collapse

* Navigation

* User Info

 
 
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

* Who's Online

Author Topic: The Ultimate This or That  (Read 1409 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Artemesia's Garden

  • Trade Count: (+26)
  • MIB Rapunzel Pony
  • *****
  • Posts: 5742
  • Flicker Flame... Thanks to Brightberry!
    • View Profile
    • Things I make and Do
Re: The Ultimate This or That
« Reply #15 on: November 07, 2021, 02:18:36 AM »

Battle of the fruits, part 1:
Applejack vs Cherry Treats
Applejack

Battle of the fruits, part 2:
Scrumptious vs Tootie Tails/Sumer Heatwave
Tootie Tails

Battle of the fruits, part 3:
Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair vs Blueberry Baskets
Strawberry Fair

Battle of the fruits, part 4:
Cherries Jubilee vs Strawberry Surprise
Cherries Jubilee

Battle of the candies, part 1:
Tootsie vs Sweet Tooth/Lollipop
Tootsie

Battle of the candies, part 2:
Taffy vs TAF Yum Yum
Yum Yum

Battle of the candies, part 3:
Sweet Stuff/Sweetie vs Mint Dreams
Sweetie

Battle of the baked treats:
Cupcake vs Lemon Treats
Lemon Treats

Battle of the ice cream cones:
Lickety Split vs Swirly Whirly/Butter Kiss
Lickety Split

Battle of the ice cream treats:
Fizzy vs Scoops
Fizzy

Battle of the gingerbread men:
Gingerbread vs Molasses
Gingerbread

Battle of the salty snacks:
Twist vs Munchie
Twist lol

Battle of the dogs:
SS Fifi vs Squeezer
Fifi

Battle of the cats:
Pink Dreams vs Tabby
Baby Katie?

Battle of the bunnies:
Hippity Hop vs Romper
Hippity

Battle of the ducks:
Sprinkles vs Quackers
Sprinkles

Battle of the butterflies:
Flutterby vs Dancing Butterflies
Hard one! Dancing Butterflies

Battle of the tropical fish:
Angel vs Sea Breeze/Surfing Days
Angel

Battle of the tropical birds:
Mimic vs Tropical Breeze
Tropical breeze

Battle of the seashells:
Seashell vs Sea F
Seashell

Battle of the gardeners:
Posey vs Trickles
Posey

Battle of the palm trees:
Paradise vs Pina Colada/(Hulu Hula in the UK)
Pins Colada

Battle of the clouds:
Cloud Puff vs Cloud Dreamer
Cloud Dreamer

Battle of the snow:
Powder vs Snowflake
Powder although I love Snowflake

Battle of the smiling suns:
Shoreline vs Sunspot
Sunspot

Battle of the planets:
Moonstone vs Night Glider
Moonstone

Battle of the intergalactic:
Galaxy vs Milky Way
Galaxy

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 1:
Skyflier vs Lofty
Skyflier

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 2:
Pinwheel vs Wind Drifter
Pinwheel

Battle of the umbrellas:
Parasol vs Dazzle Glow
Really hard! Parasol

Battle of the balloons:
Surprise vs Up Up and Away
Up up and away

Battle of the boats
Hula Hula/(Sail Away in the UK) vs Mainsail
Mainsail... Daddy Sunbright?

Battle of the hats:
Bonnie Bonnets vs Bouquet
Bouquet

Battle of the Bows:
Bowtie vs Ribbon
Ribbon

Battle of the music:
Medley vs Streaky/Rainbow Rider
Medley

Battle of the hearts:
Heart Throb vs Love Melody
I love both. Heart Throb.

Battle of the Buttons (literally!):
SS Buttons vs TAF Buttons
Nss buttons for me please!

Battle of the beach balls:
Bouncy vs Beach Ball
Beach Ball

Battle of the schoolyard games:

Skippity Doo vs Hopscotch
Hopscotch

Battle of the inanimate Beauty and the Beast characters:
SS Twilight vs Bright Eyes
SS Twilight

Battle of the mirrors:
Mirror Mirror vs Pretty Vision
Pretty vision

Battle of the magics:
Magic Hat vs Magic Star
Magic Star
« Last Edit: November 07, 2021, 02:30:24 AM by Artemesia's Garden »
:heart: ISO G1 Daffodil, upgrade for June Rose; G1 Waterfall blue towel, G1 Waterfall bubbles bottle with white writing; Perfume Puff Palace green hat, pink bracelet and mesh scarves, glitter combs for SHS, lace scarves for SHS, G3 Flower Wishes and Candy Cane, Baby Northern Lights...Accessories from FiM Collection Canterlot Castle: Tirek's staff, Phoenix and stand, open book :heart: Pony Page :heart: Wish List :heart:

Offline CherryTreats

  • Trade Count: (+34)
  • Dazzle Surprise
  • ****
  • Posts: 748
  • Gender: Female
    • View Profile
Re: The Ultimate This or That
« Reply #16 on: November 07, 2021, 08:43:41 AM »
Battle of the fruits, part 1:
Cherry Treats

Battle of the fruits, part 2:
Tootie Tails/Summer Heatwave

Battle of the fruits, part 3:
Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair

Battle of the fruits, part 4:
Strawberry Surprise

Battle of the candies, part 1:
Sweet Tooth/Lollipop

Battle of the candies, part 2:
TAF Yum Yum

Battle of the candies, part 3:
Sweet Stuff/Sweetie

Battle of the baked treats:
Cupcake

Battle of the ice cream cones:
Lickety Split

Battle of the ice cream treats:
Fizzy

Battle of the gingerbread men:
Gingerbread

Battle of the salty snacks:
Twist

Battle of the dogs:
SS Fifi

Battle of the cats:
Tabby

Battle of the bunnies:
Hippity Hop

Battle of the ducks:
Quackers

Battle of the butterflies:
Flutterby

Battle of the tropical fish:
Angel

Battle of the tropical birds:
Mimic

Battle of the seashells:
Seashell

Battle of the gardeners:
Trickles

Battle of the palm trees:
Paradise

Battle of the clouds:
Cloud Puff

Battle of the snow:
Powder

Battle of the smiling suns:
Sunspot

Battle of the planets:
Night Glider

Battle of the intergalactic:
Galaxy

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 1:
Skyflier

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 2:
Pinwheel

Battle of the umbrellas:
Parasol

Battle of the balloons:
Surprise

Battle of the boats
Mainsail

Battle of the hats:
Bouquet

Battle of the Bows:
Bowtie

Battle of the music:
Medley

Battle of the hearts:
Love Melody

Battle of the Buttons (literally!):
TAF Buttons

Battle of the beach balls:
Bouncy

Battle of the schoolyard games:

Hopscotch

Battle of the inanimate Beauty and the Beast characters:
Bright Eyes

Battle of the mirrors:
Pretty Vision

Battle of the magics:
Magic Star

Offline Ponyfan

  • Trade Count: (+39)
  • MIB Licensing Show Pinkie Pie
  • ******
  • Posts: 13778
    • View Profile
Re: The Ultimate This or That
« Reply #17 on: November 07, 2021, 02:21:02 PM »



Battle of the fruits, part 1:
Applejack

Battle of the fruits, part 2:
Tootie Tails/Sumer Heatwave

Battle of the fruits, part 3:

Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair vs Blueberry Baskets

I can't answer this one because I love both of these ponies. :D


Battle of the fruits, part 4:

Strawberry Surprise

Battle of the candies, part 1:
Sweet Tooth/Lollipop

Battle of the candies, part 2:
TAF Yum Yum

Battle of the candies, part 3:
Mint Dreams

Battle of the baked treats:
Lemon Treats

Battle of the ice cream cones:

Lickety Split

Battle of the ice cream treats:
Fizzy

Battle of the gingerbread men:
Gingerbread

Battle of the salty snacks:
Munchie

Battle of the dogs:
SS Fifi

Battle of the cats:
Tabby

Battle of the bunnies:
Hippity Hop

Battle of the ducks:
Quackers

Battle of the butterflies:
Dancing Butterflies


Battle of the tropical fish:

Sea Breeze/Surfing Days

Battle of the tropical birds:

Tropical Breeze

Battle of the seashells:
Sea Flower

Battle of the gardeners:
Trickles

Battle of the palm trees:

Pina Colada/(Hulu Hula in the UK)

Battle of the clouds:
Cloud Puff

Battle of the snow:

Snowflake

Battle of the smiling suns:
Sunspot

Battle of the planets:

Night Glider

Battle of the intergalactic:
 Milky Way

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 1:
Lofty

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 2:
Pinwheel

Battle of the umbrellas:

Dazzle Glow

Battle of the balloons:

Up Up and Away

Battle of the boats
Hula Hula/(Sail Away in the UK)

Battle of the hats:
Bonnie Bonnets

Battle of the Bows:

Bowtie

Battle of the music:
Medley

Battle of the hearts:
Love Melody

Battle of the Buttons (literally!):
SS Buttons

Battle of the beach balls:
Beach Ball

Battle of the schoolyard games:
 Hopscotch

Battle of the inanimate Beauty and the Beast characters:
SS Twilight

Battle of the mirrors:

Pretty Vision

Battle of the magics:

Magic Star



Ponyfan
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Thank you SDS for my avatar and sig

Offline WaterDraw

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Brush N Grow Pony
  • ***
  • Posts: 314
  • Gender: Female
  • Back from the dead
    • View Profile
Re: The Ultimate This or That
« Reply #18 on: November 07, 2021, 10:45:36 PM »
Battle of the fruits part one:
Applejack (would've been Cherry Treats if she didn't fade to that off-white so easily :( )

Battle of the fruits part two:
Scrumptious

Battle of the fruits part three:
Blueberry Baskets

Battle of the fruits part four:
Strawberry Surprise

Battle of the candies part one:
Sweet Tooth (although I don't particularly care for either one...)

Battle of the candies part two:
TAF Yum Yum

Battles of the candies part three:
Mint Dreams

Battle of the Baked Treats:
Lemon Treats (although I don't really care for either once again  >_< )

Battle of the ice cream cones:
Lickity Split

Battle of the ice cream treats:
Fizzy

Battle of the Gingerbread men:
This one was hard! Although I love love love Gingerbread's color scheme, I can't get over the fact of how easily she discolors/hardens. I'm not as in love with Molasses, however she doesn't have as many problems as Gingerbread plus I like her gingerbread cutie mark more...In the end I think I'll go with Gingerbread, especially since she's going to be reproduced soon so I can get one who is white and still squishy!  :P

Battle of the Salty Snacks:
Another hard one! I'm gonna have to go with Twist though as her deep purple is gorgeous

Battle of the Dogs:
Squeezer

Battle of the cats:
Pink Dreams (although they're both gorgeous...can you tell I'm a cat person?  :satisfied: )

Battle of the bunnies:
Hippity Hop (i really like both their color schemes tho)

Battle of the ducks:
Quackers, hands down

Battle of the butterflies:
Flutterbye I guess...I just don't care for either and I can't find anything I like about either...Flutterbye barely won just because yellow is my least favorite color

Battle of the tropical fish:
Angel (although Sea Breeze looks more tropical!  :lol: )

Battle of the tropical birds:
Oddly enough you'd think this one would be easy for me given my icon and Mimic being my favorite pony ever, however Tropical Breeze is my favorite flutter pony ever and has one of my favorite animals as her cutie mark  :shocked: I'm picking Mimic as the winner though simply just because Tropical Breeze can discolor to that ugly navy-ish color

Battle of the seashells:
Seashell

Battle of the gardeners:
Trickles only if her cutie mark was in pristine condition :)

Battle of the palm trees:
Pina Colada

Battle of the clouds:
Cloud Puff

Battle of the snow:
Powder (she's in my second favorite unicorn pose!) although I do really love snowflake

Battle of the smiling suns:
Shoreline although I don't like either  :huh:

Battle of the planets:
Night Glider

Battle of the intergalactic:
Gee this ones hard...Milky Way only because she's in my favorite unicorn pose!

Battle of the wind-powered objects part 1:
Lofty

Battle of the wind-powered objects part 2:
Pinwheel

Battle of the umbrellas:
Dazzleglow

Battle of the Balloons:
Up, Up, and Away

Battle of the boats:
Hula Hula

Battle of the hats:
Bouquet

Battle of the Bows:
Ribbon

Battle of the music:
Streaky

Battle of the hearts:
Love Melody

Battle of Buttons (Literally):
I like both but probably SS buttons

Battle of the beach balls:
Beach Ball

Battle of schoolyard games:
Hopscotch (I am biased)

Battle of inanimate BB characters:
OMG THIS ONE IS SUPER HARD...SS Twilight ONLY if she's deflocked with her hair still pink

Battle of the mirrors:
Mirror Mirror

Battle of the Magics:
Magic hat
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Mimic drawn by me~
Inspired by one of the Fluttershy redesigns and The Last Unicorn

Offline FernMariposa919

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Target Exclusive Winter Pony
  • ****
  • Posts: 598
  • Gender: Female
    • View Profile
Re: The Ultimate This or That
« Reply #19 on: November 13, 2021, 11:13:36 AM »
Alright, I'm finally doing this; might as well since I made it!

Battle of the fruits, part 1:
Applejack vs Cherry Treats - Applejack is a childhood pony, not to mention an iconic pony. Looking back, I probably should have pitted her against Cherries Jubilee. (No pun intended).

Battle of the fruits, part 2:
Scrumptious vs Tootie Tails/Sumer Heatwave - Scrumptious is cute, but I really love the tropical ponies. Also, I would probably chose a pineapple over a watermelon if offered  :lol:

Battle of the fruits, part 3:
Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair vs Blueberry Baskets - I really love Sugarberry's colors and design.

Battle of the fruits, part 4:
Cherries Jubilee vs Strawberry Surprise - Gotta go with the classic pony.

Battle of the candies, part 1:
Tootsie vs Sweet Tooth/Lollipop - As much as I've come around to Tootsie, I like Sweet Tooth's colors and design just a tad more.

Battle of the candies, part 2:
Taffy vs TAF Yum Yum

Battle of the candies, part 3:
Sweet Stuff/Sweetie vs Mint Dreams - more often than not, TEs will always win out!

Battle of the baked treats:
Cupcake vs Lemon Treats

Battle of the ice cream cones:
Lickety Split vs Swirly Whirly/Butter Kiss - again, gotta go with there classic pony.

Battle of the ice cream treats:
Fizzy vs Scoops - I love Scoops and her playset, but Fizzy is my favorite pony of all time!

Battle of the gingerbread men:
Gingerbread vs Molasses - No contest!

Battle of the salty snacks:
Twist vs Munchie - I still think Munchie is an odd pony with her hot dog symbols, but I am starting to come around to her. However, I went with Twist. I think she has a cute name and I like her pretzel symbols.

Battle of the dogs:
SS Fifi vs Squeezer - I don't understand why Squeezer is called Squeezer. That makes no sense to me. At least Fifi is more of a name a dog would have, especially a poodle as depicted on SS Fifi. I also like Fifi's colors better.

Battle of the cats:
Pink Dreams vs Tabby - Even though I'm not the biggest fan of flutters (their wings break off too easily), I went with Pink Dreams because I like her colors and her cat design better than Tabby.

Battle of the bunnies:
Hippity Hop vs Romper - This one was a bit difficult since they were both childhood ponies (and of course there were bffs!) but I chose Romper since I had fun with her tail mechanism.

Battle of the ducks:
Sprinkles vs Quackers - again, no contest. Quackers is a GORGEOUS pony and Sprinkles has the most dull beige color. Quackers has a fun duck symbol and Sprinkles' duck symbols are a bit ho hum. (Though I did love her playset!)

Battle of the butterflies:
Flutterby vs Dancing Butterflies - I'm not the biggest fan of her pose, but I like DB's colors and butterfly designs better than Flutterby's.

Battle of the tropical fish:
Angel vs Sea Breeze/Surfing Days - This one was hard because as I mentioned before, I do love tropical ponies and the one with tropical fish should win this for me, but I love the symbol design for Angel. I also like that she's blue so it looks like the fish are swimming in the sea. When she's deflocked, her design really pops.

Battle of the tropical birds:
Mimic vs Tropical Breeze - Tropical Breeze was a childhood pony of mine and she's my favorite flutter pony, but that being said, I had to go with Mimic. I love her colors and she's a TE which already puts her towards the top.

Battle of the seashells:
Seashell vs Sea Flower - I went with the classic, plus I like her green and purple coloring.

Battle of the gardeners:
Posey vs Trickles - A little tricky. They're both yellow trotting ponies. However, I went with Trickles because of her rainbow tail and mane and I love her watering cans symbols. It's something we haven't seen before and as much as I love Posey (another classic pony), there's many ponies with flower symbols.

Battle of the palm trees:
Paradise vs Pina Colada/(Hulu Hula in the UK) - Paradise was a childhood pony, but I went with Pina Colada because I prefer her colors and palm tree design a tad more over Paradises's. Sorry, Paradise!

Battle of the clouds:
Cloud Puff vs Cloud Dreamer - I know I said I didn't care for flutters, but I like Magic Message ponies even less (with a couple exceptions), so I chose the flutter in this scenario.

Battle of the snow:
Powder vs Snowflake

Battle of the smiling suns:
Shoreline vs Sunspot -Even though Shoreline was a childhood pony and orange isn't my favorite color for ponies, there's something so aesthetically pleasing about Sunspot.

Battle of the planets:
Moonstone vs Night Glider - This was a close one!

Battle of the intergalactic:
Galaxy vs Milky Way - I do like Milky Way, but Galaxy is a childhood pony!

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 1:
Skyflier vs Lofty

Battle of the wind-powered objects, part 2:
Pinwheel vs Wind Drifter

Battle of the umbrellas:
Parasol vs Dazzle Glow

Battle of the balloons:
Surprise vs Up Up and Away

Battle of the boats
Hula Hula/(Sail Away in the UK) vs Mainsail

Battle of the hats:
Bonnie Bonnets vs Bouquet - I think BB is adorable and I love her name!

Battle of the Bows:
Bowtie vs Ribbon

Battle of the music:
Medley vs Streaky/Rainbow Rider - I don't understand why Streaky is name Streaky. At least Rainbow Rider is a tad better, but still doesn't have anything to do with music. Why not name her Concerto or Maestro or Treble or something to do with music? But Streaky??? Terrible name. However, I chose Medley because she's a classic pony and part of my childhood herd.

Battle of the hearts:
Heart Throb vs Love Melody

Battle of the Buttons (literally!):
SS Buttons vs TAF Buttons

Battle of the beach balls:
Bouncy vs Beach Ball

Battle of the schoolyard games:

Skippity Doo vs Hopscotch

Battle of the inanimate Beauty and the Beast characters:
SS Twilight vs Bright Eyes

Battle of the mirrors:
Mirror Mirror vs Pretty Vision

Battle of the magics:
Magic Hat vs Magic Star - Love her as a so soft or a "movie star" pony. Love her in the rearing pose or Tootsie pose.


Battle of the inanimate Beauty and the Beast characters: Love this question! Great idea for a pair-up! SS Twilight for me.

Haha, thanks! I was pretty proud of thinking up this pair up!  :lol:




 

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal