Least fave pony friend?

[SkyCakes]

I would go with Edgar... someone on the boards said something silly along the lines that he looked like Trump. I can't unsee that now so I giggle everytime I see him in the ponyroom.

[northstar3184]

Where is the option for all of them?

Haha, I'd probably chose that if that were an option! I've never been overly fond of the pony friends.

I share the sentiments expressed here.

[tailrustedtealeaf]

I went with Edgar.

I would go with Edgar... someone on the boards said something silly along the lines that he looked like Trump. I can't unsee that now so I giggle everytime I see him in the ponyroom.

Yes I was about to cite this as my reason! I just can't shake it out of my head!

[Leave a Whisper]

I guess Wooly

[Carrehz]

Edgar for me too, not really an elephant person and something about his colours just rubs me the wrong way. (Also I can't unsee the Trump thing now! Eek!!)

I don't really care for Cutesaurus either (I'm just not a dinosaur person), but eh, she's grown on me a bit.

[StillandSilent]

Kingsley.  I don't care much for the mold, and he's so freaking monochrome pink.   They missed an opportunity for some different colors that would have made him stand out.

[nessa16]

I went with Edgar.

I would go with Edgar... someone on the boards said something silly along the lines that he looked like Trump. I can't unsee that now so I giggle everytime I see him in the ponyroom.

Yes I was about to cite this as my reason! I just can't shake it out of my head!

Haha, good thing I have no interest in him.  I would probably have to kick him out of the pony room.  I picked Spunky, even though I just bought her/him(?).  Not sure what made me get him but he just looks so awkward.  I am not that fond of Edgar or Oakly either.  I am kind of surprised that Kingsley is one of the least liked.  My cousin had him as a kid, so I just accept and like him due to that, I suppose.  I had Creamsicle as a kid, found her at a thrift store.  I did not know for sure that she was MLP, I just knew she resembled them and had similar eyes.  I would not pass up Cha Cha or Cutesaurus at a good price, but not actively looking for them. 

[RLisa]

Eventually I'd like to get them all but if I had to nitpick my vote goes to Edgar.
For some reason the design of manes on an elephant looks weird to me. Even in MLP world it's a bit too much, like he's wearing a wig.

[LadyMoondancer]

I love them all, but Zig Zag seems like a weird choice for a pony friend.  Like do you really need a separate zebra toy in a line that is 99% ponies?  Just seems like they could have subbed in something more unique.  They had a lion, so how about a wolf or a bear or a peacock or something?  (My concept for a peacock:  molded tail, painted.  The brushable hair would be on his head.  Basically like Fairy Tail birds but a longer neck and smaller head.)

Also this thread has ruined Edgar for me, lol!  But that's okay, I don't have him anyway.  I hate that his name is just "Edgar".  Seriously?  Call him Peanut or Trunks or something.

[dragonlady]

Also Oakly DOES have ears! I didn't even realize until I was looking at pictures of him. They're behind the antlers.

Holy cow, he does!! Took me a while to find a pic that showed them. Thanks for the info!!

[caseysealia]

I love them all but I voted Kingsley. She's just...All pink.

[ZeldaTheSwordsman]

I voted for Nectar. Nectar is still cute and all, but the sculpt and the smooth edges of the white paint make it look like the white part of the body is clothes instead of different-colored fur. If the edges were more naturally fuzzy it would look better.

[Carrehz]

I think the "problem" with Edgar's hair is the colour. I mean, the hair looks weird anyway on an elephant, but it might've looked less weird if it wasn't so...... blonde. Or maybe if he just had a little tuft of hair, like the baby pony pals.

I picked Spunky, even though I just bought her/him(?). 

"Her" according to her backcard :B the only boys in the line are Edgar and Oakly (yes, Kingsley is a girl!!).

Well, the first two lines, anyway. Dunno about the Pretty Pals cause the only backcard for those that mentions a pronoun is Hoppy... the one whose gender is obvious anyway cause of her pouch. x)

Also Oakly DOES have ears! I didn't even realize until I was looking at pictures of him. They're behind the antlers.

Holy cow, he does!! Took me a while to find a pic that showed them. Thanks for the info!!

Does anyone have a pic of his ears??? I thought he was earless, too!!

[LadyMoondancer]

You can see his ears in one of the pictures on this site:

https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/little-pony-oakley-moose-vintage-g1-1817083182

The funniest thing about this is his backcard story is about the ponies asking him why his ears are so funny-looking!  And then he tells them they're antlers.

[mlp4me]

They're all so cute though!
Kingsley is at the bottom of the list for me...