The MLP Arena
Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: Wardah on March 11, 2020, 09:22:47 AM
-
I know there's already a similar thread but that one included G1 which of course is an overwhelmingly popular answer considering many here started with it. But what I want to ask is what generation would you collect if you could only collect one other generation besides G1?
-
I put G3 as there are a lot of those ponies I like too. They also look the most like ponies to me.
-
Ooooo tough choice between g2 and g3. But I ended up choosing g2 :)
-
I'd rather collect g3 anyway so of course my answer here was no different!
-
Hard question, but I have more G3s, so probably G3. But I would hate to lose my almost-childhood from-new G2s...:/ I am very attached to Berry Bright.
-
I put G3 as there are a lot of those ponies I like too. They also look the most like ponies to me.
Same.
-
oh, so G1 + another gen? G2, because of my beloved Ivy. Didn't even have to think of it.
I mean, I'd be sad to lose my G3s and G4s too, but... Ivy....
-
G4! My answer from before.
-
I hit G3 because of HQG1C. Their wingless flutters are the same size & age as the G2s, & by taking a mould off a Peek-A-Boo or Playtime Brother it can't be too hard to give furry hooves to some to make Boys.
Anyway, there's also the fact G3 have fewer silly motion things going on, as well as more variety in their Ponies. I do love my G2s, but I know I loved G3s almost as soon as they came out & my first G3 was Daisyjo bought new in a shop. They're a huge part of my Ponyworld, along with their playsets (supermarket, nightclub, island paradise, fairground etc).
Wasn't easy though but they were the main parts of my decision. If only G2 didn't have that horrible Light Heart who goes wi the bed!!! That unyielding plastic!!!
-
I haven’t posted in that other thread, but my favorite (even when including G1) is G3, so that’s what I’m going with.
-
I'd go for G3's, I regret not buying more when they were in the store...
-
Well, I voted that G3 would be the only Gen I would collect if I could only collect one in the other topic, so this one is pretty easy for me! G3!
Personally, I don't find the G2s appealing. The G4s are kind of cute but not enough to buy any.
-
G2. Although I wish there were more to get in the line.
-
G3! I'm actually re starting my g3 collection from when I was a kid.
I adore the g3 ponies I just purchased moondancer complete with all her cool accessories, so excited! So much childhood nostalgia.
Shes a strangely colourless pony yet I remember she was a favourite of mine x
-
It's be a race between G2 and G3... but I'd go straight after a G2 before a G3 lol
-
G3 because they were close enough to G1 and I actually liked some of their animated appearances
-
G3 by far - they were the most beautiful in my opinion, and were the ones I admire the most along side G1 anyway.
I love G4 as a show, and I do have some of the toys, but there is less to them, and I don't need several versions of the same character.
I really need to research G2 more, but I do like them.
G1 and G3 are my favorite toylines despite not owning any - both are beautiful, and G1 is really imaginative and nostalgic sounding, that I really wish I grew up with it.
-
G2, because they got me into pony collecting as an adult, I like their designs (even if their bodies are a bit weird), and I love their play sets and accessories. I wish I’d bought more of them back when they were cheap and plentiful and very few collectors were after them.
Elf