We've done a huge purge on accounts that haven't been touched in over 5 years! If you're a returning member and can't login please email mlpchief @ gmail.com for more details!
Site Announcements Arena Tutorials Sigs & Site Support Introductions Pony Corral Swap Talk! Pony Fairs! MLP Nirvana Nirvana Sales Pony Brag Arena Off Topic Dollhouse Toy Box & Games Cupboard Customs Custom Sales Arts & Crafts Corral Adoptables For Sale - For Auction For Trade Wanted Trader & Classifieds Support What's Your Problem Private Messages Contact Us!
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
SpoilerI have to say the designs of the teen witches and Trench as ponies really annoy me... I felt the same about Tempest's design in the G4 movie. It seems like all the OC "edgy, cool" ponysonas that people make online.
Well the digital has a three page preview of the 4th comic… ….it’s…SpoilerNOT GOOD or well I hated it. Of course they sound like G4 with a G1 look WHY ARE THEY WALKING ON A RAINBOW??? That part I hate a lot too. They aren’t Starlite…More detail if you don’t want to know about it early?Spoiler and WHY WHHHYYYY is Bonbon there?!?!! And G3 Minty.. I guess G3’s would be fine BUT DONT ADD TALES!! They don’t make sense to be a part of that world then Megan is in her first special outfit fighting smooze I’m afraid what more they added. And Surprise narrating the story, I don’t see her saying supreme bummer and going “Like totally lame!” Now I’m hoping those are the only instances but I’m fearing the worst kinda makes her sound ‘valley girl’? UGH!!I don’t know anymore…
Quote from: Wildshadow on January 14, 2022, 08:39:47 PMWell the digital has a three page preview of the 4th comic… ….it’s…SpoilerNOT GOOD or well I hated it. Of course they sound like G4 with a G1 look WHY ARE THEY WALKING ON A RAINBOW??? That part I hate a lot too. They aren’t Starlite…More detail if you don’t want to know about it early?Spoiler and WHY WHHHYYYY is Bonbon there?!?!! And G3 Minty.. I guess G3’s would be fine BUT DONT ADD TALES!! They don’t make sense to be a part of that world then Megan is in her first special outfit fighting smooze I’m afraid what more they added. And Surprise narrating the story, I don’t see her saying supreme bummer and going “Like totally lame!” Now I’m hoping those are the only instances but I’m fearing the worst kinda makes her sound ‘valley girl’? UGH!!I don’t know anymore… Still haven't read it, but...SpoilerWhile I'd sort of get it, if it is what I said it was before (i.e. Mane Six meets Concept Six rather than G4 meets G1, although it seems like it's supposed to be the latter and then some) I do agree that it's a shame if the G1s that were the Concept Six sound like their G4 "counter parts" (unless I misunderstood that part) - if that's what they chose to do, then fine, but when I use those characters, they aren't going to act like the Mane Six - they don't need to act like them, I have the Mane Six for that, and they aren't the Concept Six in what I'm writing, they are G1 characters (or references to them) - the closest they get to being the Concept Six is that they are going to team up in at least one episode, but that's more of a shout out to the Concept Six than anything.As for Surprise... yeah, she isn't the pony I would have imagined with Valley Girl speak... I could do my usual thing, and just say that this is a "this" Surprise thing, but if the point is to bring G1s and G3s over then, it makes more sense for them to act in someway that is closer to how they did there? Interpretations aside...?(I'm trying my hardest not to sound a hypocrite with my project, since there will be creative licence with all generations I use...)Also... I actually do find Tales making sense as part of the FiM world, no offense, but I always felt like they were easy to imagine in Equestria... all pre-G4s are in my mind, but I always felt Tales fit in relatively easily - I know they have cars and that, but I always felt that was easy to overlook if you were putting them in a G4 (or even a G3, G3.5 or earlier G1, and probably even a G2) world, so they wouldn't be aware of cars etc. unless the story was that they'd litterally gone from their own world to the other one.That said, I think I have a different look toward Tales, like I've seen people essentially say that the show isn't "My Little Pony" enough, and that you could make them any other animal (including humans) and nothing would change, and there's not enough fantasy to it (I think that's been said), but I never felt that... it is very MLP to me, and I can see the fantasy potential in it.Also... I may be wrong, but I could have sworn that ponies walking a rainbow was a G1 thing, or another pre-G4 thing? Like I feel that it may be a comic book or a backcard story? I'm not sure, but it feels more pre-G4 than G4, even with the whole "Pegasi can live in clouds" thing...Maybe it's because Firefly and Medley slid down a rainbow in the first episode/special? I just feel that walking on rainbows has been done before...(Just Realized: I may be thinking of "Best Friends Until the End of Time", which was a G4 thing, but I might not be...)
Quote from: MJNSEIFER on January 15, 2022, 09:11:17 AMQuote from: Wildshadow on January 14, 2022, 08:39:47 PMWell the digital has a three page preview of the 4th comic… ….it’s…SpoilerNOT GOOD or well I hated it. Of course they sound like G4 with a G1 look WHY ARE THEY WALKING ON A RAINBOW??? That part I hate a lot too. They aren’t Starlite…More detail if you don’t want to know about it early?Spoiler and WHY WHHHYYYY is Bonbon there?!?!! And G3 Minty.. I guess G3’s would be fine BUT DONT ADD TALES!! They don’t make sense to be a part of that world then Megan is in her first special outfit fighting smooze I’m afraid what more they added. And Surprise narrating the story, I don’t see her saying supreme bummer and going “Like totally lame!” Now I’m hoping those are the only instances but I’m fearing the worst kinda makes her sound ‘valley girl’? UGH!!I don’t know anymore… Still haven't read it, but...SpoilerWhile I'd sort of get it, if it is what I said it was before (i.e. Mane Six meets Concept Six rather than G4 meets G1, although it seems like it's supposed to be the latter and then some) I do agree that it's a shame if the G1s that were the Concept Six sound like their G4 "counter parts" (unless I misunderstood that part) - if that's what they chose to do, then fine, but when I use those characters, they aren't going to act like the Mane Six - they don't need to act like them, I have the Mane Six for that, and they aren't the Concept Six in what I'm writing, they are G1 characters (or references to them) - the closest they get to being the Concept Six is that they are going to team up in at least one episode, but that's more of a shout out to the Concept Six than anything.As for Surprise... yeah, she isn't the pony I would have imagined with Valley Girl speak... I could do my usual thing, and just say that this is a "this" Surprise thing, but if the point is to bring G1s and G3s over then, it makes more sense for them to act in someway that is closer to how they did there? Interpretations aside...?(I'm trying my hardest not to sound a hypocrite with my project, since there will be creative licence with all generations I use...)Also... I actually do find Tales making sense as part of the FiM world, no offense, but I always felt like they were easy to imagine in Equestria... all pre-G4s are in my mind, but I always felt Tales fit in relatively easily - I know they have cars and that, but I always felt that was easy to overlook if you were putting them in a G4 (or even a G3, G3.5 or earlier G1, and probably even a G2) world, so they wouldn't be aware of cars etc. unless the story was that they'd litterally gone from their own world to the other one.That said, I think I have a different look toward Tales, like I've seen people essentially say that the show isn't "My Little Pony" enough, and that you could make them any other animal (including humans) and nothing would change, and there's not enough fantasy to it (I think that's been said), but I never felt that... it is very MLP to me, and I can see the fantasy potential in it.Also... I may be wrong, but I could have sworn that ponies walking a rainbow was a G1 thing, or another pre-G4 thing? Like I feel that it may be a comic book or a backcard story? I'm not sure, but it feels more pre-G4 than G4, even with the whole "Pegasi can live in clouds" thing...Maybe it's because Firefly and Medley slid down a rainbow in the first episode/special? I just feel that walking on rainbows has been done before...(Just Realized: I may be thinking of "Best Friends Until the End of Time", which was a G4 thing, but I might not be...)NOOO!! Ugh lost my long reply and got to do it all over SpoilerLet’s try this again… But first, the dialogue they already have Galaxy saying just feels G4 because they made her say “everypony”….anyway.I forgot to say my reasoning of being annoyed with the rainbow stuff. If it was only Pegasi and flutter ponies on it then the rainbow walking I could understand cause the flutter ponies did on that fake rainbow and Surprise on the frozen rainbow and now realizing I forgot about firefly and medley. Flying types.BUT thinking about it now I’d understand if it’s THE Rainbow of Light they are all walking on. Then I’d be ok with it I love Tales, just at the time I saw it, Bonbon/Tales was the furthest ponies I’d see being used in the comic. But now thinking on it, Patch seems the one they should have used but reading Carrehz post, it’s probably why they used Bonbon in the first place there’s a moment pinkie pie brings up aliens and bonbon says she loves aliens….I feel that’s Patch not Bonbon, I don’t think Bonbon has ever mentioned aliens?? ……As of the possible start of this issue? they don’t interact with their counterparts, so far only Surprise shows up and “surprises!” her way into taking over North Star’s recounting the Witches story to Twilight and Co. at which that’s the end of the preview. So I’m thinking Surprise might finish the tale? They don’t even bother twinkle eyeing Galaxy, they only add a star in her eye. Oh boy, can’t wait until the 26th to be even more annoyed and unimpressed!