Oooh, fun thread! I love stuff like this. Let's see...
1. Night Glider or MunchyNight Glider, no context. Not a fan of Munchy.
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TEMimic, cause I don't particularly care for either and I'd get more money reselling her
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target SnowflakeSnowflake!!!
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzzhmmm tough choice... I love Honeybuzz, but Feathermay's cute too... Now, is this a perfect, pristine Feathermay with a matching head/body (aka That Which Does Not Exist), or a normal Feathermay with head/body mismatch?
If it's the former, oh, definitely Feathermay. Otherwise I think I'd go for Honeybuzz.
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper GlowHad to google Waterlily, I wasn't familiar with her. Definitely Copper Glow! She's so gorgeous, whereas Waterlily's kinda meh. (don't get me wrong, I'd still like her
but you get what I mean)
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)(I'm assuming that means both of them are NBBE, not just Ribbon) REALLY tough choice, but I'm going with Baby Ribbon since she was one of my first G1s.
7. Rapunzel or Sweet ScoopsGotta be honest, I've never seen the appeal in Punzie, and Sweet Scoops isn't that thrilling, either.. mhhh... I'll go for SS, she's cute enough.
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)not a SS fan, so I'd go for Fizzy here. If it was NSS Wind Whistler though, then she'd win by a mile.
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry BasketsBlueberry Baskets, I guess. Pristina's kinda garish.
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)Red Roses, solely cause I'm not a fan of the transparent ponies. I don't care for Perfume Puffs either, though, so she'd be sold on.
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?honestly don't care for either of these... which one goes for more?
Um, Lemon I guess.
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?now, is this a deflocked Taffy, or is her flocking intact?
assuming the latter... ehh... Quackers. I'm not a SS person, and I'd feel bad deflocking one in pristine condition.
13. TAF Ribbon (Note, I think this should be TAF Buttons?) or MGR Sparkler?Buttons! MGRs aren't really my thing, and I think TAF Buttons is adorable.
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click?Honestly, I love ALL G2 babies and I really can't pick between these four... I'd have to pick by Eeny-meeny-miney-moe or something
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?Bay Breeze; Rosey's pretty boring
16. G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?now, Minty A is one of my grails, but I'd have to go with Sweetie Blue here, since - as much as I want Minty A, she still went into production in
some form. Sweetie Blue didn't. Also she's adorable.
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubblesoooh this is difficult, I'm not really a baby Sea Pony person... I was going to say Tiny Bubbles, cause the watercolour hair feels kind of matted and weird after a while (at least if it's the same stuff as Baby Cat's hair), but then I read it again and saw you specified the Pearly ver. Not a fan of pearlies. So.. I dunno. Whichever one I can sell for more money.
18. Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie?I don't collect plushies, but I love Bow-Tie, so I'd go with her. ^^
19. Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split?had to look these up.. honestly, neither of them really do it for me? Either'd be fine with me. Maybe Lofty.
20. Cuteasaurus or ChaCha (Llama)?Cuteasaurus, I guess
21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay?As much as I love Holly Dash, god I am desperate to get Haven Bay
So I'll go for her.
22. Sunburst or Tornado?Tornado, as long as I can stare longingly after whoever gets Sunburst
23. Tux & Tails or Satin & Lace (any version)?Tux. Satin's okay and all, but she's never really done it for me.
24. Rattles and Tattles (newborn) or Sandcastle and Shovels?Rattles and Tattles, but they're both so cuuute!! But I think I like those two a little more.
25. G4 Starswirl or G4 Rainbow Flash?Starswirl! Sooo pretty, I love celestial ponies. Rainbow Flash is cute too, but she's no Starswirl.
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset?gonna have to look up the kitchen, I can never remember what that looks like. hm... I'll go for the waterfall (although I prefer Sprinkles' waterfall
), the kitchen's kind of boring. Now, if the kitchen had come with the kitten it was pictured with in early photos, it'd be a different story
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam?Raspberry Jam, I guess
28. G3 SLH Rarity or SLH Sunny Salsa?Sunny Salsa!
29. G2 Miss Painter or Hip Holly?Miss Painter!! One of my favourite G2s! Also I can't stand Hip Holly, lol.
30. Clover or Patch?ooooh, REALLY tough one, I love them both... I'll go for Patch, since she's a bit more unique than Clover.
3 foot Frilly Frocks or 3 foot Star Shimmer?I didn't know they'd made a 3ft Star Shimmer :O Uh, whichever one's rarer, assuming I could find a buyer for her quickly. I don't have space for anything this huge, got enough trouble finding space for tiny little things
(If we're meant to assume we'd have space for these, then Star Shimmer, I guess? Can't find a photo of her, but her pony self is prettier than Frilly Frocks, so I'll go for her.)
Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair or Sweet Tooth/Lollipop?REALLY tough since I love both of these, but.. hmm... Sugarberry! She's so pretty.
TE Bright Eyes or Tales Bright Eyes?honestly I don't really care for either of them? but I'll go for Tales, I like her slightly more.
G4 Songbird Serenade or Tempest Shadow?Tempest Shadow, hands down. Never liked Songbird.
Welcome to the MLP Arena! 
Guests: 679
Hidden: 1
Users: 6
