lucky enough to grab any of them? There’s a group I definitely have my eye on that hasn’t been listed yet, but if this trend keeps happening with 2 crazy buyers I probably won’t have any luck.

So.
There's 24 unique winners (as of when I was bored and checked).

19 people have won 1 auction.
2 people won 4 auctions
1 person won 3 auctions

and our two heavy hitters.
15 auctions  -- tends to snipe in last few seconds, so that's believable.

and 12 auctions <-- and that is the one I'm kinda eh about because of firefly and bidding on SO many, very oddly, and the current winning totaling up to $5,111ish. ( obviously not including still live auctions like 1,575 for sweet scoops or other auctions with a current high bid.).


I'm trying to believe that person just really wants MIB Baby Firefly and MIP Sweet Scoops really bad but I also think the bidding amounts aren't normal and find the fact that they're bidding on so many auctions at once a little suspicious. Sweet Scoops is up to almost $2000 now.



Ponyfan

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 11, 2019, 09:14:22 PM
I'm trying to believe that person just really wants MIB Baby Firefly and MIP Sweet Scoops really bad but I also think the bidding amounts aren't normal and find the fact that they're bidding on so many auctions at once a little suspicious. Sweet Scoops is up to almost $2000 now.



Ponyfan



Yeah, it'd odd. I've seen people suggest it could be shill bidding, but I don't think that's the case for a few reasons. The prices of Baby Moondancer and Baby Firefly, for example. If this p***i bidder was the seller trying to raise the prices to make money, they wouldn't bid prices so high to where no one else would be willing to bid higher than them, since then their item will not sell. It feels like this is a troll who is just determined to place bids high enough to where nobody else is able to outbid them. Either they do not intend on paying for these ponies, or alternatively they're.. super rich and are somehow able to afford these. But it does feel like this is an outside person who is determined to not let other people have a chance to win.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 11, 2019, 09:41:26 PM
I'm trying to believe that person just really wants MIB Baby Firefly and MIP Sweet Scoops really bad but I also think the bidding amounts aren't normal and find the fact that they're bidding on so many auctions at once a little suspicious. Sweet Scoops is up to almost $2000 now.



Ponyfan



Yeah, it'd odd. I've seen people suggest it could be shill bidding, but I don't think that's the case for a few reasons. The prices of Baby Moondancer and Baby Firefly, for example. If this p***i bidder was the seller trying to raise the prices to make money, they wouldn't bid prices so high to where no one else would be willing to bid higher than them, since then their item will not sell. It feels like this is a troll who is just determined to place bids high enough to where nobody else is able to outbid them. Either they do not intend on paying for these ponies, or alternatively they're.. super rich and are somehow able to afford these. But it does feel like this is an outside person who is determined to not let other people have a chance to win.

Yeah, I agree with you. Either the seller is gonna block the bidder, report them or just relist the ponies they bidded on or offer them to the second highest offer.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 12, 2019, 12:23:24 AM
I missed out on two last night. I think someone has a sniper app set on them.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 12, 2019, 01:30:00 AM
You never know, it could even be someone from Hasbro who may have mislaid their original from their archives and need it to complete their set?

A bit like LEGO keeping a number of each set they make every year in their archive store.

I dunno!  :wonder:

But they seem desperate to have her MIB!

It could also be an eccentric lottery winner!  :lol:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 12, 2019, 01:57:53 AM
I missed out on two last night. I think someone has a sniper app set on them.

I know they exist, but are they allowed and if so, what are they and where can I find them?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Baby-Sweety on March 12, 2019, 04:15:57 AM
I'm trying to believe that person just really wants MIB Baby Firefly and MIP Sweet Scoops really bad but I also think the bidding amounts aren't normal and find the fact that they're bidding on so many auctions at once a little suspicious. Sweet Scoops is up to almost $2000 now.



Ponyfan



Yeah, it'd odd. I've seen people suggest it could be shill bidding, but I don't think that's the case for a few reasons. The prices of Baby Moondancer and Baby Firefly, for example. If this p***i bidder was the seller trying to raise the prices to make money, they wouldn't bid prices so high to where no one else would be willing to bid higher than them, since then their item will not sell. It feels like this is a troll who is just determined to place bids high enough to where nobody else is able to outbid them. Either they do not intend on paying for these ponies, or alternatively they're.. super rich and are somehow able to afford these. But it does feel like this is an outside person who is determined to not let other people have a chance to win.

Yeah, I agree with you. Either the seller is gonna block the bidder, report them or just relist the ponies they bidded on or offer them to the second highest offer.

thats exact my thought. - I'm curious how many ponies we will see AGAIN xD  . I bought 4 Ponies -  (amazing magic ) HAHAHA
the rest was ridiculously high -  I sold a Baby Firefly 1-2 weeks ago in a much better condition for $160
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 12, 2019, 04:41:53 AM
I'm trying to believe that person just really wants MIB Baby Firefly and MIP Sweet Scoops really bad but I also think the bidding amounts aren't normal and find the fact that they're bidding on so many auctions at once a little suspicious. Sweet Scoops is up to almost $2000 now.



Ponyfan



Yeah, it'd odd. I've seen people suggest it could be shill bidding, but I don't think that's the case for a few reasons. The prices of Baby Moondancer and Baby Firefly, for example. If this p***i bidder was the seller trying to raise the prices to make money, they wouldn't bid prices so high to where no one else would be willing to bid higher than them, since then their item will not sell. It feels like this is a troll who is just determined to place bids high enough to where nobody else is able to outbid them. Either they do not intend on paying for these ponies, or alternatively they're.. super rich and are somehow able to afford these. But it does feel like this is an outside person who is determined to not let other people have a chance to win.

Yeah, I agree with you. Either the seller is gonna block the bidder, report them or just relist the ponies they bidded on or offer them to the second highest offer.

thats exact my thought. - I'm curious how many ponies we will see AGAIN xD  . I bought 4 Ponies -  (amazing magic ) HAHAHA
the rest was ridiculously high -  I sold a Baby Firefly 1-2 weeks ago in a much better condition for $160

Wait, did you manage to snag 4 of their ponies? If so, which ones?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 12, 2019, 05:52:41 AM
Sidenote, if anyone is bidding on a mint in box (rather than mint on card) item then look closely at the pictures.  Some of the newborn twin sets had ribbons tied around their tails which means they weren't in a sealed box (as ponies weren't sold with ribbons around tails).  I don't think the seller was malicious or trying to scam anyone, I think he just doesn't know a thing about ponies and didn't know / notice. 

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


So I would definitely ask questions (like "is the tape sealed on both sides of the box", "can I get more pictures" etc) if buying a MIB.

The weird thing is the Newborn Twins do look meticulous aside from the ribbons being tied.  Like, usually you would see bits where the bubble was pulled up from the background but not with the Newborn Twins . . . Whoever owned them must have been a talent.  Maybe they pulled the bubble up just a bit from the bottom?  So that the separation would be hidden by the 'outer' box?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 12, 2019, 07:26:40 AM
Nice catch LadyMoondancer! Didn’t even notice that one! I don’t think the seller is up to anything fishy either. When they were first listed I was one of the many people I’m sure that messaged them. Especially since I live here it was crazy to think this was found so close to me, and kinda sad lol, curiosity got the best of me. Seller was very nice and seemed grateful for information. After I found out it wasn’t just a storage locker of ponies, I came to check here and saw the video links. And was just in awe, I live 20 minutes away! Now I don’t know them personally, but I have been to that thrift store, not my favorite, I find better stuff at the one next door. But the owner was always very friendly. And as other people have said, the way the bids are, doesn’t make sense. Just my two cents after talking to them through eBay and finding out I’ve actually talked to them face to face, crazy. It will be interesting to see if any do get re-listed. And if the seller does block them, they could just make another account though. But if the seller changes the rules, like you have to have at least 20 feedback/purchases then other people will have a better chance.

That’s great that some arena members were able to get some!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 12, 2019, 08:38:48 AM
But if the seller changes the rules, like you have to have at least 20 feedback/purchases then other people will have a better chance.

You can't do that on eBay, not is it really fair to others.

As I said, that buyer has racked up $5,000+ in winnings so far, with the potential of $2,000 more. :/ The seller should really be handling that because it isn't fair to any other potential buyers for the prices to inflate like that IF that buyer isn't serious.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 12, 2019, 09:06:26 AM
But if the seller changes the rules, like you have to have at least 20 feedback/purchases then other people will have a better chance.

You can't do that on eBay, not is it really fair to others.

As I said, that buyer has racked up $5,000+ in winnings so far, with the potential of $2,000 more. :/ The seller should really be handling that because it isn't fair to any other potential buyers for the prices to inflate like that IF that buyer isn't serious.

Oh really? I could of sworn in the past I’ve seen things like that in listings where the seller says they will atomically block you if you have less than so many good feedbacks/purchases
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 12, 2019, 09:17:32 AM
But if the seller changes the rules, like you have to have at least 20 feedback/purchases then other people will have a better chance.

You can't do that on eBay, not is it really fair to others.

As I said, that buyer has racked up $5,000+ in winnings so far, with the potential of $2,000 more. :/ The seller should really be handling that because it isn't fair to any other potential buyers for the prices to inflate like that IF that buyer isn't serious.

Oh really? I could of sworn in the past I’ve seen things like that in listings where the seller says they will atomically block you if you have less than so many good feedbacks/purchases

As a setting you can block people with negative feedback. That's specifically what I'm referring

Block able things:
Quote
- Don't have a PayPal account
- Have received 2 Unpaid Item strike(s) within 12 Month(s)
- Have 4 Policy Violation report(s) within 6 Month(s)
- Have a feedback score of -1 or lower

I mean sellers can block whoever they want, but it's going to send flags to retract bids so they can block buyers all Willy nilly

Adding on: a buyer with 100 feedback isn't a better buyer with 10 feedback, honestly.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 12, 2019, 09:33:45 AM
I think there’s a seller function where you can block people with zero feedback to avoid people creating fake accounts being silly and bidding things up when they have no intention of paying. I have blocked buyers for a variety of reasons, it just depends on how much sellers are willing to put up with!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 12, 2019, 09:36:04 AM
But if the seller changes the rules, like you have to have at least 20 feedback/purchases then other people will have a better chance.

You can't do that on eBay, not is it really fair to others.

As I said, that buyer has racked up $5,000+ in winnings so far, with the potential of $2,000 more. :/ The seller should really be handling that because it isn't fair to any other potential buyers for the prices to inflate like that IF that buyer isn't serious.

Oh really? I could of sworn in the past I’ve seen things like that in listings where the seller says they will atomically block you if you have less than so many good feedbacks/purchases

As a setting you can block people with negative feedback. That's specifically what I'm referring

Block able things:
Quote
- Don't have a PayPal account
- Have received 2 Unpaid Item strike(s) within 12 Month(s)
- Have 4 Policy Violation report(s) within 6 Month(s)
- Have a feedback score of -1 or lower

I mean sellers can block whoever they want, but it's going to send flags to retract bids so they can block buyers all Willy nilly

Adding on: a buyer with 100 feedback isn't a better buyer with 10 feedback, honestly.

Oh ok, thanks for the info banditpony and Noasar!

And yes your right, I agree on that. More isn’t always an indication on the buyers character, same with sellers.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 12, 2019, 09:40:54 AM
I think there’s a seller function where you can block people with zero feedback to avoid people creating fake accounts being silly and bidding things up when they have no intention of paying. I have blocked buyers for a variety of reasons, it just depends on how much sellers are willing to put up with!

-1, not 0

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 12, 2019, 10:19:11 AM
You used to be able to block 0 feedback bidders, but not anymore.

The "block bidders with negative feedback" is functionally useless now, because sellers can't leave buyers negative feedback.  It's still on eBay as a legacy thing.

Quote
Have received 2 Unpaid Item strike(s) within 12 Month(s)

This is the most useful of the block options currently, at least it might block some bad bidders.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 12, 2019, 11:09:14 AM
So not to blow details out of the water or anything but...tail ribboned newborn twins seem to be legit.

I got sandcastle and shovels mib in a lot some years back and like you guys assumed they had been out...although there was no sign of anything being disturbed. They cost me around £12 when you broke down the lot price so I didnt think much then. But..Since then I have seen at least 2 others the same way with tail ribbons on the ponies. This is the fourth. I think it is weird. But the chances of four from completely different places having tge exact same tiny detail...makes me think it is original.

And it is always that set.

The auctions I was watching ended while I was teaching. I am quite glad about that as it prevented temptation.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 12, 2019, 11:27:46 AM
Wow, that's good to know, Taffeta!  So maybe they are legit . . . It would explain why the bubble / backdrop of the box didn't have any sign of being opened.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on March 12, 2019, 11:41:17 AM
Yep some newborn twins already have ribbons attached, you'll many examples of both attached and packed when you Google search. I have a set with ribbons attached and can confirm the bubble wasn't removed from the backing /not opened
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 12, 2019, 12:03:20 PM
Wow, that's good to know, Taffeta!  So maybe they are legit . . . It would explain why the bubble / backdrop of the box didn't have any sign of being opened.

For the record, they also exist with the ribbons in the right place too. I have no idea what this means, if anything. But just putting it out there. It's not guaranteed they're legit. But it's possible. And weird.

@SaraMari - do you have it on any other twinsets? I have three of that set MIB in US packaging but I think only SandShov has the ribbons in the tail, the others are in the normal place.

I have never noticed it on any other set of twins. Just that it's this pair again makes me think something weird went on with their packaging or something :/

On the feedback, feedback on ebay is meaningless now if someone is only buying. Because you can't leave honest feedback on bad buyers. You can report them but yeah, like that does any good. The fact that one of those bidders, as banditpony exposed earlier, had 35 retractions in the last 6 months just BLEEDs problem buyer. But they also had over 100 feedback.

I used to be very proud of my feedback being 100% positive because back then you got a neg and it was with you FOREVER. Now it's not. It's just stupid. But that's a whole other rant.

I guess we'll see if the bidder pays up. I would be surprised if they did though.

Congrats to anyone who won ponies :D
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Baby-Sweety on March 12, 2019, 04:30:52 PM
Uhh... hope its really original sealed.
I bought 3 of the twin sets. By my other 2 sets the Ribbon is not at the tail. But i will let you know 😂😉
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 12, 2019, 04:42:55 PM
Uhh... hope its really original sealed.
I bought 3 of the twin sets. By my other 2 sets the Ribbon is not at the tail. But i will let you know 😂😉

:0 Congrats!

Post Merge: March 12, 2019, 04:45:39 PM

3 auctions are due to end within the hour, with sweet scoops ending in 4 hours (approx) and I did message them asking if they would relist any of the items that the trickster win, they responded with it seems like a few.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 12, 2019, 05:32:01 PM
Quote
THIS SALE IS FOR SWEET SCOOPS ONLY!! THE LAST 8 PICS IS JUST A PREVIEW OF THE NEXT BATCH THAT IS STILL TO BE POSTED! THIS IS THE LAST PONY I WILL BE LISTING FOR SALE UNTIL I GET THE FIRST BATCH PACKED AND SHIPPED TO THE NEW OWNERS. PLEASE STAY TUNED TO SEE WHAT'S NEXT. I HONESTLY HAVEN'T LOOKED AT EVERY PIECE IN THE "GLORY CONTAINER". THE PONY COMMUNITY IS D*** GOOD CROWD!! THANKS FOR HANGING!

XD
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 12, 2019, 07:28:43 PM
I didn't know some of the Sandcastles and Shovels sets had been found MIB with their tail ribbons already tied on. It makes me wonder if someone might have been practicing  tying ribbons for some reason and some of them slipped in with their ribbons tied.:)


Quote
THIS SALE IS FOR SWEET SCOOPS ONLY!! THE LAST 8 PICS IS JUST A PREVIEW OF THE NEXT BATCH THAT IS STILL TO BE POSTED! THIS IS THE LAST PONY I WILL BE LISTING FOR SALE UNTIL I GET THE FIRST BATCH PACKED AND SHIPPED TO THE NEW OWNERS. PLEASE STAY TUNED TO SEE WHAT'S NEXT. I HONESTLY HAVEN'T LOOKED AT EVERY PIECE IN THE "GLORY CONTAINER". THE PONY COMMUNITY IS D*** GOOD CROWD!! THANKS FOR HANGING!

XD


I feel that posting the last 8 pictures of the pony stash might be a little misleading if someone doesn't fully read the description that the acution is only for Sweet Scoops.


Sweet Scoops is over $2000 now.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 13, 2019, 12:57:30 AM
Oh wow

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


:faint:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 13, 2019, 01:59:18 AM
Oh wow

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


:faint:

$3661 US = $5184.78 AUD
£2795.30 = $5204.45 AUD

Seems a lot more expensive on the Australian side :p
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 13, 2019, 05:40:58 AM
Honestly $3000 for MIB Sweet Scoops doesn't surprise me that much.  She's one of the rarest mail orders and it's almost impossible to find her loose with her accessories, let alone MIB.  Way rarer than Rapunzel.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 13, 2019, 10:05:39 AM
I see a London seller has just posted Sweet Scoops for £300 start-bid on a very famous auction site, however, I see no accessories.

So if you were one of those who desperately wanted her...  :icecream:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 13, 2019, 10:37:14 AM
Holy cow that's a lot of money!! These sellers are SO LUCKY!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Haruna on March 13, 2019, 11:34:52 AM
Oh wow

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


:faint:
Whoa. Is that a record? Has a single pony (MIB or otherwise!) ever sold for that much before?!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 13, 2019, 11:39:58 AM
Oh wow

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


:faint:
Whoa. Is that a record? Has a single pony (MIB or otherwise!) ever sold for that much before?!

I know some Nirvana's have gone $5,000 and up
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 13, 2019, 01:31:46 PM
Someone on Ebay just listed a MOC sugarberry with that sellers pics and a low buy it now, and their from china. So watch out people
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: blondee1982 on March 13, 2019, 03:00:35 PM
Just chiming in here to say I almost puked when I saw what some of those ponies went for!! I have never seen such high bids on ponies in my life!! I also have never saw that many MIB MOC ponies in one place though lol! I mean that seller would be able to pay cash for a really nice car for all that profit!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 13, 2019, 03:24:24 PM
Someone on Ebay just listed a MOC sugarberry with that sellers pics and a low buy it now, and their from china. So watch out people

Thanks for the warning PrincessTiffy. I hope we don't see more of the seller's pics stolen to sell items.




Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: blondee1982 on March 13, 2019, 04:02:24 PM
Did anyone else see that lot of about 20 ponies that had Diamond dreams and maybe one or two other semi htf ponies that was bid up to over $500? It was ending around the same time as these MOC ponies. I didn't see what it actually went for. It came with a few common incomplete playsets and with some accessories too so my though was huh..maybe there is a cup or comb in there that is worth some crazy amount of money lol. I should have messaged Chip at the time to see what she thought  :lol: I literally know nothing about accessories..I feel like it was ridiculously overpriced for the condition of the actual ponies though...maybe I'm just completely out of the loop on the current prices  :shocked:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 13, 2019, 04:50:59 PM
Did anyone else see that lot of about 20 ponies that had Diamond dreams and maybe one or two other semi htf ponies that was bid up to over $500? It was ending around the same time as these MOC ponies. I didn't see what it actually went for. It came with a few common incomplete playsets and with some accessories too so my though was huh..maybe there is a cup or comb in there that is worth some crazy amount of money lol. I should have messaged Chip at the time to see what she thought  :lol: I literally know nothing about accessories..I feel like it was ridiculously overpriced for the condition of the actual ponies though...maybe I'm just completely out of the loop on the current prices  :shocked:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/My-Little-Pony-G1-Lot-/192846606454?hash=item2ce68db076%3Ag%3A9EEAAOSwz4xcfcUf&nma=true&si=KR5sX7AHVuLE1FOwkFAFtcpY99s%253D&orig_cvip=true&nordt=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557
That?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Haruna on March 13, 2019, 06:50:28 PM
Whoa. Is that a record? Has a single pony (MIB or otherwise)?!

I know some Nirvana's have gone $5,000 and up
Man, $5,000!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 13, 2019, 06:57:22 PM
Whoa. Is that a record? Has a single pony (MIB or otherwise)?!

I know some Nirvana's have gone $5,000 and up
Man, $5,000!

Yeah, there's some Nirvanas on eBay that are like $8000 AUD, like a Greek Moonstone and some others I can't recall.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: blondee1982 on March 13, 2019, 10:17:51 PM
Wow!! That is a huge lot of ponies!! I don't think that was the one I saw, there was definitely not that many... with that being said I think this is the highest I have seen lots going for though in a long time, wonderful for sellers!
Did anyone else see that lot of about 20 ponies that had Diamond dreams and maybe one or two other semi htf ponies that was bid up to over $500? It was ending around the same time as these MOC ponies. I didn't see what it actually went for. It came with a few common incomplete playsets and with some accessories too so my though was huh..maybe there is a cup or comb in there that is worth some crazy amount of money lol. I should have messaged Chip at the time to see what she thought  :lol: I literally know nothing about accessories..I feel like it was ridiculously overpriced for the condition of the actual ponies though...maybe I'm just completely out of the loop on the current prices  :shocked:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/My-Little-Pony-G1-Lot-/192846606454?hash=item2ce68db076%3Ag%3A9EEAAOSwz4xcfcUf&nma=true&si=KR5sX7AHVuLE1FOwkFAFtcpY99s%253D&orig_cvip=true&nordt=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557
That?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 14, 2019, 02:35:15 AM
Wow!! That is a huge lot of ponies!! I don't think that was the one I saw, there was definitely not that many... with that being said I think this is the highest I have seen lots going for though in a long time, wonderful for sellers!

That's the only lot I see over $400 with diamond dreams. Maybe you remember the wrong pony?
(I put in "my little pony" , sold (arranged by end date), and with a price over $400)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: blondee1982 on March 14, 2019, 06:45:24 AM
It is possible! I was pretty tired that morning  :lol: I just remember thinking the one I saw was way too high for ponies with missing tails, haircuts and ink on them. I'm still shocked at some of those MOC bids..unreal! Wish I was rich so I could spends thousands on ponies too!  :biggrin:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 14, 2019, 04:43:41 PM
Someone on Ebay just listed a MOC sugarberry with that sellers pics and a low buy it now, and their from china. So watch out people

Thanks for the warning PrincessTiffy. I hope we don't see more of the seller's pics stolen to sell items.




Ponyfan


Yeah, that's a good heads up. I have experienced that kind of scam before, and it's not fun. Also it should be reported to ebay. Hopefully they'll take it down. It's not the first time that's happened with sellers from China and it's a worrying trend that they've done it with these since it means they have lots of material to work with.

I looked at all the ended prices for the first time just now. Pretty much everything sold for more than it normally would. I wonder what that will do for MIP prices. I hope it just lures out more people listing ponies MIP and doesn't just warp the prices forever, since there's still a lot more to come from these people.

Powder sold for almost $300 which surprised me. I was watching her. I wasn't going to pay even close to that. Mass bidding madness O.o.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 14, 2019, 05:12:45 PM
The only good thing is that when scammers are from China . . . it's kind of obvious they're scammers.  Any G1 item from China is instantly going to make me suspicious, even a loose pony . . . let alone a MOC pony.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 16, 2019, 11:54:38 PM
Heads up, the seller is listing MO MIP Tux n' Tails and MO MIP Mommy and Baby.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 17, 2019, 04:30:59 AM
Heads up, the seller is listing MO MIP Tux n' Tails and MO MIP Mommy and Baby.

Am I the only one who finds that name for the mum and baby really irritating?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: ClosetAvalanche on March 17, 2019, 11:11:19 AM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Barnacle_lady on March 17, 2019, 11:26:22 AM
I think the seller has been spammed with a lot of questions that drives him crazy. Which I can imagine since a lot of people want a piece of this collection. But the question of the time zone puzzles me a bit. It looks like no one can ask with the risk of getting blocked because of that.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 17, 2019, 11:29:59 AM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Yeah, like, how do those non US people dare to bother him during their time zone? Geez! :nuts:

Seems like anything but bidding is reason enough for them to block. They will loose a lot of customers...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 11:54:23 AM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Yeah, like, how do those non US people dare to bother him during their time zone? Geez! :nuts:

Uh, but like it means people in the US can't message him outside that window too. Like I do most of my personal time within the window of 6am-8am-- because it tends to be the only time other people in my house aren't up. And that doesn't jive with his window.

If that's his rules, I think it's easy enough to respect. He's already had to deal with time wasters and people just being nosy. It's a 16 hour window, I'm sure some parts of everyone's timezones and sleep schedules will overlap.

9_9 Although he is an idiot and shouldn't assume people know what time zone he is in.

And while he can't, nor shouldn't drop the addresses of NPB, it's not like our community doesn't share usernames (and names if known scammers) of NPBs as well
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 17, 2019, 12:01:01 PM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Where did you find the new terms? I can't seem to find them (but that may be because I'm on the app)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 12:04:06 PM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Where did you find the new terms? I can't seem to find them (but that may be because I'm on the app)


It's listed on the items that have been listed within the last few hours. It is viewable in the description. (I checked my phone)

Quote
NEW RULES AND WHAT WILL GET YOU BLOCKED!!!!!!!!!!!
DO NOT BID IF YOU HAVE NO INTENTION OF PAYING=BLOCKED!!!!!
DO NOT BID IF YOU CANNOT PAY WITHIN 24 HOURS!=BLOCKED!!!!!!!!!
QUESTIONS THAT READS LIKE NOVEL!!!!=BLOCKED!!! KEEP IT SHORT!
ANY QUESTIONS OF IF I HAVE CERTAIN PONIES!!=BLOCKED!! WAIT TO SEE!!
EMAILS AFTER 10PM AND BEFORE 6AM!! GOOGLE TIME ZONE BEFORE SENDING!=BLOCKED!!!
CONDESCENDING TONE!!!!BLOCKED!!!! BLOCKED!!!! BLOCKED!!!! I DON'T GIVE AF!!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 17, 2019, 12:09:23 PM
When you have a rare product that is in high demand, as seller, you are king; as much as the contact conditions may put folks out, it won't put them off.

Look at it from the seller's p.o.v. they have been bombarded with queries from pony fans from all over the world, their alerts must be buzzing like crazy, yes, good profit is to be made but they have a life too! Imagine all that shipping they have to sort out at the end, adjusting for international pricing and the logistics of shifting them all. I think I would set boundaries too!  :icecream:

White Cap MIB with shell? I'm sure there is a whole bunch of potential buyers who will abide by the stricter conditions + take a punt.  :devious:

Sidenote>
I see the listings seem to be restricted in that you see all of them on the US .com site but only a couple on the .co.uk site.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: StrawberryScoops on March 17, 2019, 12:11:47 PM
The shipping rules look to have been changed as well. When I was viewing from the Canadian version of eBay it only showed two of the rare mail orders. When I looked up the seller on the US eBay I could see quite a few more MIB items. I’m not sure they want to ship outside the US unless it’s an item they think they can make a fortune on :(
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 17, 2019, 12:23:06 PM
Uh, but like it means people in the US can't message him outside that window too. Like I do most of my personal time within the window of 6am-8am-- because it tends to be the only time other people in my house aren't up. And that doesn't jive with his window.

9_9 Although he is an idiot and shouldn't assume people know what time zone he is in.

I know, but people outside America will have it more difficult to send an email. Also, they would have word it in another way and not like they had a tantrum. That only makes drive off potential customers.

This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Where did you find the new terms? I can't seem to find them (but that may be because I'm on the app)

You have to check US eBay, they've listed all the auctions but 2 only within the US.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 12:29:41 PM
Uh, but like it means people in the US can't message him outside that window too. Like I do most of my personal time within the window of 6am-8am-- because it tends to be the only time other people in my house aren't up. And that doesn't jive with his window.

9_9 Although he is an idiot and shouldn't assume people know what time zone he is in.

I know, but people outside America will have it more difficult to send an email. Also, they would have word it in another way and not like they had a tantrum. That only makes drive off potential customers.

I don't see how it is a tantrum to set a rule. He doesn't want to wake up to a bunch of messages. That's fair.

It's a 16 hour window... everyone's schedule should potentially overlap with it for just a hot 5 minute moment to send a message.

Like right now, you are up during this time. So.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 17, 2019, 12:31:39 PM
I can see how he would feel bombarded with questions. And as for asking whether he has x or y pony - he’s right, we should just wait and see. I messaged him about not using the GSP and he was really nice.

I think he is just realising how monumental the task he has ahead of him is! But also, he could make the process a lot quicker if he listed them in lots/bundles but he obviously wants to do it singly to make the most amount of profit. It’s work, it’s his income so if he has to spend 8+ hours a day listing and packing ponies, that’s just what you’ve got to do to keep them dollar bills rolling in! If I was making the money he is from this locker, I’d be doing it gladly with a smile on my face! 

There’s also no need for all the caps. WE GET THE MESSAGE! XD
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 12:35:37 PM
If I was making the money he is from this locker, I’d be doing it gladly with a smile on my face! 

There’s also no need for all the caps. WE GET THE MEASSAGE! XD

NOoooot me. Selling all this stuff on ebay would be a nightmare. I HATE selling ponies to collectors. I'd hire someone to sell it for me.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 17, 2019, 12:41:55 PM
If I was making the money he is from this locker, I’d be doing it gladly with a smile on my face! 

There’s also no need for all the caps. WE GET THE MEASSAGE! XD

NOoooot me. Selling all this stuff on ebay would be a nightmare. I HATE selling ponies to collectors. I'd hire someone to sell it for me.


That’s why you’re not out there buying storage lockers! He’s probably done this dozens of times before but he’s clearly underestimated how passionate the pony community is!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 12:58:40 PM
If I was making the money he is from this locker, I’d be doing it gladly with a smile on my face! 

There’s also no need for all the caps. WE GET THE MEASSAGE! XD

NOoooot me. Selling all this stuff on ebay would be a nightmare. I HATE selling ponies to collectors. I'd hire someone to sell it for me.


That’s why you’re not out there buying storage lockers! He’s probably done this dozens of times before but he’s clearly underestimated how passionate the pony community is!

No I haven't bought a locker, but I have done a side resale hustle for a summer or two. We had a loop of probably 10-15 thriftstores we'd go to, along side multiple flea markets, auctions and estate sales. ).

Ended up with a ton of connections, and my husband took a side job listing for someone who already had stock and an established buy/sell business.

So if I was in that dude's place, I'd hire someone to take pix/ answer questions / and be sweet as can be to the community. :p because I think that'd make more money.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Princess Fizzy on March 17, 2019, 01:53:01 PM
Wow! I don’t think it’s a bad thing for sellers to set rules up front, but I don’t agree with his methods. Also, threatening to publish addresses of NPB is not advisable as it goes against eBay policy.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Perikoala on March 17, 2019, 02:01:44 PM
Uh, but like it means people in the US can't message him outside that window too. Like I do most of my personal time within the window of 6am-8am-- because it tends to be the only time other people in my house aren't up. And that doesn't jive with his window.

9_9 Although he is an idiot and shouldn't assume people know what time zone he is in.

I know, but people outside America will have it more difficult to send an email. Also, they would have word it in another way and not like they had a tantrum. That only makes drive off potential customers.

I don't see how it is a tantrum to set a rule. He doesn't want to wake up to a bunch of messages. That's fair.

It's a 16 hour window... everyone's schedule should potentially overlap with it for just a hot 5 minute moment to send a message.

Like right now, you are up during this time. So.

If you don't see or think its ok that they set these rules in such a rude way and "don't give af". Well, I have nothing else to say.

But if it bothers them so much to receive emails, don't sell on eBay/online. It's that easy. You can't expect the easy way when you're selling to a group of collectors. There are always questions.

I personally don't care for US MOCs and even less with such unprofessional attitude. They only will get less money if they are going to block willy nilly.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: blondee1982 on March 17, 2019, 02:13:20 PM
I agree..I dont give AF is so unprofessional and I dont care how bad I wanted a pony I would not place a single bid! He needs to act like an adult!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on March 17, 2019, 02:22:56 PM
I feel a bit bad for being amused at his reaction, but if you are listing the find of a century you have to expect people to ask a lot of questions and any time you sell things you will be dealing with rude, time wasting and condescending people. No need to become condescending yourself.

I agree it's good to set some ground rules, but blocking for long messages, revealing personal information and using a curse slang is bad business.

I dont really have the money to afford any of these for what they are ending at but I would hesitate to deal with someone so aggressive.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Sunset on March 17, 2019, 02:26:05 PM
I guess I don’t understand the email restriction because can’t he just turn off notifications?  Set his phone on night mode?  Eh, but at this point I’m just a spectator.  :pizza:  I don’t think I’m going to be able to afford anything anyway.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 02:38:55 PM
I guess I don’t understand the email restriction because can’t he just turn off notifications?  Set his phone on night mode?

I think he doesn't want to wake up to 20 questions. It's a weird request IMO, but I don't find it too restrictive.

Everything he said was probably based on everything that happened in the first round.

There are people in this world that TYPE LIKE THIS!! OR THAT?? he's typed in caps this whole time-- it's annoying, and it makes what he's typing look worse. But *shrug*. Is it THAT big of a deal?

ETA:
I guess my opinion is because I know people who type like that and are blunt.. but it's not what it seems. He's obviously been nice in correspondence in the past week. And he's shipped items super fast.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 17, 2019, 03:21:52 PM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Yeah, like, how do those non US people dare to bother him during their time zone? Geez! :nuts:

Seems like anything but bidding is reason enough for them to block. They will loose a lot of customers...


He also said he would stop using gsp...has he?

Such terms also suggest much trolling on the last lot.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 17, 2019, 03:42:22 PM
If people voted with their feet and didn’t bid I’m sure he would soon change his tune once he saw that his attitude affected his sales. Unfortunately, what he is selling is just too good so people will still buy from him, no matter how rude he is.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 17, 2019, 03:55:53 PM
I don’t have the funds to bid on any of these amazing MOC/MIB ponies but I will be an interested observer. :)

I do feel bad for our friends outside of the US that will have trouble messaging the seller during his time window.

I guess the seller got tons of questions asking whether he had certain ponies he was going to list. He could word his message a little more nicely though.

Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 17, 2019, 04:24:18 PM
This sellers new terms is worrying. Release an address of NPBs? Blocked for asking questions between certain times. WTF?

Yeah, like, how do those non US people dare to bother him during their time zone? Geez! :nuts:

Seems like anything but bidding is reason enough for them to block. They will loose a lot of customers...


He also said he would stop using gsp...has he?

Such terms also suggest much trolling on the last lot.

It sounds like some of the listings now do not offer any international shipping based on the comments of not being able to view listings here
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 17, 2019, 05:07:55 PM
I find myself sympathising a bit with this guy. I am imagining he didn't just have messages about what he has to list. This is the kind of scenario where those disgusting people emerge - the ones who send messages saying I'll give you $200 for x pony if you close the auction early. Imagine that x 90 and anyone would flip their lid, right? He did give permission for his pics to be used on Wiki and Chrissytree's site, so it's not like he's hostile. I think he's been overwhelmed. And also been messed about by troll bids.

I think that international would appear in the list of rules if it were actively being blocked. He also said he wasn't going to use GSP again. Two of his auctions have it but the rest don't. Maybe he doesn't know how to add other shipping options if he doesn't usually ship overseas. If he wasn't willing to do that the time zone comment seems redundant. (Giving a clue as to what time zone he is in would help with the Googling though).

He might have opened a new can of worms, because it's easy to find those auctions. Two show up on ebay uk but it's not hard to change .co.uk to .com. I am sure I'm not the only one who browses ebay in both sites through force of habit, so he might get a lot more questions about international shipping.

For the most part it's possible to PM someone in a US timezone from Europe at least without staying up to unsociable hours. So that's not a huge deal, just a bit more info would be nice.

On balance, I think this the fault of the trolling bidders and the disgusting brigade who try to ruin these things for all of us. It casts shade on us as a community, because someone from outside isn't going to know that we're the real collectors and the trolls are trolls - but there we are. Unfortunately this is what happens when you put a video on youtube about something. It's not a good idea since it attracts people other than those who legitimately want to collect the items with the minimum of fuss...

Will be interesting to see if this round goes differently but I suspect Noasar is right and people will pay still for the rarer ones. People will put up with a lot and take risk sometimes for a rare item.

I am also a spectator. I love seeing them but them being US packaged makes it easy to step back and wish everyone else luck :)

(Adore seeing those flutters though <3)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 17, 2019, 09:34:06 PM
About the caps, it's just the way he types.  Yeah, it's a bit annoying but . . . *shrug*  I corresponded with him a bit (just to make sure he was going to send the MOCs in boxes, not bubble mailers--I didn't even bid on anything, just wanted to make sure, ha ha) and he was perfectly nice.  But everything was indeed in caps.

I think what he has, has resulted in him getting a lot of trolls, skeevy bidders, and probably people trying to trick him into selling valuable items for very cheap 'under the table.'  He could have responded better, but . . . I get why he's aggravated.  And he's not even selling them for himself, but for his buddy who bought the storage unit. I imagine, or at least hope, that his friend is giving him a cut of the profits.   But if a friend wanted me to sell a lot like that, I might refuse.  Not sure it's worth the money.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 17, 2019, 09:52:10 PM
Heads up, he's listed 6 new MOC ponies. Baby softsteps, cloud dreamer, baby sweetsteps, pina colada, mainsail and Tootie tails.

Tux n Tails plus Mommy and Baby's returned, as well as first tooth baby bouncy and dance n prance twirler.

Dance n prance player added.

PROM QUEEN PRETTY BELLE AND SWEET SUNDROP LISTED their shipping is over $100 AUD though.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: toyjunky on March 17, 2019, 10:49:51 PM
I think he may be listing them in the evening (or at the moment he is). I am in the same time zone and as I was looking at the auctions that just went up today I am seeing new ones pop up in the listing. As of 10:45pm on 3/17/19 there are 30 auctions now listed from that seller.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 17, 2019, 11:01:55 PM
I think he may be listing them in the evening (or at the moment he is). I am in the same time zone and as I was looking at the auctions that just went up today I am seeing new ones pop up in the listing. As of 10:45pm on 3/17/19 there are 30 auctions now listed from that seller.

Really? I'm only getting 13.

Post Merge: March 17, 2019, 11:14:38 PM

Heads up, he's listed 6 new MOC ponies. Baby softsteps, cloud dreamer, baby sweetsteps, pina colada, mainsail and Tootie tails.

Tux n Tails plus Mommy and Baby's returned, as well as first tooth baby bouncy and dance n prance twirler.

Dance n prance player added.

PROM QUEEN PRETTY BELLE AND SWEET SUNDROP LISTED their shipping is over $100 AUD though.

One listing, two boxes of MLP petite ponies.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: heftysmurf76 on March 17, 2019, 11:17:10 PM

I think that international would appear in the list of rules if it were actively being blocked. He also said he wasn't going to use GSP again. Two of his auctions have it but the rest don't. Maybe he doesn't know how to add other shipping options if he doesn't usually ship overseas. If he wasn't willing to do that the time zone comment seems redundant. (Giving a clue as to what time zone he is in would help with the Googling though).


Ebays system for not willing to ship internationally as a US seller is incredibly complicated, so I'm not surprised some have gotten through. They do NOT make it easy! In fact I would swear they make it more complicated! I have to go over my auctions with a fine tooth comb, I  have my preferences set with an exclusion list and yet somehow people have still managed to buy from me internationally...So I'm not surprised by his frustration, and like you I actually lean toward sympathizing with him overall for this and several other reasons....Still, he could handle his wording a little nicer, but I kinda understand where he's coming from if I'm being honest...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 17, 2019, 11:32:35 PM

I think that international would appear in the list of rules if it were actively being blocked. He also said he wasn't going to use GSP again. Two of his auctions have it but the rest don't. Maybe he doesn't know how to add other shipping options if he doesn't usually ship overseas. If he wasn't willing to do that the time zone comment seems redundant. (Giving a clue as to what time zone he is in would help with the Googling though).


Ebays system for not willing to ship internationally as a US seller is incredibly complicated, so I'm not surprised some have gotten through. They do NOT make it easy! In fact I would swear they make it more complicated! I have to go over my auctions with a fine tooth comb, I  have my preferences set with an exclusion list and yet somehow people have still managed to buy from me internationally...So I'm not surprised by his frustration, and like you I actually lean toward sympathizing with him overall for this and several other reasons....Still, he could handle his wording a little nicer, but I kinda understand where he's coming from if I'm being honest...

The seller made it clear to me that he was willing to ship internationally and that he was going to turn off GSP on the next round of auctions in order to do so without the risk of damage to the items. That's what he told me.

I am not personally a fan of own country only shipping but at the end of the day it's the seller's profit that gets the hit, so it's not really my problem. So long as it isn't coupled with the excuse that "foreigners are bad", which so commonly comes up as an excuse, it's really too much bother to concern over.

What I was suggesting was that he didn't know how to turn on normal shipping options since GSP I think is default often on US auctions. And of course international people will still be able to bid because you can't shut off your items from being seen, even if you don't want to ship overseas. Like I said before, it is literally a matter of changing the url.

With the most recent auctions he's added international shipping, albeit the quotes for some of the boxed ones are ridiculous to the UK ($90ish) so I don't quite know where he got his calculations. Max I have ever paid for 3 MIP ponies in one box with full insurance and tracking was around the $50 mark. I guess that's the max insured rate and it may be that it's a flat rate or includes handling but then again I guess if you really wanted something...? I dunno. But he clearly IS willing to ship overseas. It's just going to cost almost as much as the GSP (but probably more safe). I personally wouldn't pay $90 on shipping one MIP item, but some folk might.

On another note, it's been on my mind for a bit, and this is an extreme circumstance, so the discussion is merited - but I wonder how much this and other similar discussions have also added to the problem he's experienced with messages from people. Since we're discussing things here and then maybe several people go to him with the same issue.

Finally - and this is more a query than anything else because again, this is an exceptional circumstance. But links to live auctions are banned. I am wondering to what extent publicising the items on sale when the seller is known is within the rules of the Arena? I would think that's the same thing as posting the link?

The reason that rule was first brought in was because people were having hidden items posted and they were then being bidded up to a ridiculous level and it got quite nasty because people would do it to spite other people - or people would get upset when an auction they'd been watching was 'found'. It was also annoying because people would post links to auctions they had no intention of bidding on, but if the auction they were watching got posted, they'd get upset and it'd create bad feeling. There were lots of reasons the rule was put in place. That being the case, I wonder how giving the name and the items and so on is any different. We all know with this seller so it seems a bit redundant to not talk about it - but in the general bigger picture this discussion and others like it are probably also adding to the price hike by concentrating everyone's attention on these auctions. And that's not good for any of us...

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 18, 2019, 12:03:03 AM
Hey friends

Does anybody know the dimensions of a boxed Prom Queen Sweetheart sister's box?

Pretty Belle and Sweet Sundrop together results in $200+ for the shipping or $100+ combined isn't really economical, especially with the possibility of paying import fees because perfume. 
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 18, 2019, 12:09:24 AM
Hey friends

Does anybody know the dimensions of a boxed Prom Queen Sweetheart sister's box?

Pretty Belle and Sweet Sundrop together results in $200+ for the shipping or $100+ combined isn't really economical, especially with the possibility of paying import fees because perfume. 

I have ChaCha but I can't measure her since she's not with me in London. However the boxes are not really bigger than other pony boxes, just a weird shape. They're rounded at the front (I think the US bride box is the same?) which I guess makes packing them more annoying. It certainly makes putting them in the cupboard more annoying.

BUT IMO the int'l shipping is hiked over what it probably would be, I think this is a seller taking no chances and putting the max option on posting internationally. Another sign that he's probably not used to shipping overseas, because people who are used to shipping MIP items overseas know you can do better than that rate. I think his quote will put people off.

If your border is like ours, you will be charged regardless. Not because of perfume but because of the value of the pony which will be written on the custom form and will be determined by the end bid price.

Incidentally, the rant about blocking isn't on the newest auctions that have international shipping. What's that about?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: heftysmurf76 on March 18, 2019, 12:17:38 AM


The seller made it clear to me that he was willing to ship internationally and that he was going to turn off GSP on the next round of auctions in order to do so without the risk of damage to the items. That's what he told me.

I am not personally a fan of own country only shipping but at the end of the day it's the seller's profit that gets the hit, so it's not really my problem. So long as it isn't coupled with the excuse that "foreigners are bad", which so commonly comes up as an excuse, it's really too much bother to concern over.

What I was suggesting was that he didn't know how to turn on normal shipping options since GSP I think is default often on US auctions. And of course international people will still be able to bid because you can't shut off your items from being seen, even if you don't want to ship overseas. Like I said before, it is literally a matter of changing the url.
OIC, Well I'm glad he is willing to ship internationally for our fans...

For me personally it is most certainly not a matter of having an attitude of "foreign people are bad" (I have plenty of overseas friends whom I will and have shipped for), Its the hassle of customs forms, the prohibitive cost and the time wasters. For example, when I have agreed to ship overseas in the past, gone to the trouble of getting a quote, only to come back with the rate and get told "nevermind" or simply not get paid. There's just too many factors that make it not worth my time and trouble.  Couple that with what is arguably a much worse service overall (USPS after all is not known for its cooperative attitude in my experience) compared to the services available overseas, and its an easier decision to exclude, rather than open a can of proverbial worms...This is just my experience and opinion though....
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 18, 2019, 12:53:50 AM


The seller made it clear to me that he was willing to ship internationally and that he was going to turn off GSP on the next round of auctions in order to do so without the risk of damage to the items. That's what he told me.

I am not personally a fan of own country only shipping but at the end of the day it's the seller's profit that gets the hit, so it's not really my problem. So long as it isn't coupled with the excuse that "foreigners are bad", which so commonly comes up as an excuse, it's really too much bother to concern over.

What I was suggesting was that he didn't know how to turn on normal shipping options since GSP I think is default often on US auctions. And of course international people will still be able to bid because you can't shut off your items from being seen, even if you don't want to ship overseas. Like I said before, it is literally a matter of changing the url.
OIC, Well I'm glad he is willing to ship internationally for our fans...

For me personally it is most certainly not a matter of having an attitude of "foreign people are bad" (I have plenty of overseas friends whom I will and have shipped for), Its the hassle of customs forms, the prohibitive cost and the time wasters. For example, when I have agreed to ship overseas in the past, gone to the trouble of getting a quote, only to come back with the rate and get told "nevermind" or simply not get paid. There's just too many factors that make it not worth my time and trouble.  Couple that with what is arguably a much worse service overall (USPS after all is not known for its cooperative attitude in my experience) compared to the services available overseas, and its an easier decision to exclude, rather than open a can of proverbial worms...This is just my experience and opinion though....

I think this is probably a discussion for another thread, but basically everything you just said is what offends me about US only shipping.

I never understand why some US sellers believe they have to go through more hassle than anyone overseas does shipping internationally. We do all the same things, plus currency conversion as well. USPS is no more complicated or more unreliable than Royal Mail is, either. I mean, USPS has sent my ponies to Bangladesh before, and Royal Mail has sent them to China, so I'd say they're about the same really.

Also, as buyers, we pay the high shipping costs and the custom fees, so they're our problem, not yours. (Unless you falsify the custom form, of course, which is never advisable).

 I can't imagine you think we never have timewasters for whom we get a quote and then they vanish? I'm sure you don't. And the most trouble I've had over the years, buying and selling, has been with the US. But I tend to assume that's because I have done SO MANY transactions with the US that you're going to get some bad ones. So I just ignore it and move on.

If I do something terrible as a buyer, I expect to be slighted for it. But I don't expect to be slighted because someone in France or Spain or Italy (not even my country!) did something annoying two years ago :/

If someone told you they wouldn't ship to you because they had some hassle calculating shipping to someone in Canada or Mexico you'd probably be aggrieved.

We've ALL had bad experiences at some point but it's way better to judge on behaviour of the individual and not generalise on location.

Next time you buy from overseas, stop and think about the hassle to which your seller is going. You know you're not a timewaster (and so do I!), so you probably assume it's all fine and doesn't count. But the thing is, I also know I'm not a timewaster. I have 20 years of ebay feedback and also feedback here that proves it. Yet some people choose not to ship to me because of my location, not because of my reputation as a buyer, because people like me are 'hassle'.

You wouldn't want to be treated like that...but that's how it is for the rest of us when a seller decides all foreign people are not worth going the extra mile for because one was a waste of time.

So yeah. If you don't want to ship internationally then just don't do it. It's absolutely your choice where you ship to. Just don't make it about overseas hassle and past timewasters, because that's offensive. As a buyer it's easier to accept a US only seller who just doesn't want to ship overseas, rather than one who's blaming all of us for the actions of a few.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: heftysmurf76 on March 18, 2019, 01:33:42 AM
I think this is probably a discussion for another thread, but basically everything you just said is what offends me about US only shipping.

I never understand why some US sellers believe they have to go through more hassle than anyone overseas does shipping internationally. We do all the same things, plus currency conversion as well. USPS is no more complicated or more unreliable than Royal Mail is, either. I mean, USPS has sent my ponies to Bangladesh before, and Royal Mail has sent them to China, so I'd say they're about the same really.

Also, as buyers, we pay the high shipping costs and the custom fees, so they're our problem, not yours. (Unless you falsify the custom form, of course, which is never advisable).

 I can't imagine you think we never have timewasters for whom we get a quote and then they vanish? I'm sure you don't. And the most trouble I've had over the years, buying and selling, has been with the US. But I tend to assume that's because I have done SO MANY transactions with the US that you're going to get some bad ones. So I just ignore it and move on.

If I do something terrible as a buyer, I expect to be slighted for it. But I don't expect to be slighted because someone in France or Spain or Italy (not even my country!) did something annoying two years ago :/

If someone told you they wouldn't ship to you because they had some hassle calculating shipping to someone in Canada or Mexico you'd probably be aggrieved.

We've ALL had bad experiences at some point but it's way better to judge on behaviour of the individual and not generalise on location.

Next time you buy from overseas, stop and think about the hassle to which your seller is going. You know you're not a timewaster (and so do I!), so you probably assume it's all fine and doesn't count. But the thing is, I also know I'm not a timewaster. I have 20 years of ebay feedback and also feedback here that proves it. Yet some people choose not to ship to me because of my location, not because of my reputation as a buyer, because people like me are 'hassle'.

You wouldn't want to be treated like that...but that's how it is for the rest of us when a seller decides all foreign people are not worth going the extra mile for because one was a waste of time.

So yeah. If you don't want to ship internationally then just don't do it. It's absolutely your choice where you ship to. Just don't make it about overseas hassle and past timewasters, because that's offensive. As a buyer it's easier to accept a US only seller who just doesn't want to ship overseas, rather than one who's blaming all of us for the actions of a few.
I'll preface this by saying I am INCREDIBLY grateful for international sellers who are willing to ship overseas to America (etc)...My collection would be so incomplete without help from foreign sellers, and that's not a notion that's lost to me.
I can only base my experiences with USPS on firsthand, and IMO the service is not up to teh same standards as its overseas counterparts. I may be wrong about that, but the experiences I've had even internally/nationally are bad, so I'm basing my opinion on those experiences. Are comparable services in other countries just as bad, if not worse in some cases?, probably, I don't know, i have I've only ever lived in and shipped from North America.

 I've never judged anyone based upon their location and did not insinuate that my bad experiences were any better or worse than anyone elses.
I hope it was clear that everything I said in my second quote above was my opinion only. I iterated that at the end of my paragraph. Bottom line is, its a hassle to me, and not one I am willing to make efforts for random ebay customers. I'm sorry if you feel I insinuated  that the hassle for Americans was any greater, that was not my intention. I think it's a hassle to sell no matter what country you are in and no matter what you are selling. I try to keep my sales as simple and streamlined as possible, and I've been VERY pleased with the results of the streamlining, and didn't ever feel like i "lost" a sale by being exclusive...

One final thing i will note: if t wasn't already obvious, all of this only applies to ebay. I always have exceptions for this and other online communities when it comes to shipping...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Khayman81 on March 18, 2019, 01:47:23 AM


The seller made it clear to me that he was willing to ship internationally and that he was going to turn off GSP on the next round of auctions in order to do so without the risk of damage to the items. That's what he told me.

I am not personally a fan of own country only shipping but at the end of the day it's the seller's profit that gets the hit, so it's not really my problem. So long as it isn't coupled with the excuse that "foreigners are bad", which so commonly comes up as an excuse, it's really too much bother to concern over.

What I was suggesting was that he didn't know how to turn on normal shipping options since GSP I think is default often on US auctions. And of course international people will still be able to bid because you can't shut off your items from being seen, even if you don't want to ship overseas. Like I said before, it is literally a matter of changing the url.
OIC, Well I'm glad he is willing to ship internationally for our fans...

For me personally it is most certainly not a matter of having an attitude of "foreign people are bad" (I have plenty of overseas friends whom I will and have shipped for), Its the hassle of customs forms, the prohibitive cost and the time wasters. For example, when I have agreed to ship overseas in the past, gone to the trouble of getting a quote, only to come back with the rate and get told "nevermind" or simply not get paid. There's just too many factors that make it not worth my time and trouble.  Couple that with what is arguably a much worse service overall (USPS after all is not known for its cooperative attitude in my experience) compared to the services available overseas, and its an easier decision to exclude, rather than open a can of proverbial worms...This is just my experience and opinion though....

I think this is probably a discussion for another thread, but basically everything you just said is what offends me about US only shipping.

I never understand why some US sellers believe they have to go through more hassle than anyone overseas does shipping internationally. We do all the same things, plus currency conversion as well. USPS is no more complicated or more unreliable than Royal Mail is, either. I mean, USPS has sent my ponies to Bangladesh before, and Royal Mail has sent them to China, so I'd say they're about the same really.

Also, as buyers, we pay the high shipping costs and the custom fees, so they're our problem, not yours. (Unless you falsify the custom form, of course, which is never advisable).

 I can't imagine you think we never have timewasters for whom we get a quote and then they vanish? I'm sure you don't. And the most trouble I've had over the years, buying and selling, has been with the US. But I tend to assume that's because I have done SO MANY transactions with the US that you're going to get some bad ones. So I just ignore it and move on.

If I do something terrible as a buyer, I expect to be slighted for it. But I don't expect to be slighted because someone in France or Spain or Italy (not even my country!) did something annoying two years ago :/

If someone told you they wouldn't ship to you because they had some hassle calculating shipping to someone in Canada or Mexico you'd probably be aggrieved.

We've ALL had bad experiences at some point but it's way better to judge on behaviour of the individual and not generalise on location.

Next time you buy from overseas, stop and think about the hassle to which your seller is going. You know you're not a timewaster (and so do I!), so you probably assume it's all fine and doesn't count. But the thing is, I also know I'm not a timewaster. I have 20 years of ebay feedback and also feedback here that proves it. Yet some people choose not to ship to me because of my location, not because of my reputation as a buyer, because people like me are 'hassle'.

You wouldn't want to be treated like that...but that's how it is for the rest of us when a seller decides all foreign people are not worth going the extra mile for because one was a waste of time.

So yeah. If you don't want to ship internationally then just don't do it. It's absolutely your choice where you ship to. Just don't make it about overseas hassle and past timewasters, because that's offensive. As a buyer it's easier to accept a US only seller who just doesn't want to ship overseas, rather than one who's blaming all of us for the actions of a few.
Well said. I get why some people don't want to buy from overseas and it is just a matter of costs. Used to pay less for shipping  if the pony stays in the country. As it has been said if there was not for us sellers and Canadian ones my collection would be very tiny. I had to send a pony this week to the US, fill forms and pay the shipment and it was a bummer yes. But I do it happy because I know the pony I sold is going to a good home. And it is not the first time I have sent ponies to the US. Then again eBay is not very easy with all the procedures for listing. And unless you make a draft to use all the time it can be time wasting. I get that if you list 30 ponies it can consume a lot of time. I did it and it was booooooring. Anyways. Those ponies are great but wayyyyy out of my reach.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 18, 2019, 02:27:59 AM
Been outbid permanently on Pretty Belle, it's like $92 us ($114 something AUD) and I'm sad about that :(
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 18, 2019, 03:28:57 AM
Hey friends

Does anybody know the dimensions of a boxed Prom Queen Sweetheart sister's box?

Pretty Belle and Sweet Sundrop together results in $200+ for the shipping or $100+ combined isn't really economical, especially with the possibility of paying import fees because perfume. 

Just a note, perfume is not legal to ship international.. it's subject to being destroyed by customs.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 18, 2019, 04:41:07 AM
It’s not real perfume though so it shouldn’t be subject to import restrictions. You can call anything Perfume but there’s a bit of a difference between Coco Chanel and half a dried up bottle of kids play ‘perfume’ from the 1980’s. You could mention it if you were being super conscientious but I wouldn’t be worried.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 18, 2019, 04:46:57 AM
Except I've heard stories where toy perfume has been destroyed and/or stopped and never delivered. Customs doesn't always take the time to determine if something is "real" or not. Some kids toys are packaged with "real" perfume, after all (which is what the MLP box claims as well, very boldly on the front)

And I made my comment because:
especially with the possibility of paying import fees because perfume.

If something is that noticeable and not kind of hidden, then it'll get noticed by customs, and won't get through past the US.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 18, 2019, 05:03:26 AM
Except I've heard stories where toy perfume has been destroyed and/or stopped and never delivered. Customs doesn't always take the time to determine if something is "real" or not. Some kids toys are packaged with "real" perfume, after all (which is what the MLP box claims as well, very boldly on the front)

And I made my comment because:
especially with the possibility of paying import fees because perfume.

If something is that noticeable and not kind of hidden, then it'll get noticed by customs, and won't get through past the US.

That's one of my biggest fears, and I'm afraid to ask the dude to remove it incase he freaks out (if I win Sweet Sundrop)

But if worst comes to worst I can pass up on them, the other sweetheart sisters come without perfume so I can bid on them and both bride ponies come without perfume as well.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 18, 2019, 05:26:48 AM
Except I've heard stories where toy perfume has been destroyed and/or stopped and never delivered. Customs doesn't always take the time to determine if something is "real" or not. Some kids toys are packaged with "real" perfume, after all (which is what the MLP box claims as well, very boldly on the front)

And I made my comment because:
especially with the possibility of paying import fees because perfume.

If something is that noticeable and not kind of hidden, then it'll get noticed by customs, and won't get through past the US.

That's one of my biggest fears, and I'm afraid to ask the dude to remove it incase he freaks out (if I win Sweet Sundrop)

But if worst comes to worst I can pass up on them, the other sweetheart sisters come without perfume so I can bid on them and both bride ponies come without perfume as well.

I don't think you have anything to fear. People in this thread have mentioned when they corresponded with him he's been nice.

I would think, the safest thing to do is to ask someone to empty the bottle. And make it clear that there is no perfume being sent. I get it that it ruins the MIB aspect... but I think it's risky otherwise.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 18, 2019, 06:05:37 AM
I'm really going to have to exercise my resistance to bid on these ponies as I'm seeing childhood ponies MOC now or their setmates such as Pina Colada/Hula Hula the ballerina baby and the Magic Message ponies


I never realized that toys with "real perfume" could cause a problem with customs when shipped outside the US. I guess that would apply to all toys with perfume such as Perfume Pretty Barbie, Perfume Dream Beauties etc..

Did anyone else notice that Mommy and Baby MO ponies are listed as Mommy and Baby Beachy Keen? I've never heard the MO baby referred to by that name before.




Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 18, 2019, 06:46:39 AM
The Beachy Keen name was invented by someone. I think Debbie Birge. Which is fine except it's a horrible name. It's not official. I hate it ;) It sounds stupid. Nothing against unofficial names for nameless ponies but that one just makes me cringe.

Re the perfume, that's interesting. I have ChaCHa, like I said. She came from America. I bought her maybe 10 years ago? She's MIB. She still has her perfume. She came through customs just fine. So I never thought of it as a problem.

And what about nail polish? My UK boxed Star Gleamer has nail polish in her package. She's a UK packaged pony but she came from Canada. Again, customs weren't remotely interested in her. Is it a symptom of any particular country that these things get rigorously checked?

As a MIP collector I obviously have big issues with someone opening a package to remove something, whether it be the seller, the buyer or the customs officials. I have thought of trying to track down others from this set MIB but if there's likely to be an issue I won't bother. I'd rather not have them than see MIB ponies that are already scarce desecrated, but that's me.

@heftysmurf, I understand your perspective now. I am fine with anyone not wanting to ship abroad because you personally don't want to. It's up to you. I just resent when the hassle word comes into it because I've had so many people be really rude about me being outside the US over the years.

For the record, this applies to UK only sellers, too - I hold them in the same contempt when they make the same excuses.

As for hassle, hassle is having to have an item shipped to a friend and pay double shipping because the original seller won't ship abroad :/ It happened with a pony recently - the one that went to Bangladesh and Dubai over Christmas - and it basically cost me 2x the pony cost to get her to me and took almost 4 months. That's hassle. And the GSP? That's also hassle.

 In any case, all of it is easier now because you can do so much online. When I started I had to wait for people to send me $US - in CASH, argue with them when they sent me a MO that I couldn't cash, and entirely deal in an alien currency at high risk to transact overseas. As a result going to PO, signing a form and sending a pony after receiving a paypal payment seems pretty easy ;)

...Maybe I'm just getting old...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 18, 2019, 07:11:58 AM
Re the perfume, that's interesting. I have ChaCHa, like I said. She came from America. I bought her maybe 10 years ago? She's MIB. She still has her perfume. She came through customs just fine. So I never thought of it as a problem.

And what about nail polish? My UK boxed Star Gleamer has nail polish in her package. She's a UK packaged pony but she came from Canada. Again, customs weren't remotely interested in her. Is it a symptom of any particular country that these things get rigorously checked?

As a MIP collector I obviously have big issues with someone opening a package to remove something, whether it be the seller, the buyer or the customs officials. I have thought of trying to track down others from this set MIB but if there's likely to be an issue I won't bother. I'd rather not have them than see MIB ponies that are already scarce desecrated, but that's me.

Well, 99% of things will pass through customs because they don't check every item. If it's listed on the custom slip as perfume, it's going to be a red flag...


As for nail polish
Quote
If the nail polish you want to mail is flammable, you are responsible for knowing its flashpoint and toxicity. Flammable nail polishes may be mailed if they are a consumer commodity. Some nail polishes may only be sent by ground transportation and may not be shipped internationally.

And I think the key is that the custom person may or may not take the time to be like "yeah this doesn't have any harmful chemicals". They might just be the type to be like "Nope" and trash it.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on March 18, 2019, 07:22:27 AM
Yeah I am not surprised this seller has been exposed to the CRAY CRAY that is MLP collecting - both the good and bad sides, from what I can see! 
If normally he flips storage units, then he's used to dealing with AS-IS conditions with designer purses and shoes and stereo systems and power tools.... NOT pristine collectibles that are valued for their packaging as well as contents and factory errors.  I can only imagine the implosion of his mobile phone!!!! 
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 18, 2019, 07:44:15 AM
I think the key is that the custom person may or may not take the time to be like "yeah this doesn't have any harmful chemicals". They might just be the type to be like "Nope" and trash it.

I agree.  It's going to be a roll of the dice.  I don't think emptying out the perfume bottle or even removing it really provides much protection when the package is screaming "CONTAINS REEEEEAL PERFUUUUME".  Like, how does the customs worker know the perfume isn't hidden behind the backflap of the box?  How would they know it's already removed?

And let's not forget the mint in box Perfume Puff Palace that Pitney-Bowes confiscated, refused to send to the buyer AND refused to return to the seller because they thought the playset was a real bottle of perfume.

Even within the US, shipping domestically, they always ask you if you're shipping perfume (along with lithium batteries etc) because it's a prohibited item.

I can't think of any particular solution.  It's just a risk for mint in box MLPs that are "perfumey."  Buy at your own risk . . .

Edit:  Upon further thought I'm going to eat my words and say that removing the bottle probably does increase the odds of getting the pony, because I just went to the wiki to refresh my memory on the packaging of that SHS set, and the perfume bottle is sooo prominent and is really obviously a perfume bottle.  I don't think it would guarantee the package arriving safely but it probably would increase the odds.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 18, 2019, 07:50:06 AM
I think the key is that the custom person may or may not take the time to be like "yeah this doesn't have any harmful chemicals". They might just be the type to be like "Nope" and trash it.

I agree.  It's going to be a roll of the dice.  I don't think emptying out the perfume bottle or even removing it really provides much protection when the package is screaming "CONTAINS REEEEEAL PERFUUUUME".  Like, how does the customs worker know the perfume isn't hidden behind the backflap of the box?  How would they know it's already removed?

Oh I agree that box is NOT helpful.
The only thing I could think of is that if contents were removed and there was a hand written note that "this package does not contain any perfume. contents were removed" very securely put right next to the bottle. and as you said, it's still a gamble in the end.

And yes, it's the perfume puff palace story which is like... just proof that people aren't going to care to double check.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 18, 2019, 07:52:27 AM
Friends, I'm only seeing 16 ponies on their eBay via the app and through careful maneuvers via Google Chrome, he's listed 34.

Is this a glitch or some seller blocking certain certain listings?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 18, 2019, 07:57:59 AM
I guess it is like batteries. By law I'm not allowed to post batteries overseas. And our post office ask at the desk if there are batteries, so saying no is lying and that's actively breaking the law. So MIB items with batteries I can't ship overseas because that's the law. I guess I didn't realise perfume could also come into this category.

I will take good care of ChaCha. >.>

@freezetime, I assume you load ebay as ebay.com.au normally, and so your app is probably set up to that? The ones that don't list international shipping won't show up on an international site.

The only way to view them is to view them on ebay.com. On a web browser that's easy, just change the .com.au to .com. But on the app you would probably have to meddle with settings to see them all...

It's not a glitch so much as ebay not making available items to an audience who potentially aren't able to buy them.

Except we can, because it's not hard to load US ebay :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 18, 2019, 09:30:44 AM
I never thought about the nail polish either. I have a Perfume Pretty Barbie that was mailed to me and never thought twice about her perfume being an issue


I'm sorry to hear about the MIB Perfume Puff palace that was confiscated by customs because someone thought it was a giant bottle of perfume. That reminds me of another story It's not exactly MLP related but is related to the dicussion of toys being mistaken for real items.

Spoiler
Someone bought a Barbie doll styling head as a gift and put it in their suticase unwrapped and it showed up on the x-ray machine. When security questioned the person they were asking a lot of strange questions about the styling head until she expalined it was a toy. 



@Taffeta. I agree Beachy Keen doesn't make any sense as a name for the mail order baby.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: heftysmurf76 on March 18, 2019, 12:31:28 PM
@heftysmurf, I understand your perspective now. I am fine with anyone not wanting to ship abroad because you personally don't want to. It's up to you. I just resent when the hassle word comes into it because I've had so many people be really rude about me being outside the US over the years.

For the record, this applies to UK only sellers, too - I hold them in the same contempt when they make the same excuses.

As for hassle, hassle is having to have an item shipped to a friend and pay double shipping because the original seller won't ship abroad :/ It happened with a pony recently - the one that went to Bangladesh and Dubai over Christmas - and it basically cost me 2x the pony cost to get her to me and took almost 4 months. That's hassle. And the GSP? That's also hassle.

 In any case, all of it is easier now because you can do so much online. When I started I had to wait for people to send me $US - in CASH, argue with them when they sent me a MO that I couldn't cash, and entirely deal in an alien currency at high risk to transact overseas. As a result going to PO, signing a form and sending a pony after receiving a paypal payment seems pretty easy ;)

...Maybe I'm just getting old...
I'm glad we cleared that up :D I think I am getting old too, but I'm sure you have comparably LOADS more experience than me selling, especially when it comes to ponies. I will admit that I get easily overwhelmed by forms and procedures, its part of my anxiety issues, so I try to avoid extra complications at all costs...In any case  like I said I do my best when it comes to other close-knit communities and friends for shipping overseas, its random ebay strangers that I'm not keen to go out of my way for...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 18, 2019, 01:26:58 PM
You can also use a VPN blocker to brows eBay US which is what I am doing!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 18, 2019, 07:31:32 PM
I just don't have access to my computer atm, the on/off button is stuck so I have to go through some hoops.

And I might have to retract my bids incase there's no options to get her across (and being blocked) however I'll see who I can call/email to talk about it. Idk who or what but I can still research.

I've messaged UPS about it since they ship to Australia, and on the prohibited items Australia it doesn't seem to mention perfume. So I'm hoping if she can get pass the US border control, she might have an easier time here.

Edit: if I'm understanding correctly, UPS can ship perfume if it has no alcohol in it? Does anyone know if the Prom Queen's perfume has alcohol in it?

Edit edit: they cancelled their Goldilocks auction :/ I was in the lead.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 18, 2019, 09:53:30 PM
Edit edit: they cancelled their Goldilocks auction :/ I was in the lead.

I took a look at their listings and they cancelled... a lot of them. Wonder why?

Edit: Upon clicking "completed listings" on their page to view them, I think they deleted just all of the ones with the rules on what would get people blocked. Maybe they plan on relisting them without that description. Can you not just edit eBay descriptions?

Edit 2: Alright I did some Googling, from what I can gather, you can freely add on to the descriptions of listings, but if a listing has bids on it already, you cannot remove any part of the description you've put there already. My guess is they realized how harsh their description on blocking people sounded and decided to take down the listings with those rules and will probably redo them with their newer description.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 18, 2019, 10:06:09 PM
Edit edit: they cancelled their Goldilocks auction :/ I was in the lead.

I took a look at their listings and they cancelled... a lot of them. Wonder why?

Edit: Upon clicking "completed listings" on their page to view them, I think they deleted just all of the ones with the rules on what would get people blocked. Maybe they plan on relisting them without that description. Can you not just edit eBay descriptions?

Maybe people were complaining about it? Or the original seller (the one who bought the unit) didn't like how he was sounding? Or maybe he's in a much more clear state of mind and regrets writing it like that? Or maybe there were too many faker bidders so they cancelled to start a fresh and block the fakers?

Edit: yeah, that sounds plausible.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: pandabear_chan on March 19, 2019, 01:00:09 AM
Edit edit: they cancelled their Goldilocks auction :/ I was in the lead.

I took a look at their listings and they cancelled... a lot of them. Wonder why?

Edit: Upon clicking "completed listings" on their page to view them, I think they deleted just all of the ones with the rules on what would get people blocked. Maybe they plan on relisting them without that description. Can you not just edit eBay descriptions?

Maybe people were complaining about it? Or the original seller (the one who bought the unit) didn't like how he was sounding? Or maybe he's in a much more clear state of mind and regrets writing it like that? Or maybe there were too many faker bidders so they cancelled to start a fresh and block the fakers?

Edit: yeah, that sounds plausible.

From my experiences at a German platform like Goodwill I know that people are very fast when it comes to complaining at something. So they maybe messaged ebay telling the rules of the seller are not correct and ebay forced him to take it down an relist it. Just my 2 cents.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 19, 2019, 02:14:28 AM
I'm sure they got taken down because of the threat to post people's addresses. Quite against TOS.

I just don't have access to my computer atm, the on/off button is stuck so I have to go through some hoops.

I've messaged UPS about it since they ship to Australia, and on the prohibited items Australia it doesn't seem to mention perfume. So I'm hoping if she can get pass the US border control, she might have an easier time here.

Edit: if I'm understanding correctly, UPS can ship perfume if it has no alcohol in it? Does anyone know if the Prom Queen's perfume has alcohol in it?


https://www.ups.com/us/en/services/knowledge-center/article.page?name=ups-expands-dangerous-goods-shipping-options&kid=aa3942f7

(And as I mentioned.. it's not really about what's there, it's more so customs not taking the time to look at it other then "that's perfume". But how would they know that contents? )
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 19, 2019, 02:26:15 AM
I'm sure they got taken down because of the threat to post people's addresses. Quite against TOS.

I just don't have access to my computer atm, the on/off button is stuck so I have to go through some hoops.

I've messaged UPS about it since they ship to Australia, and on the prohibited items Australia it doesn't seem to mention perfume. So I'm hoping if she can get pass the US border control, she might have an easier time here.

Edit: if I'm understanding correctly, UPS can ship perfume if it has no alcohol in it? Does anyone know if the Prom Queen's perfume has alcohol in it?


https://www.ups.com/us/en/services/knowledge-center/article.page?name=ups-expands-dangerous-goods-shipping-options&kid=aa3942f7

Ah, thank you. It seems like shipping dangerous goods from the US to Australia is a no go, I do however have some relatives in Norway and Scotland. I might ask my family about the relatives and get in contact with them.

Edit: I researched a bit and I'd have to label it "contains perfume" get special clearances, ect.

Late night edit: I talked with family and friends, general consensus is it could get outside of the us but it couldn't get inside on Australia's end. She'd be disposed of with no care.

So unless I visit the US and find another one of her there, it's practically impossible.

The only possible thing would be is if I ship it to someone in the US, they take it with them on a plane from US to Australia then either meet up with me or then mail it from their location to mine.

So I'm not able to take in Sweet Sundrop, but it's not the end of the world (now I just hope someone outbids me so I don't have to end up blocked)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Avea2006 on March 19, 2019, 11:07:07 AM
LOL he simply listed MIP Rapunzel as QUEEN. I mean, I guess it is fitting  :lol:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: tictactoe_kf on March 19, 2019, 11:25:54 AM
LOL he simply listed MIP Rapunzel as QUEEN. I mean, I guess it is fitting  :lol:

I saw that too! I actually messaged him to let him know that he might want to include her name in his listing (and explained that she's super rare and sought after). Either way, she's going to sell for a ridiculous amount I'm sure.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 19, 2019, 11:30:54 AM
LOL he simply listed MIP Rapunzel as QUEEN. I mean, I guess it is fitting  :lol:

I saw that too! I actually messaged him to let him know that he might want to include her name in his listing (and explained that she's super rare and sought after). Either way, she's going to sell for a ridiculous amount I'm sure.

I'm sure he knows already.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 19, 2019, 11:36:09 AM
LOL he simply listed MIP Rapunzel as QUEEN. I mean, I guess it is fitting  :lol:

I saw that too! I actually messaged him to let him know that he might want to include her name in his listing (and explained that she's super rare and sought after). Either way, she's going to sell for a ridiculous amount I'm sure.

With discussions like this and the attention the last wave got, I imagine people will find her.

It's been a long time since there was last a MIP Punzie on ebay. Dread to think how that's going to end up.

...And there's Sugarcake. *dies*

Although actually I don't like things mint in bag. Cards are pretty. SO are boxes. Bags are annoying. So I'll just remind myself that she's so sealed and thus I really am NOT interested.

There are still eight or nine auctions missing for me when I load on co.uk but they show up on .com.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 19, 2019, 11:47:42 AM

Although actually I don't like things mint in bag. Cards are pretty. SO are boxes. Bags are annoying. So I'll just remind myself that she's so sealed and thus I really am NOT interested.


I also don't like Mint in Bag.

I can't imagine how it could be nicely displayed.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 19, 2019, 01:24:11 PM
I'm not very interested in mint in bag ponies, either. They're kinda ugly? While on the other hand, boxes and cards are just so beautiful...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 19, 2019, 02:44:48 PM
I'm not very interested in mint in bag ponies, either. They're kinda ugly? While on the other hand, boxes and cards are just so beautiful...

I guess it's a way to know for sure you have a pristine pony with the right accessories. But yeah. I have a baby Nightcap who is sealed in bag (it seems to be a UK thing) and I've left her like that because I don't open MIP and it's weird she's in bag when she wasn't sold that way originally, but seriously, it's annoying trying to store her.

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 19, 2019, 03:16:08 PM
WOW MIB Rapunzel is already over $400. I wonder how high she'll go?


I also don't like mint in bag toys unless they're Happy Meal toys.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Pokeyonekenobie on March 19, 2019, 04:17:52 PM
As pretty as these all are, I don't think I could ever bring myself to buy any original G1s still in the box.  Partially because of the price but mostly because I wouldn't be able to stand them being trapped in there and I would have to free them.  So it's just better if I don't.   :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: toyjunky on March 19, 2019, 07:28:59 PM
As pretty as these all are, I don't think I could ever bring myself to buy any original G1s still in the box.  Partially because of the price but mostly because I wouldn't be able to stand them being trapped in there and I would have to free them.  So it's just better if I don't.   :P

I agree and would have the same problem. Must free the pony..... but it is fun to look at all those MIB ponies and the variety of box art and packaging.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Eighties_Otaku on March 20, 2019, 12:26:17 AM
I've never seen anything like this O_O Is someone keeping track of what ones are were there? Or is this actually the whole set?
I might want to bid, but I live in Canada and the shipping is crazy. I would want to email about that, but I might get banned?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 20, 2019, 01:33:15 AM
I've never seen anything like this O_O Is someone keeping track of what ones are were there? Or is this actually the whole set?
I might want to bid, but I live in Canada and the shipping is crazy. I would want to email about that, but I might get banned?

You aren't going to be banned for asking about shipping.

He was asking people not to send him irrelevant long winded posts,.or be general time wasters.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on March 20, 2019, 10:42:52 AM
I've been keeping records of which ones are coming up - I like to keep info like the price labels :) So I've got an excel file going.

I don't think I posted here but the first lot of auctions went for $23,595! of course I don't know about non-paying bidders but that figure is the hammer price.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 20, 2019, 10:50:13 AM
We will probably annoy him less if we pool generally learnt information here.

For what it's worth he combines on shipping, even internationally.

@Chrissytree - your data gathering as ever is awesome. :) But as a record of this kind of unusual event, it's great to have.

That is a crazy amount. But I wonder how much was lost to npb trolls :/ Still, I bet it's a lot more than was paid for the storage unit.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on March 20, 2019, 11:26:38 AM
I'm data obsessive, can't help it :P but I can put it to good use!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 22, 2019, 02:20:02 PM
I'm still amazed by some of the prices these are going for. :wow:


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on March 22, 2019, 05:25:13 PM
It really highlights how few there were,, in comparison to the quantities of toys now...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 22, 2019, 11:58:38 PM
It really highlights how few there were,, in comparison to the quantities of toys now...

I don't think there were few, not really. Given how many exist second hand, and still turn up even this long after the event in some places. Maybe compared with now there'd be fewer, but in general I think there were quite a lot produced.

The prices happen because of the nature of the find and the scarcity of some MIP items. But that's because this wasn't a deliberate collectable, thus in pack items are already rarer. And because a lot of people deboxed when ponies were cheaper in package. And that has an impact on supply and demand now.

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 23, 2019, 07:49:47 PM
Mail Order Mommy and Baby pony are almost $1000 now and the Soft Sleepy Newborns between $400-$500 each.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 24, 2019, 02:29:45 AM
Mail Order Mommy and Baby pony are almost $1000 now and the Soft Sleepy Newborns between $400-$500 each.



Ponyfan

In a sense, though, those aren't really surprising prices. Not like baby Firefly from the last round.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: gullideth on March 24, 2019, 07:02:24 AM
The prices really aren't as unrealistic this time.

I've got my sights on at least one that I am hoping to win, hoping to score at least two this time.  I didn't get any last time.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Gator on March 24, 2019, 11:52:45 AM
Has anyone looked at MIP Satin n Lace?  Description says no discolorations, but in the photos she looks full of possible regrind.  Is it just me?  I'm curious of others opinions because Satin is my army pony, and I'm trying to decide if I want to bid on this MIBag one.  Or, since my birthday is next month, if anyone wants to get her for me that'd be super nice. (Just kidding)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Sunset on March 24, 2019, 03:28:09 PM
Has anyone looked at MIP Satin n Lace?  Description says no discolorations, but in the photos she looks full of possible regrind.  Is it just me?  I'm curious of others opinions because Satin is my army pony, and I'm trying to decide if I want to bid on this MIBag one.  Or, since my birthday is next month, if anyone wants to get her for me that'd be super nice. (Just kidding)

I looked at her and she looks full of regrind to me, too.  Also, it looks like there is a melt mark where she might have been resting on something metal in that hot locker.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 24, 2019, 03:30:30 PM
Has anyone looked at MIP Satin n Lace?  Description says no discolorations, but in the photos she looks full of possible regrind.  Is it just me?  I'm curious of others opinions because Satin is my army pony, and I'm trying to decide if I want to bid on this MIBag one.  Or, since my birthday is next month, if anyone wants to get her for me that'd be super nice. (Just kidding)

Definitely regrind, yes. I think they probably just copy pasted there description to all of their ponies without actually taking a close look at them...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Gator on March 24, 2019, 04:56:01 PM
Thank you guys, I apreciate your help.

I will say, seeing this one, I'm worried about my army.  A year or more ago I posted about how one of my perfect Satin's came out of storage, and she now had this neon pink zit on her body that wasn't there before.  Will time and age eventually ruin all my lovely Satins? :sad: :sad:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 24, 2019, 05:44:20 PM
The way the bag seems to be clinging lovingly to the discoloured areas of plastic makes me think that probably it was sped up by the conditions in the storage unit and the fact she was sealed. Admittedly I only have one lavender Satin and Lace and she's never been in storage, but she has no signs of regrind from being stuck in my cupboard with her sisters for the past 20 years or so.

My cupboard is pretty cold and the doors are never totally shut so there's air circulation...I'm guessing that's a factor though I'm no scientist :/
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 24, 2019, 07:17:07 PM
Thank you guys, I apreciate your help.

I will say, seeing this one, I'm worried about my army.  A year or more ago I posted about how one of my perfect Satin's came out of storage, and she now had this neon pink zit on her body that wasn't there before.  Will time and age eventually ruin all my lovely Satins? :sad: :sad:

The best thing to do is to keep them in an environment where you control the humidity and temperature and light.

But I agree with taffeta, I also think being trapped in plastic accelerated it.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 24, 2019, 10:27:33 PM
Sweet Sundrop sold, I hope to a loving collector.

Edit: I hope there's the two bride and other SHS ponies in the next batch. I think the merch will be the last of the unit lot, maybe with play sets (I think the Satin something play set sold already though)

Edit edit: Pretty Belle also sold.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 25, 2019, 06:47:25 AM
I also see regrind on Satin and Lace. :sad: I think this illustrates that sometimes keeping mail order ponies MIB isn't the best in the long term.  I don't see the same discoloration on Rapunzel though.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 25, 2019, 08:01:59 AM
I don't think there's really any way to prevent regrind.  If it's going to happen, it's going to happen.  I've lived in pretty mild climates with no extremes of hot / cold and my ponies were in a nice airy space, but it didn't prevent Party Time, Quackers, Cloud Puff, and the other usual suspects from developing regrind. :(

Quackers was particularly heartbreaking because originally she was perfect, even had extremely nice hair (which you don't always see on Quackers), but within the space of a few years she developed nasty brownish regrind on half her body.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 25, 2019, 10:09:33 AM
That's true. I didn't mean to say that not keeping them MIB would ensure they wouldn't get regrind just that I think a pony that's prone to regrind might degrade faster if sealed in a plastic bag.

My childhood Skydancer has regrind also and she was always stored in my room. She was the one pony that wasn't packed away with the others when I thought I'd never be in to ponies again and even she has regrind.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: ClosetAvalanche on March 25, 2019, 01:18:03 PM
the soft sleepy newborns went insane. I don't think those are real prices. I got outbid at $800 on the last one i needed :(
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 25, 2019, 01:27:53 PM
the soft sleepy newborns went insane. I don't think those are real prices. I got outbid at $800 on the last one i needed :(

Honestly, it';s been so long since any of those came up MIB, given inflation and rarity and everything, I wouldn't be surprised if their normal rate is now pretty high. Esp. when all three are there which makes it worse.

(Edit to add, ok, just saw exactly where the ended. Perhaps that's a tad much!)

I would say they are rarer than MOC Mimic, though, which still sells for similarly stupid prices.

 but I imagine there are a lot of people who decided it was a once in a lifetime chance to obtain them with all their stuff.

PErsonally I would love just the box for one of those, but I don't need all the rest of it. But those don't ever come up either...

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on March 26, 2019, 03:56:13 PM
The next lot finished for $23,045.46 bringing the total to a little over $47k!
But did some of the pony friends go missing? I can't see them in the completed listings at all even going through the US site. There was definitely a Cha Cha, Cutesaurus and Oakley. I'm also missing MO Sprinkles.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: charlatan on March 26, 2019, 04:14:22 PM
Can’t believe the price of Rapunzel.  Are these being inflated by the story?  So many other cheaper MOC on eBay are not being purchased.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 26, 2019, 04:50:31 PM
The next lot finished for $23,045.46 bringing the total to a little over $47k!
But did some of the pony friends go missing? I can't see them in the completed listings at all even going through the US site. There was definitely a Cha Cha, Cutesaurus and Oakley. I'm also missing MO Sprinkles.

There was a Cha Cha?! I never saw her! I only saw Pretty Belle and Sweet Sundrop! I saw Oakley, the cutesaurus and MO sprinkles!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Princess Fizzy on March 26, 2019, 04:54:44 PM
The next lot finished for $23,045.46 bringing the total to a little over $47k!
But did some of the pony friends go missing? I can't see them in the completed listings at all even going through the US site. There was definitely a Cha Cha, Cutesaurus and Oakley. I'm also missing MO Sprinkles.

Yes, you’re right, but they aren’t always showing up in completed listings for some reason.
Cha Cha went for 196.50
Cutesaurus went for 203.50
Oakley went for 164.83
MO Sprinkles went for 511.99

Thanks for keeping track

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 26, 2019, 06:01:50 PM
The next lot finished for $23,045.46 bringing the total to a little over $47k!
But did some of the pony friends go missing? I can't see them in the completed listings at all even going through the US site. There was definitely a Cha Cha, Cutesaurus and Oakley. I'm also missing MO Sprinkles.

Yes, you’re right, but they aren’t always showing up in completed listings for some reason.
Cha Cha went for 196.50
Cutesaurus went for 203.50
Oakley went for 164.83
MO Sprinkles went for 511.99

Thanks for keeping track

Oh no, does that mean I missed out on more? Does anybody have a pic of the Cha Cha listing?

Edit: I searched through the seller's completed items and didn't stumble upon Cha Cha anywhere!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Princess Fizzy on March 26, 2019, 07:14:49 PM
It’s Cha Cha the Llama not the Prom Queen if that makes you feel better. Here are the ended auction links.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-CHA-CHA-LLAMA-SEALED-G1/123699133548?hash=item1ccd0afc6c:g:Z0kAAOSwlf5cjnmu#vi__app-cvip-panel

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-CUTESAURUS-BRACHIOSAURUS-DINOSAUR-SEALED-G1-/123699119517?nav=SEARCH

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-OAKLEY-MOOSE-PONY-SEALED-/123699117586?nav=SEARCH

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-SPRINKLES-SEALED-G1-/123699123299?nav=SEARCH

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 26, 2019, 07:26:16 PM
It’s Cha Cha the Llama not the Prom Queen if that makes you feel better. Here are the ended auction links.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-CHA-CHA-LLAMA-SEALED-G1/123699133548?hash=item1ccd0afc6c:g:Z0kAAOSwlf5cjnmu#vi__app-cvip-panel

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-CUTESAURUS-BRACHIOSAURUS-DINOSAUR-SEALED-G1-/123699119517?nav=SEARCH

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-OAKLEY-MOOSE-PONY-SEALED-/123699117586?nav=SEARCH

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-SPRINKLES-SEALED-G1-/123699123299?nav=SEARCH

Oh my! Thank you for giving the links! I'm glad it's not Prom Queen Cha Cha (I'd be so sad if I'd miss her entirely)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on March 27, 2019, 12:34:08 AM
I think those prices for Oakley, Cha-Cha etc are very reasonable. Even loose Oakley can be $70+ so congrats to whoever won them.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 27, 2019, 12:56:13 AM
I am surprised Oakly went for less than Cutesaurus.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: NightGliderSA on March 27, 2019, 01:22:23 AM
I have noticed that a few copycat listings are popping up, using the images from this seller. All are Chinese sellers, buy it now and free shipping. With 0 ratings and no other items for sale. And ridiculously low prices. Just be careful.

Rapunzel went for crazy money... some people don't even earn that in a year in SA, with our exchange rate it comes to over R90,000. Are there other MIB Rapunzels around, or is she The Only One?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 27, 2019, 03:48:12 AM
Did I miss something special about Sprinkles? Is she so rare MIB that the price is reasonable for her?


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: bladed on March 27, 2019, 04:09:50 AM
I have noticed that a few copycat listings are popping up, using the images from this seller. All are Chinese sellers, buy it now and free shipping. With 0 ratings and no other items for sale. And ridiculously low prices. Just be careful.

Rapunzel went for crazy money... some people don't even earn that in a year in SA, with our exchange rate it comes to over R90,000. Are there other MIB Rapunzels around, or is she The Only One?
she's the second one i've seen personally - and i've not heard of many more from what i can remember.
Did I miss something special about Sprinkles? Is she so rare MIB that the price is reasonable for her?


Ponyfan
how much did she go for in the end? (wait, just looked up) MO being she's just bagged, right? i guess theres the curiousity of bagged sprinkles...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 27, 2019, 04:13:23 AM
Mo Sprinkles is pink. Like Firefly. She doesn't show up much.

I have seen a few MIP punzies before. But she has the same status quality as Mimic which puts up her price generally.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 27, 2019, 11:12:47 AM
Someone got extremely lucky with Oakly, he can go for more than that loose.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 27, 2019, 04:41:52 PM
Mo Sprinkles is pink. Like Firefly. She doesn't show up much.

I have seen a few MIP punzies before. But she has the same status quality as Mimic which puts up her price generally.


I forgot that MO Sprinkles is pink instead of lavender. :silly: I don't own a Sprinkles.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 27, 2019, 11:31:49 PM
Friends, do you think the previous owner may have some previously unseen prototypes? Or errors?

I personally believe the person was employed by Hasbro in some way, idk exactly what way but a way.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 28, 2019, 01:33:44 AM
Friends, do you think the previous owner may have some previously unseen prototypes? Or errors?

I personally believe the person was employed by Hasbro in some way, idk exactly what way but a way.

I think both are unlikely.

We've seen collections liquidated before with rare or ooak items in - the delaneys and Helen's collections both had these, especially the latter - but thus far and from the storage facility photos this seems like an (admittedly awesome) collection of only US mint in package and loose items.

So the Hasbro possibility...I thought about that right at the start but since that point and seeing ones on ebay with certain issues, I think not so much now. Not just that but the discussion about his time zone rant also made me notice that the seller is, I believe, West Coast. Hasbro in the US is in Rhode Island. A very few rare items have been found in thaty vicinity. It's highly unlikely that they'd have all migrated from RI to a storage locker on the other side of the country.

Of course, if it's an online collector, then there's no precluding them having stuff. But as yet we've seen nothing not American. That suggests if it's a collection, either they collected at the time things were out/very early in proceedings when there were more MIP items around but not so much foreign stuff or other rarer material, or they chose to collect only US stuff and focus on that.

Either way the prices are the most exceptional part of this. Having a lot of MIP items is impressive. And having them all up on ebay like this is highly unusual. But I think that's all it is.

I guess we'll see though what still has to come out of the locker.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 28, 2019, 06:25:40 AM
I am certain this collection of ponies did not come from Hasbro, as a lot of the boxes had store price tags.

Also, Hasbro would not put examples of their toys in a random storage locker.  They'd put them in their company vault.  And the storage locker wasn't even in Rhode Island.

Quote
Of course, if it's an online collector, then there's no precluding them having stuff. But as yet we've seen nothing not American.

I noticed that too!  It adds another layer of mystery.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 28, 2019, 07:52:37 AM
Hey friends! The unit auction person is listing new ponies again! So far are some princesses, happy tails, sea ponies, dream beauties and peek a boo babies.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 28, 2019, 12:18:12 PM
I love the MIB princesses and Dream Beauties. :lovey:


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on March 28, 2019, 02:16:26 PM
The missing ponies are showing up for me again too. So new second round total is $24,798.49. $48,394 so far in total!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 28, 2019, 02:52:12 PM
Aaaww no Windwalker's already pretty high. There goes trying getting one of my grails MIB, haha.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 28, 2019, 07:20:51 PM
Heads up! There's the crib (I will fight for it, until I can't afford it anymore) and the secret surprise ponies!

Post Merge: March 28, 2019, 08:09:50 PM

Edit: they mention a "prince" being the 50th listed pony, twice in the MiB bathtub listing (also fighting for that)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 28, 2019, 09:40:46 PM
Honestly, you'd have a better chance of winning them if you didn't post about them.

Like I realize it's exciting for the community to see what's there, but every auction can only have one winner, you know what I mean?  I once found an auction for a Takara prototype (not on eBay) and you can bet I clutched that information close to my chest and stayed quiet as a monk who'd taken a vow of silence.  (Though I suppose in this case posting about the auctions probably doesn't make too much of a difference in this case because the storage unit lot is already so highly publicized.)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 28, 2019, 10:15:47 PM
Honestly, you'd have a better chance of winning them if you didn't post about them.

Like I realize it's exciting for the community to see what's there, but every auction can only have one winner, you know what I mean?  I once found an auction for a Takara prototype (not on eBay) and you can bet I clutched that information close to my chest and stayed quiet as a monk who'd taken a vow of silence.  (Though I suppose in this case posting about the auctions probably doesn't make too much of a difference in this case because the storage unit lot is already so highly publicized.)

Yeah, I understand, I just like telling people about them but thank you regardless.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: glitterball on March 28, 2019, 10:34:06 PM
The missing ponies are showing up for me again too. So new second round total is $24,798.49. $48,394 so far in total!

Ooh, a nice little earner, eh?  :biggrin:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 01:29:03 AM
Honestly, you'd have a better chance of winning them if you didn't post about them.

Like I realize it's exciting for the community to see what's there, but every auction can only have one winner, you know what I mean?  I once found an auction for a Takara prototype (not on eBay) and you can bet I clutched that information close to my chest and stayed quiet as a monk who'd taken a vow of silence.  (Though I suppose in this case posting about the auctions probably doesn't make too much of a difference in this case because the storage unit lot is already so highly publicized.)

Yeah, I understand, I just like telling people about them but thank you regardless.

I think it's actually borderline breaking the rules to post about them in such specific detail. It's just that this is such an exceptional circumstance that even if you didn't post about it, we'd all still know and be discussing the event somehow.

But as I mentioned before, the posting link rule happened so that we didn't create bad feeling by advertising auctions someone else was watching. Posting the seller, the item name/how to find it is basically the same thing as that. I don't know officially these days if that is against the rules too, I only know the links are - but it's better not to post that kind of detail in general, just as a rule of thumb. This seller, as I said, it's kind of an exception and not discussing it probably isn't going to stop them selling high. But you can also see from the attention and discussion on those auctions the impact it has on price as well.

We've all had a situation whereby we've found something hidden and then someone's posted about it on a forum to 'help people' looking for it. That then annoyed people who were watching that auction because it made it go higher and often was settled by whoever was richest. This is especially an issue with hidden items because it stops being hidden.

A week or so ago there was a lot with MO mum and baby in unmarked in the title. I don't know how high it sold, but even though I know people here are probably looking for them, I would never have posted about it on here, because I don't know how many people here are watching it hoping they might finally be able to afford a rare pony without breaking the bank. (I don't know if anyone here won it, if they did, congrats). I have also had my fair share of hidden auction wins...knowing that this is a community where those won't be posted or signposted by other members is hugely reassuring.

To sum up, it's generally wise to steer away from talking in specifics about live auctions. I admit some of the specifics being posted about auctions (not just these) lately make me uncomfortable. I'm not looking for any of the ponies being mentioned, or I know I can't afford them - but if I was, or I did, I'd be upset that they were being pointed out so someone else could hike the price.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: freezestime on March 29, 2019, 01:46:34 AM
Honestly, you'd have a better chance of winning them if you didn't post about them.

Like I realize it's exciting for the community to see what's there, but every auction can only have one winner, you know what I mean?  I once found an auction for a Takara prototype (not on eBay) and you can bet I clutched that information close to my chest and stayed quiet as a monk who'd taken a vow of silence.  (Though I suppose in this case posting about the auctions probably doesn't make too much of a difference in this case because the storage unit lot is already so highly publicized.)

Yeah, I understand, I just like telling people about them but thank you regardless.

I think it's actually borderline breaking the rules to post about them in such specific detail. It's just that this is such an exceptional circumstance that even if you didn't post about it, we'd all still know and be discussing the event somehow.

But as I mentioned before, the posting link rule happened so that we didn't create bad feeling by advertising auctions someone else was watching. Posting the seller, the item name/how to find it is basically the same thing as that. I don't know officially these days if that is against the rules too, I only know the links are - but it's better not to post that kind of detail in general, just as a rule of thumb. This seller, as I said, it's kind of an exception and not discussing it probably isn't going to stop them selling high. But you can also see from the attention and discussion on those auctions the impact it has on price as well.

We've all had a situation whereby we've found something hidden and then someone's posted about it on a forum to 'help people' looking for it. That then annoyed people who were watching that auction because it made it go higher and often was settled by whoever was richest. This is especially an issue with hidden items because it stops being hidden.

A week or so ago there was a lot with MO mum and baby in unmarked in the title. I don't know how high it sold, but even though I know people here are probably looking for them, I would never have posted about it on here, because I don't know how many people here are watching it hoping they might finally be able to afford a rare pony without breaking the bank. (I don't know if anyone here won it, if they did, congrats). I have also had my fair share of hidden auction wins...knowing that this is a community where those won't be posted or signposted by other members is hugely reassuring.

To sum up, it's generally wise to steer away from talking in specifics about live auctions. I admit some of the specifics being posted about auctions (not just these) lately make me uncomfortable. I'm not looking for any of the ponies being mentioned, or I know I can't afford them - but if I was, or I did, I'd be upset that they were being pointed out so someone else could hike the price.

Oh geez, I didn't actually realize that. I can only say my bad, but I'll take on those words and tone it way down. Cheers.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 02:38:39 AM
Well, I think with this particular set of auctions, it hardly matters, as it's all under such public scrutiny anyway. But probably more people are bidding on these because of all the publicity, youtube video, whatever. The long term impact of that on pricing we have yet to find out I suppose.

Thinking of the price of Rapunzel, and then how it was listed as Queen...although it probably wouldn't have been a hidden auction, it might have taken longer for people to find and might have sold for less if not for all the discussion around the seller's auctions. He benefitted from the fact we're all watching his listed auctions. But if that were the only auction he listed and that was how he listed it, there might be fewer people who noticed it and it might have sold for considerably less.

As a rule of thumb, it's not a bad idea to be cautious in the information you mention during the live run of an auction. Just in case. If a seller has done their job properly in listing the item in the right place with the right information, then they'll make a good sale from it. But I firmly believe if a seller can't be bothered to do the proper research and puts something in a job lot in a bad category with the description "hasbro horses rare", then the person who does the hard work and finds the lot deserves to have a shot at winning it without someone blasting it all over the pony community...it's not our job to advertise for lazy sellers ;)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 29, 2019, 03:38:25 AM
It seems pretty normal for people to mention seller names, or whole auction titles, or describing in a way to easily find.. as in, people have been getting around the "no link" rule for YEARS.

:) OP even mentioned they weren't sure if it was ok to post the seller in the original post. No one said "take it down" then. I actually think it's ok?

Although what I think LadyMoondancer is saying -- is for your OWN benefit, people keep quiet about who they bid on as a strategic plan to not bring hype to a listing.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 03:59:04 AM
It seems pretty normal for people to mention seller names, or whole auction titles, or describing in a way to easily find.. as in, people have been getting around the "no link" rule for YEARS.

Sorry, but no they haven't.  Talking about live auctions within the rules is not the same as trying to get around the rules, and seller names only get posted if an auction is likely a scam.

Quote
:) OP even mentioned they weren't sure if it was ok to post the seller in the original post. No one said "take it down" then. I actually think it's ok?

It's already been said that this is an exceptional circumstance.
Quote
Although what I think LadyMoondancer is saying -- is for your OWN benefit, people keep quiet about who they bid on as a strategic plan to not bring hype to a listing.
Yes, she is.

What I am saying is why the rule happened and what its purpose is.

And now maybe we can go back to the actual topic which is the storage locker ponies and their sales.

...on which note, it is interesting to me that there seem to be some split sets here. I wonder if that is an accident or deliberate, or if they're coming later.

...And I also wonder what the Prince is. They've sold Tux, right? And Rapunzel was Queen. What makes sense as Prince?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 29, 2019, 04:08:05 AM
It seems pretty normal for people to mention seller names, or whole auction titles, or describing in a way to easily find.. as in, people have been getting around the "no link" rule for YEARS.

Sorry, but no they haven't.

Quote
:) OP even mentioned they weren't sure if it was ok to post the seller in the original post. No one said "take it down" then. I actually think it's ok?

It's already been said that this is an exceptional circumstance.

Well. To me, since I've seen other threads get around mentioning the ebay link by mentioning details-- it is a way for people to do it. I rarely see anyone say "not allowed". (But I imagine MORE people just don't post).

And I personally would of had NO idea about these listings if not for this thread. I don't do other social media. So this thread did contribute to the overall hype even if it was being discussed elsewhere. *shrug*

In the end, I don't see how it's different/exempt just because it's big.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 04:18:08 AM
For me personally, I agree in the sense this shouldn't be an exception. I believe very much that the rules are important because I don't want to go back to the free for all arguments that happened before they existed.

For the forum generally, though, common sense tells me that not discussing it somehow would've been more impossible.

In any case, what would probably have happened is that if it was posted when the first auctions ended, then more got added, it would be hard to separate them out. So therefore it kind of became pointless to try.

So yes. Personally I think this thread shouldn't have existed. But I understand why it did exist, and now it does, it seems kind of pointless to insist we all stop talking about what's currently listed.

But it does also give the indication of how publicity impacts price of items. There are arguably other factors as well, but it does help to underscore why posting links and highlighting auctions holds no benefit whatsoever to collectors unless they are selling. Which in itself is perhaps not a bad thing.

I also knew about it from here. I don't use social media either for pony stuff. But I probably also would've found it on ebay myself eventually because I search for MIP items.

I think if it were just the seller listing out of the blue, rather than the whole storage locker story around it, then maybe it would be different.

In any case, I feel sure the mods would rather not moderate a discussion on selling rules, so let's not. Points have been made. Back to the topic at hand.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 29, 2019, 04:43:43 AM
I actually think its more on topic then some of the other discussions in this thread (sniping, thoughts about international shipping unrelated to the listings) because the OP asked about this specific thing in her first post.

I don't see why the mods need to monitor our discussion. We aren't being rude to each other.

I don't have much else to say about it, other then I didn't want the OP to think she did something massively wrong. :/ It would of been closed on page 1 otherwise.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 29, 2019, 05:31:09 AM
I think this thread is fine, I just wanted to point out that if the circumstances were different--like if a seller only listed ONE rare pony and it was mislabeled (say a Rapunzel with the listing title of "Fairy horse queen" and they put it in the wrong eBay category)--then, in THAT case, a thread like this would be a faux pas.  The people who were already watching the auction (and I guarantee, SOMEONE spotted it) would be resentful as they watched their hidden gem shoot up to "typical" Rapunzel prices.  (Which is why live links were banned from the mailing lists and later the various forums.)

I mean, maybe the OP wouldn't have done that anyway, in which case I apologize for my assumption.  I just thought it was worth bringing up.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 05:37:33 AM
I think this thread is fine, I just wanted to point out that if the circumstances were different--like if a seller only listed ONE rare pony and it was mislabeled (say a Rapunzel with the listing title of "Fairy horse queen" and they put it in the wrong eBay category)--then, in THAT case, a thread like this would be a faux pas.  The people who were already watching the auction (and I guarantee, SOMEONE spotted it) would be resentful as they watched their hidden gem shoot up to "typical" Rapunzel prices.  (Which is why live links were banned from the mailing lists and later the various forums.)

I mean, maybe the OP wouldn't have done that anyway, in which case I apologize for my assumption.  I just thought it was worth bringing up.

That was what I was getting at as well. You just put it better than I did :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Baby-Sweety on March 29, 2019, 11:32:05 AM
It’s Cha Cha the Llama not the Prom Queen if that makes you feel better. Here are the ended auction links.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-CHA-CHA-LLAMA-SEALED-G1/123699133548?hash=item1ccd0afc6c:g:Z0kAAOSwlf5cjnmu#vi__app-cvip-panel

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-CUTESAURUS-BRACHIOSAURUS-DINOSAUR-SEALED-G1-/123699119517?nav=SEARCH

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-OAKLEY-MOOSE-PONY-SEALED-/123699117586?nav=SEARCH

https://www.ebay.com/itm/MLP-SPRINKLES-SEALED-G1-/123699123299?nav=SEARCH

Oh my! Thank you for giving the links! I'm glad it's not Prom Queen Cha Cha (I'd be so sad if I'd miss her entirely)
now prom queen Cha Cha is online  ;)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 11:35:46 AM
It's interesting how some of these sets are now getting broken up. I am sure they would do better all sold at the same time.

I miss the days when nobody liked MOC baby sea ponies. The Sea Sparkles are the nicest set. I have a bunch of their cards but only one of them MOC. I'd love to have more but these days everyone loves sea ponies too much :'(
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 29, 2019, 12:06:07 PM
It's interesting how some of these sets are now getting broken up. I am sure they would do better all sold at the same time.

I'm wondering if by the end of this the average prices will be lower. Just in general, it seems like most people don't have money saved up for lots of big purchases and/or don't want to spend $$$ money on ponies.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 29, 2019, 12:25:34 PM
It's interesting how some of these sets are now getting broken up. I am sure they would do better all sold at the same time.

I'm wondering if by the end of this the average prices will be lower. Just in general, it seems like most people don't have money saved up for lots of big purchases and/or don't want to spend $$$ money on ponies.

I guess it depends on...

- How many people are maxing credit cards
- How many collectors there are interested

I guess both of those are difficult to gauge...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on March 29, 2019, 12:27:39 PM
I wonder if some MOC collectors have blown their money on the earlier items and just have less left in their budget now?  Ha ha, yeah, the Watercolor Baby Sea ponies used to be worth next to nothing MOC.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 29, 2019, 12:36:01 PM
I wish I'd been collecting in the days of the cheap MOC sea ponies. I would have loved to get Watercolor Misty MOC.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Eternia on March 29, 2019, 01:40:52 PM
Any idea who this “prince” pony is they keep mentioning in their listings??
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on March 29, 2019, 01:52:04 PM
Any idea who this “prince” pony is they keep mentioning in their listings??

No idea... guess we'll find out with time...

--

Man, I feel really bad for that MIB purple princess he listed. Her poor nose is smushed from how the person who owned the storage unit beforehand had stored the ponies all piled up....
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on March 29, 2019, 03:41:26 PM
I think this thread is fine, I just wanted to point out that if the circumstances were different--like if a seller only listed ONE rare pony and it was mislabeled (say a Rapunzel with the listing title of "Fairy horse queen" and they put it in the wrong eBay category)--then, in THAT case, a thread like this would be a faux pas.  The people who were already watching the auction (and I guarantee, SOMEONE spotted it) would be resentful as they watched their hidden gem shoot up to "typical" Rapunzel prices.  (Which is why live links were banned from the mailing lists and later the various forums.)

I mean, maybe the OP wouldn't have done that anyway, in which case I apologize for my assumption.  I just thought it was worth bringing up.

Exactly!  This is such a rare instance, of course we will discuss it (it's a part of community history!), but usually we don't.  Because sometimes.... sometimes people get vindicative.  They take things personally.  And we've all been privy to what happens when people intentionally cause drama because they want to hurt others.  Yes, yes, even over ponies!    People who have been collecting ponies for over 30 years have seen it all!  ;)  Our suggestions become Best Practice and guidelines and sometimes even rules (like the no-live-auction link rule on the Arena - unless they are your own sales!) BECAUSE we have experienced all the crazy ways that people get their feelings wounded over plastic brushable fantasy equines.

I have had a number of my own "secretly watched" auctions get called out ... even without the direct links... and I lost out on those ponies because, as Taffeta pointed out, the HIGHEST bidder wins... even if they don't plan on paying. 
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on March 29, 2019, 07:20:07 PM
Any idea who this “prince” pony is they keep mentioning in their listings??

No idea... guess we'll find out with time...

--

Man, I feel really bad for that MIB purple princess he listed. Her poor nose is smushed from how the person who owned the storage unit beforehand had stored the ponies all piled up....

I've never seen a pony nose smooshed like that either. I've noticed a lot of the boxes this time aren't as pristine as the first ones we saw.


I just saw my one and only childhood Dream Beauty Song Rider. I wish I could bid on her.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Squirtsquirt on March 29, 2019, 07:26:57 PM
I'm wondering if this "prince" is Baby Lucky?  He has a bow tie and kinda looks like a prince, if Rapunzel is a queen...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 30, 2019, 03:25:03 AM
I'm wondering if this "prince" is Baby Lucky?  He has a bow tie and kinda looks like a prince, if Rapunzel is a queen...

Ah that's a possibility....I hadn't thought of him.

Am weirdly amused by the photos of purple princess and the helpful biro.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 30, 2019, 08:22:21 AM
Any idea who this “prince” pony is they keep mentioning in their listings??

No idea... guess we'll find out with time...

--

Man, I feel really bad for that MIB purple princess he listed. Her poor nose is smushed from how the person who owned the storage unit beforehand had stored the ponies all piled up....

I've never seen a pony nose smooshed like that either. I've noticed a lot of the boxes this time aren't as pristine as the first ones we saw.


I just saw my one and only childhood Dream Beauty Song Rider. I wish I could bid on her.


Ponyfan


I don’t see it? It looks the same as the other Misty’s I’ve seen in box. Am I missing something?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on March 30, 2019, 08:23:51 AM
Any idea who this “prince” pony is they keep mentioning in their listings??

No idea... guess we'll find out with time...

--

Man, I feel really bad for that MIB purple princess he listed. Her poor nose is smushed from how the person who owned the storage unit beforehand had stored the ponies all piled up....

I've never seen a pony nose smooshed like that either. I've noticed a lot of the boxes this time aren't as pristine as the first ones we saw.


I just saw my one and only childhood Dream Beauty Song Rider. I wish I could bid on her.


Ponyfan


I don’t see it? It looks the same as the other Misty’s I’ve seen in box. Am I missing something?

Not Misty. The eyelash princess :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on March 30, 2019, 09:05:14 AM
I'm wondering if this "prince" is Baby Lucky?  He has a bow tie and kinda looks like a prince, if Rapunzel is a queen...

Ah that's a possibility....I hadn't thought of him.

Am weirdly amused by the photos of purple princess and the helpful biro.

I hope price is Mimic. XD
(yes, not a boy).

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on March 30, 2019, 03:56:07 PM
Any idea who this “prince” pony is they keep mentioning in their listings??

No idea... guess we'll find out with time...

--

Man, I feel really bad for that MIB purple princess he listed. Her poor nose is smushed from how the person who owned the storage unit beforehand had stored the ponies all piled up....

I've never seen a pony nose smooshed like that either. I've noticed a lot of the boxes this time aren't as pristine as the first ones we saw.


I just saw my one and only childhood Dream Beauty Song Rider. I wish I could bid on her.


Ponyfan


I don’t see it? It looks the same as the other Misty’s I’ve seen in box. Am I missing something?

Not Misty. The eyelash princess :)

Ah thank you! I forgot about those princess ponies. :blush:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 01, 2019, 09:46:17 AM
It is fun to look at so many MOC I don't even collect MOC ponies but was tempted by them-

That bag full of pearlized baby ponies is pretty tempting-  I can understand keeping ponies MOC somewhat, cuz the packaging is so cute.  But who on earth could keep so many adorable ponies in BAGS for 35 YEARS?

It's a good thing I'm not bidding on that auction, I'd buy them all and FREE them immediately!!! *insert mad laughter here***


Post Merge: April 01, 2019, 09:49:49 AM

OMG I just read this was a STORAGE LOCKER FIND?

That kinda makes my stomach tie all up...  can you imagine if this was your collection?  Or finding such a collection in one of those storage lockers?  I might have had a heart attack.



Post Merge: April 01, 2019, 09:52:15 AM

Ooh I saw that listing, apparently it was a friend of hers who bought a storage unit and it happened to have all these G1 MOC/MIB ponies!

What are the odds?!
[/quote]

I know! It's a super amazing miracle! AAAAAAAAA

Post Merge: March 05, 2019, 11:14:09 PM

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[/quote]

OMG these photos.   This person cared about their collection very much.  So organized and careful.

I wonder where the collector is? Did they stop paying their storage fees because they got sick? Died? Do they know what happened?  Are they a member of the pony community?  It makes me anxious!!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on April 01, 2019, 10:04:14 AM
OMG these photos.   This person cared about their collection very much.  So organized and careful.

I wonder where the collector is? Did they stop paying their storage fees because they got sick? Died? Do they know what happened?  Are they a member of the pony community?  It makes me anxious!!!

On the organization - that was done by the person who bought the storage, or the guy selling them, or something. They were not like this when the unit was bought. They were in cardboard boxes stacked on top of one another, which resulted in some boxes being damaged as you can see in some of the eBay listings (particularly with the purple eyelash princess where it damaged the pony too). You can see how they were stored originally in this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=7Z3nc8oD13c&app=desktop

Two minutes in they cut to how these were in there originally. It wasn't only ponies in here either. There were also comics, and Transformers, some other stuff too.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on April 01, 2019, 12:55:34 PM
Wow, looking at the video I'm surprised how carelessly the storage unit owner had tossed all these MOC ponies into those huge cardboard boxes!  I wonder if the owner of the storage unit wasn't the original owner either?  Like maybe they bought them at an estate sale or something and just chucked them into the storage unit because they didn't know what they were worth?  Or maybe their parent collected them and passed away?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 01, 2019, 01:59:32 PM
It reminds me of a situation with a collector here years ago - her parents split up. Her mother was the chief collector and the kid went along with it but the Dad was not in favour and he threw them both out during their divorce. He then proceeded to burn (!) all the packaging and comics (I gave him hell about that O.o) and basically just dumped out all the rest of their collections - some of which he had people come to the house to buy and others ended up sold to dealers (who took better care of them) including some MIP or boxed items.

It may be a similar situation.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on April 01, 2019, 03:39:50 PM
Someone on a facebook group contacted the seller and it appears the original owner has died.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: HarmonyShare on April 01, 2019, 06:23:53 PM
Someone on a facebook group contacted the seller and it appears the original owner has died.
I didn't realize that. How sad! :(
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 02, 2019, 10:31:35 AM
Someone on a facebook group contacted the seller and it appears the original owner has died.


On the organization - that was done by the person who bought the storage, or the guy selling them, or something. They were not like this when the unit was bought. They were in cardboard boxes stacked on top of one another, which resulted in some boxes being damaged as you can see in some of the eBay listings (particularly with the purple eyelash princess where it damaged the pony too). You can see how they were stored originally in this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=7Z3nc8oD13c&app=desktop

Two minutes in they cut to how these were in there originally. It wasn't only ponies in here either. There were also comics, and Transformers, some other stuff too.

Wow, looking at the video I'm surprised how carelessly the storage unit owner had tossed all these MOC ponies into those huge cardboard boxes!  I wonder if the owner of the storage unit wasn't the original owner either?  Like maybe they bought them at an estate sale or something and just chucked them into the storage unit because they didn't know what they were worth?  Or maybe their parent collected them and passed away?

Oh! What a relief.

So I guess that is what happened-  the original owner/collector probably got sick (or maybe just put in a home or something) and someone put their toy hoard hastily (and not particularly lovingly) into boxes and shoved it in storage. Then the person died and the bill didn't get paid.  OR the family who put it in storage just didn't care about it. So the storage facility sold the contents of the unit to the highest bidder like in "storage wars"...

I know it is super sad that a collector died- (especially as we might have known this person if they were here on the boards 10 years ago!)  BUT here's my thought- although it is sad that someone died, the situation with the selling the treasures of someone who passed away (and who has no idea) somehow feels less horrible to me than the thought of some poor collector (could have been me!) who lost possession of their pony hoard inadvertently... and who has or will find out later that their most treasured things are now GONE FOREVER.  But once I die?  Who cares. Hopefully my wife will take my advice to contact a certain friend to help her liquidize, but even if she finds that to be too much work and just gives it all away-  it won't matter to me as I'll be pushing up daisies.

Hopefully this poor collector never knew that the storage unit was lost.  Probably they didn't.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 02, 2019, 12:30:09 PM
So the storage facility sold the contents of the unit to the highest bidder like in "storage wars"...

ironically, the dude who was doing the video... is on that show. -_-
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 02, 2019, 12:34:15 PM
So the storage facility sold the contents of the unit to the highest bidder like in "storage wars"...

ironically, the dude who was doing the video... is on that show. -_-

Lets hope this isn't one of the lockers on the show. The prices stuff is selling for is something that doesn't need to be broadcast on global TV, Youtube and our discussions are enough. (Storage Wars airs over here too, though I don't watch it, so the last thing we need is a TV show worldwide telling everyone PONIES ARE VALUABLE).

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 02, 2019, 12:39:45 PM
I'm going to guess because I feel like they couldn't show that sort of content if it needed to air..The video guy did say it was his friend who won it (so might not be on the show).

That's why he says "you guys say the show is fake" in the beginning.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Strawberry Swirl on April 02, 2019, 07:30:59 PM
I saw those storage images on Tumblr a little bit back...what an absolute dream find! How sad that the original owner is no longer with us, though. I'm glad that at least some of these beauties are going to collectors who will care for them well. I myself have bidded on one of those Dream Beauties, oh what a dream to own one in box...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on April 02, 2019, 08:50:25 PM
If I ran a show like that, I would 100% make sure that storage locker was on the show.  It's a dramatic, exciting find and I think even people who don't collect MLP would realize that finding a billion MOCs from the 80s is something special.   

Like, the only thing I can think of that would be more exciting would be a treasure chest full of jewels, a lost Picasso, or a couple perfectly preserved classic cars.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on April 04, 2019, 07:58:58 AM
Well princess ponies went just out of budget  :cry:

Anyone here get these lovely girls?

Or perhaps have a Pristina MIB to sell?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 04, 2019, 08:11:23 AM
Well princess ponies went just out of budget  :cry:

Anyone here get these lovely girls?

Or perhaps have a Pristina MIB to sell?


Wow. That's quite a lot more than I paid for the ones I have from that set...
I really think that this storage lot is probably not the place for a cheap bargain.

Congrats to anyone who won any. I was watching Misty as she's one of the three I still don't have MIB, just to see what she went for as a guide for when I actually have money - but yeah, that was a fair bit higher than I thought. I have an affinity for this set, but they're so stupidly expensive MIB :/
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Kendall8014 on April 04, 2019, 12:56:19 PM
This whole thing has just blown me away. I’m so thankful I nabbed two of my grail MIBs for very fair prices 💜
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SkyCakes on April 04, 2019, 06:21:50 PM
I do have to say that this thread is amazing. I wish I could of bought one or two of those ponies but I cant aford anything at the moment. :/ The best I have done so far is a MOC surprise and a MIB baby surprise. I wish everyone great luck with these finds.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on April 04, 2019, 11:29:18 PM
I dropped in a few cheeky bids on this round of ponies but I didn’t win everything. I think prices seem to be levelling our a bit, although they still seem a bit higher than normal.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on April 05, 2019, 03:52:14 AM
It looks like whoever won the MIB Satin and Lace with all of the regrind spots was unhappy as there is one feedback mentioning "several spots of discoloration even though item was sealed"


Even though I can't bid on anything I'm enjoying seeing everything look so perfect MIB/MOC.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on April 05, 2019, 05:34:46 AM
It looks like whoever won the MIB Satin and Lace with all of the regrind spots was unhappy as there is one feedback mentioning "several spots of discoloration even though item was sealed"


Even though I can't bid on anything I'm enjoying seeing everything look so perfect MIB/MOC.



Ponyfan

Haha, and I'm fairly certain being sealed is what led to there being so many regrind spots! I'm surprised they didn't notice because... it's pretty obvious she has tons of regrind from the images on the auction.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 05, 2019, 05:37:44 AM
u_u ugh those spots were VERY noticeable on the photos

Reality is, just because something is in it's original package, doesn't make it perfect.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 05, 2019, 06:28:26 AM
I';ve noticed that they've added comments about international shipping that isn't as crazy as the total showing up on the auctions themselves. Which is reassuring.

Glad people are managing to snag items :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Kendall8014 on April 05, 2019, 08:57:16 AM
Yeah, the dream beauties showed me shipping at $71 EACH to Canada. I won two and combined shipping priority was only $40. The shipping calculator is whacked, I’m sure it scared off a ton of people !
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: ClosetAvalanche on April 05, 2019, 02:46:31 PM
It looks like whoever won the MIB Satin and Lace with all of the regrind spots was unhappy as there is one feedback mentioning "several spots of discoloration even though item was sealed"


Even though I can't bid on anything I'm enjoying seeing everything look so perfect MIB/MOC.



Ponyfan

Haha, and I'm fairly certain being sealed is what led to there being so many regrind spots! I'm surprised they didn't notice because... it's pretty obvious she has tons of regrind from the images on the auction.

As a seller, I can say that people do not read descriptions or looks at photos. I get at least one return a week becasue their pants didn't fit, despite the measurements in the listing.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 05, 2019, 03:34:43 PM
The way ebay is set up now, it makes the description less obvious unless you go looking for it. And it seems to be increasingly optional for sellers to put one, which the old person living inside of me puts down to the smartphone listing phenomenon. The people who go take picture, list, two word description...and that's it.

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on April 11, 2019, 07:13:09 PM
I took a look at the latest items on Ebay.  Princess Sparkle/Amethyst's box looks really crushed and the pony looks like she has shifted slightly from where she should be.

I love those MOC baby sea ponies. :lovey:


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: PrincessTiffy on April 12, 2019, 09:33:53 AM
I took a look at the latest items on Ebay.  Princess Sparkle/Amethyst's box looks really crushed and the pony looks like she has shifted slightly from where she should be.

I love those MOC baby sea ponies. :lovey:


Ponyfan

Are you referring to her being at an angle and not straight like the other princess ponies? All of the Sparkles I’ve seen are like that. Guessing it has to do with her horn and fitting in the packaging. I never got why she was at an angle but Misty wasn’t.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 12, 2019, 11:00:33 AM
Random observation but I've noticed how some US boxed ponies go in for bubble-to-card-inside-box whereas UK boxed ponies from the same time (ie Princesses with dragons) are more tie-to-box-inlay-with-cellophane.

The US method seems more durable -my MIB Pristina has some damage to her box but she and her bubble are intact. If it had been a cello box she'd have been wrecked I think :/

I feel like one day I will want a US 1st set princess pony box because the art is so pretty, but the MIB ponies are always so expensive and nobody ever sells the boxes on their own.

I am slightly scared by the prices of the MIB 2nd set princesses so far. Taffeta I expected to go for a lot but not quite that much. I would still like Dawn and Misty as well, but I suspect Dawn will also go for a lot :/

This set of auctions kind of confirmed they're no longer anywhere near my price range and so completing the set will need a miracle or a lottery win xD.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 12, 2019, 11:23:29 AM
aah paradise. ;_; *grabby*

It's interesting that "prince" is a BiN.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 12, 2019, 11:42:38 AM
aah paradise. ;_; *grabby*

It's interesting that "prince" is a BiN.

Ahh. Isn't it though.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on April 12, 2019, 12:43:07 PM
I took a look at the latest items on Ebay.  Princess Sparkle/Amethyst's box looks really crushed and the pony looks like she has shifted slightly from where she should be.

I love those MOC baby sea ponies. :lovey:


Ponyfan

Are you referring to her being at an angle and not straight like the other princess ponies? All of the Sparkles I’ve seen are like that. Guessing it has to do with her horn and fitting in the packaging. I never got why she was at an angle but Misty wasn’t.


I didn't realize are MIB Sparkles are like that. :) That's really interesting.  It's also interesting that the US Princess Ponies have the bubble inside the box and the UK princess ponies with dragons don't.

Seeing my chidhood ponies MOC/MIB really makes me want to purchase them but I can't afford them. 


Someone bought "prince"



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 12, 2019, 12:47:13 PM
How nice it would be to have the pocket money to do that o.o

Congrats to the winner!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 12, 2019, 12:57:43 PM
Lol that was fast :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on April 12, 2019, 01:21:04 PM
I love that Sweet Scoops was just "PRINCE".  :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on April 12, 2019, 01:58:39 PM
I'm so confused. I can't find the 'Prince' listing anywhere? Even on completed items?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on April 12, 2019, 02:18:51 PM
I found it by searching "My Little Pony Prince" for Sold listings.  :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 12, 2019, 03:45:34 PM
I'm so confused. I can't find the 'Prince' listing anywhere? Even on completed items?

Noasar - it doesn't show on ebay UK. Try completed listings and changing the url to .com :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on April 12, 2019, 03:57:37 PM
I missed that one for "Prince."
I forgot to post the last total: $13,297.70

For an overall total of $61,691.70
But that didn't include "Prince!"

I wonder why they had two of Sweet Scoops.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 12, 2019, 03:59:13 PM
I wonder if they had two or if the previous high bidder flaked. I feel like there were some bid abuses that wound the seller up in the first round of bidding, so maybe that's what happened.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 12, 2019, 04:06:15 PM
I wonder if they had two or if the previous high bidder flaked. I feel like there were some bid abuses that wound the seller up in the first round of bidding, so maybe that's what happened.

Last pic is the two together
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 12, 2019, 05:02:14 PM
I wonder if they had two or if the previous high bidder flaked. I feel like there were some bid abuses that wound the seller up in the first round of bidding, so maybe that's what happened.

Last pic is the two together

Ooh. Well, that's convenient.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 13, 2019, 07:03:33 AM
I wonder if they had two or if the previous high bidder flaked. I feel like there were some bid abuses that wound the seller up in the first round of bidding, so maybe that's what happened.

Last pic is the two together

Ooh. Well, that's convenient.

That's ok I was staring at both auctions for over 5 minutes before I saw the last pic XD lol
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 13, 2019, 07:05:59 AM
I wonder if they had two or if the previous high bidder flaked. I feel like there were some bid abuses that wound the seller up in the first round of bidding, so maybe that's what happened.

Last pic is the two together

Ooh. Well, that's convenient.

That's ok I was staring at both auctions for over 5 minutes before I saw the last pic XD lol

I admit, I didn't even look xD My browser is sometimes funny with ebay's images and I couldn't be bothered to scroll through xD. But wow. Imagine having two o.O.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 13, 2019, 07:12:38 AM
two... UNOPENED!

I mean, if I had two, I surely would open one.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 13, 2019, 08:19:07 AM
two... UNOPENED!

I mean, if I had two, I surely would open one.

If I had two I'd sell one. And go to Japan o.o.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on April 13, 2019, 08:41:49 AM
At this point I really don't see a logical explanation for how the person collected all this stuff other than a time machine.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 13, 2019, 08:45:06 AM
At this point I really don't see a logical explanation for how this person collected all this other than a time machine.

It's pretty likely they were collected when they were in the stores. Most of them have TRU price tags, but some of the other ones have other tags that seem local to the SoCal area. OG collector.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 13, 2019, 08:57:20 AM
At this point I really don't see a logical explanation for how this person collected all this other than a time machine.

It's pretty likely they were collected when they were in the stores. Most of them have TRU price tags, but some of the other ones have other tags that seem local to the SoCal area. OG collector.

I think that's likely too. There were some people who did this during the eighties, for whatever reason. Although it is also possible they amassed a lot of it back at the end of the line, when ponies were more available MIP and not so expensive.

Just, the lack of anything foreign makes me think banditpony is probably right. Unless the collector actively chose not to collect overseas releases, which some people do.

A time machine would be a nice touch though :)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on April 13, 2019, 09:01:12 AM
At this point I really don't see a logical explanation for how this person collected all this other than a time machine.

It's pretty likely they were collected when they were in the stores. Most of them have TRU price tags, but some of the other ones have other tags that seem local to the SoCal area. OG collector.

Aaaaand apparently humour/sarcasm doesn't always come across well on a keyboard. Because obviously, time machines don't exist.

Would be cool if they did though! First stop: 1981
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 13, 2019, 09:16:17 AM
At this point I really don't see a logical explanation for how this person collected all this other than a time machine.

It's pretty likely they were collected when they were in the stores. Most of them have TRU price tags, but some of the other ones have other tags that seem local to the SoCal area. OG collector.

Aaaaand apparently humour/sarcasm doesn't always come across well on a keyboard. Because obviously, time machines don't exist.

Would be cool if they did though! First stop: 1981

I know time machine's aren't real?

I made my comment because generally speaking there would be two ways someone could have a collection like this
1) buying them in stores in the 80s.
2) buying them second hand via internet
(and sometimes a variety of the two).

But just based on the price tags, it just leans toward the ame stores. I had been paying attention to the tags to see if there were any from out of state. Back in the 80s, there were some stores that were national -- but there were so many more regional stores.

We never had a Target or Walmart in our area in the 80s. Only in the mid-late 90s did those stores even show up in our region. And now they are absolutely everywhere.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 13, 2019, 09:24:22 AM
To be fair, the comment wasn't really either humour or sarcasm... I took it as a statement of amazement at what was coming out of the locker...which I can totally empathise with, because it's awesome.

On the time machine subject, I would like to go back to 1987, because I want some MIB princesses with dragons and mountain boys, but that's just me. I'm not patient enough to go back to 1981 and wait for MLP to appear in late 1982-3...

@banditpony, the price tag thing is interesting. I hadn't been looking at those really but it does make it seem more like something someone collected at the time for whatever reason. I also didn't realise that stores in the 80s over there were sometimes more regional than now.

If that's how this collection happened, it does make you wonder why they did it - whether they just liked the ponies and thought them pretty, or if they were collecting for some other reason. They collected some other stuff too, right? Maybe they just really liked the toys out at the time...

They also must have sent off for the mail order ponies, too. But we didn't see any ponies with cut cards, and I think there were also loose ponies in the locker. So I wonder if there was another part of this collection too - the played with collection that a kid maybe had, while the adult collected them in package too?

It makes me really curious about the human being behind these things now that we've seen so many of their collectables. It is sad that we didn't know them before this point. I think they would have found kindred spirits here - I hope they are happy that their ponies are gaining so much attention now.

Is this the last round of auctions, incidentally? I think the seller said something like that? Because if so there are some gaps. Unless they've also done some local selling, which is possible I suppose...I noticed a few of the buyers were able to do local pickup, so maybe they also brokered deals at the same time.

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Noasar on April 13, 2019, 03:47:56 PM
Quote
I'm not patient enough to go back to 1981 and wait for MLP to appear in late 1982-3...

I’d take my credit card, start with My Pretty Pony and work my way on from there! In fact, I’m surprised this person didn’t have MPP’s in there. They were scarily intuitive about how collectible all this would be in the future.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 17, 2019, 09:09:40 AM
I found it by searching "My Little Pony Prince" for Sold listings.  :)

HOLY CR@P! I didn't realize there was a regular US pony worth so much.  I guess this seller did their homework before selling to get that price?

Wow.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/PRINCE/123733080625?hash=item1ccf10fa31:g:QFEAAOSwaP5csLTb
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 17, 2019, 09:11:58 AM
I found it by searching "My Little Pony Prince" for Sold listings.  :)

HOLY CR@P! I didn't realize there was a regular US pony worth so much.  I guess this seller did their homework before selling to get that price?

Wow.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/PRINCE/123733080625?hash=item1ccf10fa31:g:QFEAAOSwaP5csLTb

They had already had an auction for one and set the bin based on that.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 17, 2019, 09:16:23 AM
I found it by searching "My Little Pony Prince" for Sold listings.  :)

HOLY CR@P! I didn't realize there was a regular US pony worth so much.  I guess this seller did their homework before selling to get that price?

Wow.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/PRINCE/123733080625?hash=item1ccf10fa31:g:QFEAAOSwaP5csLTb

They had already had an auction for one and set the bin based on that.

WOW.  Seriously though, all of the ponies seem to be going for higher than market. I think these listings are getting a lot of viewership.

One thing that kind of boggles my mind- can you imagine collecting so many mail order ponies in the 1980s and never taking them from their bags? They aren't even cute in the bags.  And they weren't exactly collectible in the 1980s yet...  very OCD collector maybe... or as someone else speculated- maybe an adult collection someone collected alongside their child.  Still, I can't imagine...

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on April 20, 2019, 11:14:13 AM
I've got the next total of auctions including the pony wear and the BIN Sweet Scoops.

$11,489.84

New total: $73,181.69
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Artemesia's Garden on April 20, 2019, 12:32:30 PM
:popcorn:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: maycrestmom on April 20, 2019, 02:08:16 PM
heck of a time-capsule that is for sure
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 20, 2019, 02:17:45 PM
I wonder how that total compares to sales from other storage lockers...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 20, 2019, 03:08:43 PM
I wonder how that total compares to sales from other storage lockers...

Each one is different? Some have junk, others worth a lot.

https://www.thisisinsider.com/five-hundred-dollar-storage-unit-had-7-million-inside-storage-wars-2018-11

Clearly it isn't the one with the most..
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 21, 2019, 01:27:43 AM
I wonder how that total compares to sales from other storage lockers...

Each one is different? Some have junk, others worth a lot.

https://www.thisisinsider.com/five-hundred-dollar-storage-unit-had-7-million-inside-storage-wars-2018-11

Clearly it isn't the one with the most..

Well, yeah, obviously it's going to vary, that goes without saying. But I was thinking more in terms of how certain types of stuff gets attention over others when dealing with this kind of thing. The idea of "respectable" stuff and "ponies"...if that makes sense? I don't watch Storage Wars but it just occurred to me that they probably didn't expect 70k from a bunch of toy ponies.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 21, 2019, 05:01:06 AM
I wonder how that total compares to sales from other storage lockers...

Each one is different? Some have junk, others worth a lot.

https://www.thisisinsider.com/five-hundred-dollar-storage-unit-had-7-million-inside-storage-wars-2018-11

Clearly it isn't the one with the most..

Well, yeah, obviously it's going to vary, that goes without saying. But I was thinking more in terms of how certain types of stuff gets attention over others when dealing with this kind of thing. The idea of "respectable" stuff and "ponies"...if that makes sense? I don't watch Storage Wars but it just occurred to me that they probably didn't expect 70k from a bunch of toy ponies.

They knew it was going to be a good amount based on they looked up the price of one, and it was $200. I'm sure they didn't expect the price of Rapunzel, but that also surprised some pony people.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on April 21, 2019, 03:09:38 PM
It sounded like the person who bought the locker sold the ponies and some other things to the person who's selling them now. So it's unlikely they'll be featured on any kind of storage wars programme at all.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 21, 2019, 04:29:41 PM
It sounded like the person who bought the locker sold the ponies and some other things to the person who's selling them now. So it's unlikely they'll be featured on any kind of storage wars programme at all.

The person who bought the locker isnt someone who was on storage wars anyway. It was a friend of one of the SW guys (and that guy made the video). So that alone means it won't be on SW.

People who buy lockers don't necessarily sell every item themselves. *Shrug* they will sell to other resellers

If it was on storage wars, then they'd show the amount they sold to the friend. Rather then the auctions. But they'd still show it.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 22, 2019, 09:38:07 AM
I'm sure that 99.98% of the time those storage units contain outdated technology (dead TVs) and moldy old clothing and furniture.

That "storage wars" show has people thinking that these things are goldmines...

And, every once in a while, they are. 
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 26, 2019, 10:55:45 AM
So I guess the ponies are done?  I wonder if they will sell the other things they found- they didn't seem overly interesting (cards or something?) but maybe there were some MOTU or something fun in there...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on April 26, 2019, 11:35:23 AM
I don't think so - there were playsets and loose ponies in outfits too.
My guess is they need a break before they continue!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 26, 2019, 11:54:48 AM
I don't think so - there were playsets and loose ponies in outfits too.
My guess is they need a break before they continue!

Yeah, I was gonna say there were loose items. Although it's just as possible they sold them in a job lot to someone else locally.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 26, 2019, 11:58:33 AM
It could be they are just sorting out the packaging-  if they are playsets and loose ponies, they may need to assess how best to package.  If they are low value playsets they may not even bother (since the plastic is so brittle)

I'm sure by NOW they have encountered some difficult buyers... (just based on their feedback) so maybe they are going to go more carefully with round two

Or you may be right, they could try and sell local. 
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on April 26, 2019, 12:13:15 PM
Some buyers have stories on facebook. Some have arrived damaged due to poor packaging. Cracked bubbles, folded cards and too small boxes. Part of it was down to the global shipping service but they dropped that after the first lot of auctions. Later ones have also had a few problems. They aren't toy collectors but they could take some time and expense to make sure the items are packaged carefully.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 26, 2019, 12:30:17 PM
I don't think so - there were playsets and loose ponies in outfits too.
My guess is they need a break before they continue!

Yeah, I was gonna say there were loose items. Although it's just as possible they sold them in a job lot to someone else locally.

My thought was it was possible it was local too.  Especially since his friend has a store (and who knows maybe he does too. They obviously are in the business of selling used things)
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 26, 2019, 01:29:31 PM
Some buyers have stories on facebook. Some have arrived damaged due to poor packaging. Cracked bubbles, folded cards and too small boxes. Part of it was down to the global shipping service but they dropped that after the first lot of auctions. Later ones have also had a few problems. They aren't toy collectors but they could take some time and expense to make sure the items are packaged carefully.

That's sad. I wonder if that's why Global Shipping disappeared off the options after the first round except for some bagged items. When I asked them about international shipping at the time the first stuff got listed I did mention that GSP does that, and I wonder if they fell foul of it and decided not to risk it again. It's why, honestly, even if my most wanted MOC comes up on ebay, I won't use GSP - rather not have the item than receive the heartbreaking sight of one broken by neanderthal repackers trying to skim profits.

Sad that some of these, with the prices they were making, got damaged. There aren't enough surviving examples of some of these MIP items for shoddy shipping to damage them :/
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on April 26, 2019, 01:36:34 PM
Some buyers have stories on facebook. Some have arrived damaged due to poor packaging. Cracked bubbles, folded cards and too small boxes. Part of it was down to the global shipping service but they dropped that after the first lot of auctions. Later ones have also had a few problems. They aren't toy collectors but they could take some time and expense to make sure the items are packaged carefully.

That's sad. I wonder if that's why Global Shipping disappeared off the options after the first round except for some bagged items. When I asked them about international shipping at the time the first stuff got listed I did mention that GSP does that, and I wonder if they fell foul of it and decided not to risk it again. It's why, honestly, even if my most wanted MOC comes up on ebay, I won't use GSP - rather not have the item than receive the heartbreaking sight of one broken by neanderthal repackers trying to skim profits.

Sad that some of these, with the prices they were making, got damaged. There aren't enough surviving examples of some of these MIP items for shoddy shipping to damage them :/


I agree. Some of these items don't come up MIP?MIB/MOC often and to find out that some were damaged due to poor packaging or through GSP workers is heartbreaking. :sad:



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: kamakazee82 on April 27, 2019, 01:25:54 PM
they have more up now
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on April 27, 2019, 08:06:52 PM
Yeah that's sad to hear that paying all that money (with a lot of them finishing above market rate esp) that the buyers received damaged packages.

They added this to their listings now to cover themselves I guess "DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD. "
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on April 27, 2019, 08:26:01 PM
Yeah that's sad to hear that paying all that money (with a lot of them finishing above market rate esp) that the buyers received damaged packages.

They added this to their listings now to cover themselves I guess "DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD. "


"Don't expect to receive in the condition you bought it for" fixed that for you, seller. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 28, 2019, 04:02:24 AM
Yeah that's sad to hear that paying all that money (with a lot of them finishing above market rate esp) that the buyers received damaged packages.

They added this to their listings now to cover themselves I guess "DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD. "


"Don't expect to receive in the condition you bought it for" fixed that for you, seller. :rolleyes:

Absolutely. Although some of the cards are clearly damaged, any additional bending should not happen in transit or because of packaging...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 28, 2019, 05:07:24 AM
Yeah that's sad to hear that paying all that money (with a lot of them finishing above market rate esp) that the buyers received damaged packages.

They added this to their listings now to cover themselves I guess "DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD. "


"Don't expect to receive in the condition you bought it for" fixed that for you, seller. :rolleyes:

Actually, since a majority, if not all those cards are damaged.. It's a fair and important statement. That's not saying he should not be properly packing them as well. And I feel like it's important to say he notes "LOOK AT THE CONDITION OF THE CARD".

His shipping is so expensive, he has no excuse not to ship nicely in a box. It's $16, when actual shipping is $9.30.

I do wonder what amount of damage was.there previously vs in transit. He's taking more care to note damage now.

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on April 28, 2019, 06:27:54 AM
I noticed he has two negative feedback for items being damaged in shipping by using too small boxes/wrong shipping container for the item.  It looks like Whizzer's bubble is detaching/torn  at the bottom?


I agree with everyone else. Even with a disclaimer there's no excuse for not making sure the items will arrive in the condition the buyer paid for the item in. I would be devastated to find out my MOC?MIB G1 had been damaged during shipping due to poor packaging.



Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on April 28, 2019, 06:38:27 AM
Yeah that's sad to hear that paying all that money (with a lot of them finishing above market rate esp) that the buyers received damaged packages.

They added this to their listings now to cover themselves I guess "DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD. "


"Don't expect to receive in the condition you bought it for" fixed that for you, seller. :rolleyes:

Actually, since a majority, if not all those cards are damaged.. It's a fair and important statement. That's not saying he should not be properly packing them as well. And I feel like it's important to say he notes "LOOK AT THE CONDITION OF THE CARD".

No true I  see your point (and he for sure should say that) but to me the intent appears differently because this statement was added after getting negative feedback for damaged by poor packing. Most of the cards/boxes he's sold have been curled, bent and/or dented and some being straight up mashed. But he never said anything about that before.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 28, 2019, 06:46:14 AM
Yeah that's sad to hear that paying all that money (with a lot of them finishing above market rate esp) that the buyers received damaged packages.

They added this to their listings now to cover themselves I guess "DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD. "


"Don't expect to receive in the condition you bought it for" fixed that for you, seller. :rolleyes:

Actually, since a majority, if not all those cards are damaged.. It's a fair and important statement. That's not saying he should not be properly packing them as well. And I feel like it's important to say he notes "LOOK AT THE CONDITION OF THE CARD".

No true I  see your point (and he for sure should say that) but to me the intent appears differently because this statement was added after getting negative feedback for damaged by poor packing. Most of the cards/boxes he's sold have been curled, bent and/or dented and some being straight up mashed. But he never said anything about that before.

As a non collector, he probably didn't know that the condition of the box was that important.
Again, his full warning was : PEN POINTS TO OPENING. LOOK AT CONDITION OF CARDS BEFORE BIDDING! DON'T EXPECT A PERFECTLY FLAT CARD.

Omitting the "look at the condition before bidding" skews the whole statement.

But he's taking sideway pictures of the bubbles falling off and pointing out all the damage. He's making sure people know they were in bad condition BEFORE he sends them off.

Any additional damage due to poor packaging is also his fault. But at this point, he's documenting the damage beforehand too. This is a GOOD thing!

I personally think it's a mixture of both.



:( Man, poor Cherry Treats tho... what happened to her face.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 28, 2019, 07:01:14 AM
I don't think that not being a collector - not knowing the importance of card condition is an excuse. Whatever he usually sells, anything getting damaged by poor packaging or bad shipping is something he ought to know. So for me that side of it is not an excuse.

On the other hand, it's been obvious from the pictures so far that some have damage. I still think Twilight was taped shut and I maintain it (not the SS, the unicorn). But I don't see why if you were a MOC collector you WOULDN'T scrutinise the issues. It's important because you have to know if you can live with those flaws in your collection. And if you can't, then don't bid. That goes for anything, though. You should always scrutinise, ask questions, etc. (Though this seller discourages asking questions, so there is more onus on him for a more detailed description).

The things I wouldn't expect him to notice necessarily are things like ponies discolouring (if it's even/fading hair/etc), ponies on the wrong card, with the wrong sticker. Regrind etc or mismatch he might or might not see but it might not occur to him as being important. However, detached bubble and great bit tear in card - those are flaws. So those should be mentioned no matter what. Even if you don't sell ponies regularly...that's the condition of the item.

I feel like it's a partnership between a buyer and a seller.

And I have no quarter for poor mip packaging. I have had four MIB Flutters mailed to me from overseas and none of them got damaged. That's because of the great packaging by the sellers. By contrast, I lost two MOCs because the sellers put them in padded mailers and the bubbles came off the card in transit. The worst was watercolor Misty, as she was also sent this way via surface mail (she spent 6 weeks in transit with no packing). I didn't ask for surface mail...but that was a long time ago and she wasn't expensive so I let it go since I didn't have her at all in my collection then. The other was a movie Wind Whistler. I got a partial refund for that one as it came from within the collecting community and shouldn't have happened. But the heartbreak of a damaged MOC for a MOC collector is profound.

So to summarise...

If there are flaws, state them very clearly. Even if you don't know if they matter, if you notice something, state it.

Pack MOC items safely no matter what. No excuses. I have heard of people cutting bits off cards to fit them in smaller boxes. MOC collectors collect the whole thing, not just the pony...but the bigger issue is that the moment you wreck a MOC pony in this way, there's one less MOC pony out there - so protecting it in transit is really important to do.

...Yeah, this is one of those twitches for me :) I have some MOC ponies in less than perfect condition, and I have a few which have come off card before I bought them but I got them knowing that. It's the nasty surprises that I think we really need to prevent.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 28, 2019, 09:49:57 AM
I don't think that not being a collector - not knowing the importance of card condition is an excuse. Whatever he usually sells, anything getting damaged by poor packaging or bad shipping is something he ought to know. So for me that side of it is not an excuse.

I NEVER ever said that anything was an excuse for poor packaging.

I said that he is documenting the damage BEFORE he sends the item now, because he wasn't aware of the importance to collectors.

Just like he's pointing out the flaws on ponies that have defects (like cherry treats). He didn't with the whatever pink pony with regrind, and yet while so many of us saw that -- the buyer did not.

Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on April 28, 2019, 02:42:06 PM
What could have happened to Cherry Treats? It looks like some kind of mold/fungus on her face?


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: SaraMari on April 28, 2019, 03:32:18 PM
Not being a collector is not a reason to not disclose the damage on the cards and boxes. He is knowingly selling a collectable and stated he expected hundreds of dollars for each because they are MIB/MOC. Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?

saying "look at the pictures" is not enough, I'm sick of sellers saying look at the pictures then damage that is pictured but not very clear can be waved away. But that is something I find upsetting across the board not just this case.

And yeah that Cherry Treats 😱 I kinda looks like something melted into her and stained? I wouldn't pay even the 10$ starting price for her
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on April 28, 2019, 04:58:09 PM
Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?

More often then not, yes. There's been many stories in the past about it.

-_- I've even gotten that sort of ignorance from collectors who should know better. (not disclosed damage AND poor packaging). Nothing like paying $500+ for an item and then noticing minor damage to the packaging that wasn't talked about or really shown clearly in pix... *sigh*



And yeah that Cherry Treats 😱 I kinda looks like something melted into her and stained? I wouldn't pay even the 10$ starting price for her
That was my thought, it looked like something melted. o_O but I can't imagine what could even cause that. I also wouldn't want to pay $10... poor thing...

Very curious to hear anyone else's input if they know what that is.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on April 29, 2019, 05:05:50 AM
I think I said in my other post that there are things the seller might not know are important to buyers and things that they should know are, including card and bubble damage, given that MOC items are not a pony only phenomenon but a general collecting THING that someone into selling stuff would and should know about. But pointing out the other things if you notice them is important too. I suspect it's more that he didn't notice because he didn't look closely at the items before this, rather than not seeing or trying to conceal flaws. They're just ponies, right? :) How much can possibly be wrong with them? (As we know, a good deal!)

Not being a collector is not a reason to not disclose the damage on the cards and boxes. He is knowingly selling a collectable and stated he expected hundreds of dollars for each because they are MIB/MOC. Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?
This exactly was my point too.
Quote
And yeah that Cherry Treats 😱 I kinda looks like something melted into her and stained? I wouldn't pay even the 10$ starting price for her
I feel so sorry for her. If I had any money I'd want to rescue her. I think melting or burn of some kind rather than mould as mould would have spread up inside the whole bubble and this is just around the edge of her face. It makes me think she was either in really direct light or, as the card isn't faded, up against some kind of heater :/

I hope she goes to a good home.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on April 30, 2019, 09:56:47 AM
What could have happened to Cherry Treats? It looks like some kind of mold/fungus on her face?


Ponyfan

Yikes I saw that too-  my guess is that these ponies were in storage somewhere humid and hot- maybe a combination of dirty condensation and mold...

I cringed when I read that review that the seller put a NRFB carded pony into a BUBBLE MAILER. I hope he learned his lesson on that ...

I remember once buying a super rare fragile NRFB Brazil SSC, and the buyer wrapped the ultra-thin aged cardboard doll box- in brown paper before mailing. NO other protection whatsoever.  Unsurprisingly it arrived 100% mashed.  It was heartbreaking.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Sonisia on May 07, 2019, 06:17:59 AM
Incredible collection. So mamy great Ponies still in original boxes. I would love to see some of them at my pony shelf 💓💓💓💓💓💓💓 Especially Fizzy :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Eighties_Otaku on June 01, 2019, 09:48:46 PM
Anyone still keeping track of the total? I'm curious what ones he has left now too. I know the playsets are still there.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on June 02, 2019, 06:56:25 AM
Anyone still keeping track of the total? I'm curious what ones he has left now too. I know the playsets are still there.
I am sure the shipping is a huge deterrent on the playsets...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on June 02, 2019, 02:51:13 PM
Oops, Sorry. I didn't post the last totals.

The lot before last came to $5319.90
Last lot came to $9084.33

New overall total: $87585.92
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on June 02, 2019, 11:57:11 PM
Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?

In the late 90s I saw a MOC Glory on eBay.  Her bubble had yellowed--not unusual.  So then I read the auction description.  Wherein the seller said "I wasn't sure if the pony was still white inside the package, so I opened it.  Yep, still pure white!"

I then died inside.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on June 03, 2019, 06:16:27 AM
Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?

In the late 90s I saw a MOC Glory on eBay.  Her bubble had yellowed--not unusual.  So then I read the auction description.  Wherein the seller said "I wasn't sure if the pony was still white inside the package, so I opened it.  Yep, still pure white!"

I then died inside.

Ouch!  :yikes:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: FiddlePhan on June 04, 2019, 02:58:29 PM
Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?

In the late 90s I saw a MOC Glory on eBay.  Her bubble had yellowed--not unusual.  So then I read the auction description.  Wherein the seller said "I wasn't sure if the pony was still white inside the package, so I opened it.  Yep, still pure white!"

I then died inside.

That is brutal.    I wanted to bang my head on my desk after reading that.   Nooooo!  Don't open the package!!!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: nebulavery on June 04, 2019, 09:22:52 PM
This whole thread is a wild thread! Might have binge read the whole thing in one sitting, whoops. Don't think I'll end up purchasing anything since I don't collect MIB, but it sure is fun to see how much everything sells for.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Taffeta on June 04, 2019, 09:26:17 PM
Are there really sellers out there that think the condition of the collectables' packaging doesn't effect the value?

In the late 90s I saw a MOC Glory on eBay.  Her bubble had yellowed--not unusual.  So then I read the auction description.  Wherein the seller said "I wasn't sure if the pony was still white inside the package, so I opened it.  Yep, still pure white!"

I then died inside.

Ouch!  :yikes:

If you think that's bad, a year or two ago there was the seller who opened a MIP Bobbie to get better auction pics.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Pumpkin_Tart on June 05, 2019, 04:21:18 PM
That's awful! Yikes! :shocked:
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Ponyfan on June 05, 2019, 04:38:09 PM
It happens a lot with NRFB dolls too. I've seen several sellers either say they removed everything for photos or they took everything out to make sure all of the accessories are in there.  :shocked:


I have the seller on my favorite sellers list and haven't seen any new listings from them for a while.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: applejackbunny on June 08, 2019, 07:17:36 AM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.



Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on June 08, 2019, 07:44:17 AM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.


For the most part, donating to charity shops, or auctions, these items will trickle down to collector's hands. Collectors are the only ones who really want these things.

I hope I don't burden my family members to much if/when they have to deal with my stuff. I could care less if they toss it, sell it, donate it-- I want them to do whatever is easiest for them.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: applejackbunny on June 08, 2019, 12:16:38 PM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.


For the most part, donating to charity shops, or auctions, these items will trickle down to collector's hands. Collectors are the only ones who really want these things.

I hope I don't burden my family members to much if/when they have to deal with my stuff. I could care less if they toss it, sell it, donate it-- I want them to do whatever is easiest for them.

Good point banditpony. I should have said to make sure your family are aware of your wishes and, more importantly, are happy to do this for you. Mine are.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on June 09, 2019, 02:58:08 PM
Most recent lot of Storage Locker Auctions have gone for $3,770.35 for a new overall total of $91,356.27
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: banditpony on June 09, 2019, 05:23:54 PM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.


For the most part, donating to charity shops, or auctions, these items will trickle down to collector's hands. Collectors are the only ones who really want these things.

I hope I don't burden my family members to much if/when they have to deal with my stuff. I could care less if they toss it, sell it, donate it-- I want them to do whatever is easiest for them.

Good point banditpony. I should have said to make sure your family are aware of your wishes and, more importantly, are happy to do this for you. Mine are.

I would say my family would do so. However, I have been in those shoes (finding good homes for things after a loved one has passed). It's certainly skewed my attitude about possessions. Heck, it skewed my attitude about gifts. That's why I said-- what ever is easiest for my family. :)

I have a friend who is dealing with a record and a coin collection... I dunno. :/ The time it's taking her (over a year), and the space it's taking (a whole room)... is a lot.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on June 10, 2019, 10:37:53 AM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.



For the most part, donating to charity shops, or auctions, these items will trickle down to collector's hands. Collectors are the only ones who really want these things.

I hope I don't burden my family members to much if/when they have to deal with my stuff. I could care less if they toss it, sell it, donate it-- I want them to do whatever is easiest for them.

Good point banditpony. I should have said to make sure your family are aware of your wishes and, more importantly, are happy to do this for you. Mine are.

I would say my family would do so. However, I have been in those shoes (finding good homes for things after a loved one has passed). It's certainly skewed my attitude about possessions. Heck, it skewed my attitude about gifts. That's why I said-- what ever is easiest for my family. :)

I have a friend who is dealing with a record and a coin collection... I dunno. :/ The time it's taking her (over a year), and the space it's taking (a whole room)... is a lot.

Yes!  Actually my grandfather had a magic collection- like original magic books, first editions, rare rare books- he was a magician and a very early member of the Magic Castle club - (which evidently was a big deal).

I'm sure the collection had value- but some of these things aren't supposed to be out of the hands of magicians-  and then there is the issue of FINDING someone who wants something so rare.

Finally my parents donated the entire collection to a magician whose mind was just blown to pieces.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: justinb on July 03, 2019, 10:09:44 AM
I'm late to the party, but does anybody know if there was a Baby Buggy for sale?
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Strawberry Swirl on July 03, 2019, 11:24:37 AM
I just thought of this after seeing this thread for the first time months ago, is mentioning shopgoodwill relevent to the convo? TBH I’ve seen lots there with plenty of gems. There was one with TWO Mimics once. Also a MOC Sweetheart Sister. Crazy that somebody would think to give that to a charity shop...
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on July 03, 2019, 02:31:27 PM
justinb - they've only just started listing playlets so there hasn't been a buggy yet.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on August 08, 2019, 06:56:33 AM
New total from the latest auctions:
$5739.01 in sales this round
Total: $99911.21

So the next lot will take it over $100k!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: LadyMoondancer on August 08, 2019, 08:22:13 AM
That was the luckiest storage unit find in the world.  :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on August 27, 2019, 09:53:40 AM
I think they've just relisted their first item. Baby Sunribbon looks the same as one that's been up before and sold.
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: BabyMoon on August 27, 2019, 06:25:24 PM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.



For the most part, donating to charity shops, or auctions, these items will trickle down to collector's hands. Collectors are the only ones who really want these things.

I hope I don't burden my family members to much if/when they have to deal with my stuff. I could care less if they toss it, sell it, donate it-- I want them to do whatever is easiest for them.

Good point banditpony. I should have said to make sure your family are aware of your wishes and, more importantly, are happy to do this for you. Mine are.

I would say my family would do so. However, I have been in those shoes (finding good homes for things after a loved one has passed). It's certainly skewed my attitude about possessions. Heck, it skewed my attitude about gifts. That's why I said-- what ever is easiest for my family. :)

I have a friend who is dealing with a record and a coin collection... I dunno. :/ The time it's taking her (over a year), and the space it's taking (a whole room)... is a lot.

Yes!  Actually my grandfather had a magic collection- like original magic books, first editions, rare rare books- he was a magician and a very early member of the Magic Castle club - (which evidently was a big deal).

I'm sure the collection had value- but some of these things aren't supposed to be out of the hands of magicians-  and then there is the issue of FINDING someone who wants something so rare.

Finally my parents donated the entire collection to a magician whose mind was just blown to pieces.

my great aunt was a doll collector and when she passed. my grandma and i were both set to the task of finding collectors who wanted all of these things. she had amazing dolls and hand traced patterns for sewing clothes. it was really heartbreaking for us to be unable to find collectors, we only got one self proclaimed collector to take a single trunk of them. i spent hours listing entire lots on ebay for cheap, we searched the whole county for anyone who might want some dolls.
we're still holding onto some things to see if we'll find anyone, and we've found use for the patterns and tools (very good stuff from the 50s and 60s) left behind. the whole process got me into collecting ponies, even though she didn't have any of those :P
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Galactica on August 30, 2019, 03:11:35 PM
Apologies if this has already been said (have not had time to read the whole thread!)  :P

This would be an absolute dream find for most of us here and I've been drooling over the videos and pics too  :dribble:

I think this is a stark lesson for all of us. If we wish our beloved collection to be dealt with in a specific way after our death, we should make a will stating those details.

I would hope that the executors of the will would then go to some lengths to carry out our wishes. For example, in my will I have specifically requested that all my ponies go to other collectors, rather than to charity shops or just disposed of.



For the most part, donating to charity shops, or auctions, these items will trickle down to collector's hands. Collectors are the only ones who really want these things.

I hope I don't burden my family members to much if/when they have to deal with my stuff. I could care less if they toss it, sell it, donate it-- I want them to do whatever is easiest for them.

Good point banditpony. I should have said to make sure your family are aware of your wishes and, more importantly, are happy to do this for you. Mine are.

I would say my family would do so. However, I have been in those shoes (finding good homes for things after a loved one has passed). It's certainly skewed my attitude about possessions. Heck, it skewed my attitude about gifts. That's why I said-- what ever is easiest for my family. :)

I have a friend who is dealing with a record and a coin collection... I dunno. :/ The time it's taking her (over a year), and the space it's taking (a whole room)... is a lot.

Yes!  Actually my grandfather had a magic collection- like original magic books, first editions, rare rare books- he was a magician and a very early member of the Magic Castle club - (which evidently was a big deal).

I'm sure the collection had value- but some of these things aren't supposed to be out of the hands of magicians-  and then there is the issue of FINDING someone who wants something so rare.

Finally my parents donated the entire collection to a magician whose mind was just blown to pieces.

my great aunt was a doll collector and when she passed. my grandma and i were both set to the task of finding collectors who wanted all of these things. she had amazing dolls and hand traced patterns for sewing clothes. it was really heartbreaking for us to be unable to find collectors, we only got one self proclaimed collector to take a single trunk of them. i spent hours listing entire lots on ebay for cheap, we searched the whole county for anyone who might want some dolls.
we're still holding onto some things to see if we'll find anyone, and we've found use for the patterns and tools (very good stuff from the 50s and 60s) left behind. the whole process got me into collecting ponies, even though she didn't have any of those :P

Hey, I know a doll collector-  me!  But seriously, what kind of dolls are they?  Like baby dolls from the 50s and 60s?

Are you really in WA?  Western WA?  You might want to try the "Teddy Bear and Doll show" in Puyallup-  most of the people who go collect older dolls and baby dolls.  You could even get a table there and sell stuff

https://www.google.com/search?q=washingotn+teddy+bear+and+doll+show&rlz=1C1GCEU_enUS821US821&oq=washingotn+teddy+bear+and+doll+show&aqs=chrome..69i57j33l5.6142j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&ibp=htl;events&rciv=evn&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjIpciHzqvkAhWrJzQIHe5zAsQQ5bwDMAB6BAgPEAE#fpstate=tldetail&htidocid=HGzcXqwYgn-vN7z7JpA8-A%3D%3D&htivrt=events
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: Chrissytree on September 01, 2019, 03:39:42 PM
New Storage Locker Auctions total has passed $100k!
This set have sold for $2056.66 for a new total of:
$101,967.87!
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: maycrestmom on September 07, 2019, 08:40:51 AM
holy moly whoa = this auction locker is still selling?

man...just that the family had no idea

crazy history in the making

thanks chrissytree for keeping tabs
Title: Re: Rare ponies on eBay?
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on September 07, 2019, 11:24:01 AM
definitely an interesting moment in pony history, that's for sure!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal