Which pony would you pick?

[Esbayne]

ROUND ONE
1. Night Glider 100%! Munchy's cool, and funny (it was that one post that really got me loving her) but Nightglider is one of the most beautiful, I think!
2. Mimic I think, that's a HARD one! I really want both, lol. Bright Eyes is at least somewhat easier to find later on.
3. Snowflake! She was actually my very first pony ever. Xmas Minty is cool but not as cool. B)
4. Honeybuzz!
5. Water Lily 1005. @_@ I want her so bad!
6. Baby Ribbon, but another tough one.
7. Sweet Scoops! I don't like Rapunzel. >_>
8. Wind Whistler, but that's another really hard one.
9. Blueberry Baskets, but both are so lovely.
10. Star Glow!

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul)
11. Lemon Treats!
12. Quackers!
13. Sparkler!
14. Study and Play!
15. Bay Breeze!
16. Sweetie Blue! She never got an official release, did she? At least you can still get Minty in packs.

[SpacePinto]

1. Night Glider, although Munchy is quite pretty as well
2. Mimic, because I kind of like her and it seems like no collection is complete without one from what I've seen around the fandom
3. Minty all the way!
4. Neither.
5. Copper Glow because she looks cute and I couldn't find anything on G2 Water Lily anyway
6. Baby Ribbon because she was cute in the cartoon
7. Rapunzel because I like how she looks and I heard she is really valuable (but I'd probably go for SS if it wasn't for that)
8. Neither, because I already have both and I'm happy with that
9. Blueberry Baskets because I only like year five princesses (and BB looks cute)
10. Starglow because GnS ponies are awesome and Red Roses looks pretty generic anyway

[Safflower]

Round two:
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?
12. Pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?
13. TAF Ribbon or MGR Sparkler?

[Ponyfan]

1. Munchy

I like Nigh Glider also but would choose to get Munchy first

2. TE Bright Eyes

I'm not a Mimic fan. I'd rather Mimic go to someone that would love her.

3. G3 Minty

She's been on my wishlist for quite some time.

4. Honeybuzz

5.  Copper Glow

I love her wings

6. Baby Gusty

7. Sweet Scoops

I think Rapunzel is pretty but she's not a must have for me.

8. Fizzy

I'm not a big fan of So Softs

9. Princess Pristina

10. Star Glow. I 'd love to own that white haired version


Round 2

11. Lemon Treats

12.  Quackers

13. TAF Buttons

14. Nosey and Click

15. Bay Breeze

16. Minty A

Suggestions

Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles


Ponyfan


 

[Gator]

ROUND ONE
1. Night Glider
2. Bright Eyes TE
3. ?
4. ?
5. ?
6. Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)
7. Sweet Scoops
8. Wind Whistler (SS)
9. Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul and Ponyfan)
11. Diamond Dreams
12. pure white Taffy
13. TAF Buttons
14. ?
15. ?
16 ?
17. Pearly Tiny Bubbles

[tailrustedtealeaf]

Ahh I love this idea!
1. Night Glider or Munchy
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE - I do prefer Bright Eyes but I was able to get her rather easily, so I'd go with the trickier one to get if I'm still going for completion.
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?
13. TAF Buttons or MGR Sparkler?
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click?
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?
16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles?
I admit I am a bit typical because I will usually go for the more expensive option...shopping online a lot makes me realize how easy it is to get certain ponies so with completion in mind, I would definitely go this route.
I have a few to add:
Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie? (I'd go Cotton Candy)
Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split? (Baby Lofty!!)
Cuteasaurus or ChaCha? (Chacha!)

[SunPony]

Ah!  This is fun!  And a bit nerve-wracking
ROUND ONE
1. Night Glider or Munchy  This was a tough one!
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE  Not really a huge Mimic fan.
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake  Ah I like them both!
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)  <3 Gusty
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops  Sweet Scoops are in the pose I love best!
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)  Fun fact: I have NEVER had a pony in her pose!
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul and Ponyfan)
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?  There's that pose again...
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?
13. TAF Ribbon (Note, I think this should be TAF Buttons?) or MGR Sparkler?
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click?
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?
16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles  I love her duck floatee!

[Goanna]

1. Night Glider- but this was tough cos I love Munchy too ;_;
2. Bright Eyes- but again, I love them both and own neither
3. Christmas Minty
4. Honeybuzz 
5. Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty
7. Sweet Scoops- much prettier
8. Fizzy
9. Blueberry Baskets
10. Starglow
11. Diamond Dreams
12. Quackers
13. Sparkler
14. Study & Play
15. Bay Breeze
16. Prototype Minty
17. Misty

[IceCrystal02]

Round two:

11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats? definitely her, I don't really care for MGR ponies
12. Pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers? definitely Quackers, I have her, she is lovely
13. TAF Ribbon or MGR Sparkler?

[bright rabbit 1]

11) None
12) None
13) None
14) Study & Play
15) None
16) None
17) Pearly Tiny Bubbles

[LivioKelem]

1. Munchy
2. Mimic
3. Snowflake
4. Honeybuzz
5. Copper Glow
6. Baby Ribbon
7. Rapunzel
8. Wind Whistler
9. Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses

11. Diamond Dreams
12. Quackers
13. TAF Buttons
14. Nosy and Click
15. Rosey Posey
16 Prototype Sweetie Blue
17. Pearly Tiny Bubbles

[Ponybookworm]

I just thought of a suggestion!!!
3 foot Frilly Frocks or 3 foot Star Shimmer?
My answer is 3 foot Star Shimmer due to her gorgeous colours, & the fact she's higher on my Wantlist.

[Taffeta]

Some of these answers are really interesting...

I added a new round and also some more suggestions from people, keep them coming...

Also I figured I should answer them as well now xD

ROUND ONE
1. Night Glider or Munchy - Night Glider
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE - Hard one but Mimic.
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake - Snowflake, no contest.
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz - Another hard one, probably just Feathermay but it'd be tough.
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow - Also difficult, I'm going to go with Copper Glow.
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE) - Baby Gusty
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops - Sweet Scoops
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS) - Fizzy. The best WW to me is a Movie Star
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets - Pristina. Princesses > Scent
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version) - This one is harder. Probably Red Roses unless it was my coral Starglow, who might tempt me the other way.

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul, tailrustedtealeaf and Ponyfan)
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats? - Lemon Treats.
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers? - Taffy. MUCH harder to find.
13. TAF Buttons or MGR Sparkler? - Buttons
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click? - I had to ask google which was which, but Nosy and Click.
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey? - Bay Breeze
16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue? - Minty
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles - Tiny Bubbles, because UK.
18. Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie? - Bow Tie
19. Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split? - Lofty
20. Cuteasaurus or ChaCha (Llama)? - This one is tough. I'll go with Cutesy.

I'm gonna add a Round Three as well!
21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay? - Haven Bay is way harder for me to get, so Haven Bay.
22. Sunburst or Tornado? - Sunburst!
23. Tux & Tails or Satin & Lace (any version)? Satin & Lace (Magenta)
24. Rattles and Tattles (newborn) or Sandcastle and Shovels? - Sandcastle and Shovels, just.
25. G4 Starswirl or G4 Rainbow Flash? - Starswirl
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset? - Waterfall. It has a pony, and she's awesome.
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam? - Raspberry Jam.
28. G3 SLH Rarity or SLH Sunny Salsa? - Sunny Salsa
29. G2 Miss Painter or Hip Holly? - Miss Painter
30. Clover or Patch? - Clover. I never liked Patch much.

Bonus from Ponybookworm:
3 foot Frilly Frocks or 3 foot Star Shimmer? - Frilly.

[Aeryala]

ROUND ONE
1. Night Glider or Munchy - Munchy!  I love both, but Munchy has my heart
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE - don't care for either, but Mimic is such a meme how could I not grab her?
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake - Snowflake, she's so pretty
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz - Honeybuzz is just too cute
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow - Water Lily, her colors are great
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE) - Gusty, 'cause I had her as a kid
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops - food themed ponies are always the winner for me
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS) - Fizzy!
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets - not a fan of those princess ponies, and Blueberry Baskets is absolutely precious
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version) - Red Roses?

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul, tailrustedtealeaf and Ponyfan)
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats? Lemon Treats has a great color scheme
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers? Quackers, I've always loved her
13. TAF Ribbon (Note, I think this should be TAF Buttons?) or MGR Sparkler? - I'll take TAF over MGR any day
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click?  Study and Play (I'm a big reader)
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey? Rosey Posey but honestly don't care
16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue? Sweetie Blue! we've seen Minty so many times..
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles - Tiny Bubbles
18. Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie? Cotton Candy, probs
19. Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split? Lickety Split
20. Cuteasaurus or ChaCha (Llama)?  ChaCha!  I want one so bad!

Round Three
21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay?  Haven Bay - those sea ponies are p cool
22. Sunburst or Tornado? Tornado!  way cooler
23. Tux & Tails or Satin & Lace (any version)? Tux & Tails - I love the boy ponies
24. Rattles and Tattles (newborn) or Sandcastle and Shovels? S&S?
25. G4 Starswirl or G4 Rainbow Flash? Star Swirl
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset? Kitchen Playset!  How did I not know it existed! 
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam?  Peppermint Crunch
28. G3 SLH Rarity or SLH Sunny Salsa?  Sunny Salsa, but don't care for either tbh
29. G2 Miss Painter or Hip Holly?  Miss Painter, mostly because I'm an artist but also those colors!
30. Clover or Patch?  Not sure which ponies these are?

[Safflower]

18. Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie?
19. Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split?
20. Cuteasaurus or ChaCha (Llama)?

Round 3:
21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay? - Haven Bay is way harder for me to get, so Haven Bay.
22. Sunburst or [bTornado[/b]?
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset?
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam?