Which pony would you pick?

[Taffeta]

So just for fun, imagine you were at a second hand store, and there were two ponies on the shelf but you only could afford one. Both are in mint condition. We'll say they're priced at $5/€5/£5/whatever your preferred currency is each.

Rules - you can't ask someone else to buy the other one.
The other one will be gone next time you go to the shop.
You can't ask the store to hold the pony.
You don't own either of the ponies. (If you already have one of the two, or both of them, you must pretend you don't)

It's literally one OR the other.

But you can choose your own reasons for which one you buy (rarity, cost, childhood nostalgia, colours, anything you like).

Which one would you choose, from the following list (answer all or any). I tried to include a few other gen ones but most are G1, feel free anyone to suggest new pairs if they like from G2,3 or 4 and I will add them to this post.

ROUND ONE
1. Night Glider or Munchy
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul, tailrustedtealeaf and Ponyfan)
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?
13. TAF Ribbon (Note, I think this should be TAF Buttons?) or MGR Sparkler?
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click?
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?
16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles
18. Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie?
19. Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split?
20. Cuteasaurus or ChaCha (Llama)?

I'm gonna add a Round Three as well!
21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay?
22. Sunburst or Tornado?
23. Tux & Tails or Satin & Lace (any version)?
24. Rattles and Tattles (newborn) or Sandcastle and Shovels?
25. G4 Starswirl or G4 Rainbow Flash?
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset?
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam?
28. G3 SLH Rarity or SLH Sunny Salsa?
29. G2 Miss Painter or Hip Holly?
30. Clover or Patch?

Bonuses from Ponybookworm and Ponyfan:
3 foot Frilly Frocks or 3 foot Star Shimmer?
Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair or Sweet Tooth/Lollipop?
TE Bright Eyes or Tales Bright Eyes?
G4 Songbird Serenade or Tempest Shadow?

Feel free to add more suggestions!

[Safflower]

Ooh this seems like fun!
1. Night Glider - huuuge want for me, way more than Munchy.
2. Mimic - I don't like either very much, and she sells for higher x)
3. No idea, I don't collect G3
4. Neither lol
5. Copper Glow, her colors!
6. Baby Ribbon
7. Oh this one is tough. Probably Sweet Scoops, I just like her colors more.
8. Fizzy! I don't really care for so softs.
9. Blueberry Baskets for sure, she's been on my want list for forever.
10. Hm... can I have coral haired Starglow?

[bright rabbit 1]

1) None because I don’t like them
2) Bright Eyes Twinkleeyed
3) Only collect G3 unicorns
4) None
5) None
6) None because I customised a Baby Glory into Baby Gusty plus I’m in the process of airbrushing a Baby Glory into Baby Ribbon
7) Rapunzel
8) Fizxy (I need a new one or a Speedy to airbrush)
9) Princess Pristina (on my want list)
10) Red Roses (on my want list under grail)

[Ponybookworm]

My turn!!!
1. Night Glider or Munchy - Night Glider because blue
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE - TE Bright Eyes again because blue
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake - G3 Snowflake because blue & she's not a variant
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz - Have both, love both, hard choice, but I'll say Feathermay as she's in a fanfic I'm writing.
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow - Copper Glow all the way here!!! Water Lily G2 is a beautiful Pony & her frog outfit is cute, but Copper Glow has that unique hair going on, & wings, & a horn!!!
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE) - Baby Gusty because her Mum was sold in the UK. Ribbon wasn't.
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops - Rapunzel because long hair (& can rehair a bad hair one)
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS) - Fizzy because green Ponies are rare. Also prefer Wind Whistler Movie Star
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets - Blueberry Baskets because blue & bilberries are local to Scotland
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version) - Starglow because glow in the dark!!! (Blue too)

Oto edit
Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats? Lemon Treats because I love lemon scents
pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers? Pure White Taffy, harder to find as that glue yellows so much
TAF Buttons or MGR Sparkler? MGR Sparkler, there's just something about the Merry Go Rounds & their designs
Study and Play or Nosy and Click? Study & Play look nicer & have cuter accessories
Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey? Bay Breeze as she's not pink (yep wi G3s it comes down to whether her body's pink or not)
prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue? Prototype Sweetie Blue as I'm sure there's a good deal of blue involved

Ponyfan edit
Watercolour Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles? Misty, watercolours are harder to find in such good condition.

Tailrusted edit
Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie? Bowtie because blue
Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split? Baby Lofty (though I actually have both of these Baby Lofty has a bit more AWWW!!!
Cuteasaurus or ChaCha? ChaCha, even though Cutesaurus is cute...

Taffeta edit (I've already answered my own lol)
21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay? Haven Bay!!! because Sea Pony
22. Sunburst or Tornado? Tornado because blue & used to have
23. Tux & Tails or Satin & Lace (any version)? Tux & Tails because Boy
24. Rattles and Tattles (newborn) or Sandcastle and Shovels? Sandcastle & Shovels. Don't EVER want Rattles & Tattles Newborns.
25. G4 Starswirl or G4 Rainbow Flash? Starswirl!!! SO VERY HTF
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset? Kitchen!!! Later sets are harder to find
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam? Peppermint Crunch because I don't like jam
28. G3 SLH Rarity or SLH Sunny Salsa? Sunny Salsa is harder to find & gorgeous too!!!
29. G2 Miss Painter or Hip Holly? Miss Painter is also more HTF
30. Clover or Patch? Hard one... either way I'd miss the other. Patch I think, her symbol would do it (plant Ponies are everywhere)

Ponyfan 2 edit
Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair or Sweet Tooth/Lollipop? Lollipop because blue again.
TE Bright Eyes or Tales Bright Eyes? Tales because books
G4 Songbird Serenade or Tempest Shadow? Songbird because friend

[lovesbabysquirmy]

1. Night Glider or Munchy: Munchy
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE: Mimic
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake - neither
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz - neither
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow - Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE) - Baby Ribbon
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops - Rapunzel
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS) - Fizzy
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets - Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version): Starglow

11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats? - Diamond Dreams
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers? - Quackers
13. TAF Ribbon (Note, I think this should be TAF Buttons?) or MGR Sparkler? - TAF Ribbon
14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click? - Nosy and Click
15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey? - Rosey Posey
16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue? - Minty A
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles - neither
18. Pajama Case Plush Cotton Candy or Bowtie? - Cotton Candy
19. Plush Baby Lofty or Baby Lickety Split? - Lickety Split
20. Cuteasaurus or ChaCha (Llama)? ChaCha

21. G4 Holly Dash or Haven Bay? Haven Bay
22. Sunburst or Tornado? Sunburst
23. Tux & Tails or Satin & Lace (any version)? Tux n Tails
24. Rattles and Tattles (newborn) or Sandcastle and Shovels? Sandcastle and Shovels
25. G4 Starswirl or G4 Rainbow Flash? Starswirl
26. Waterfall with Cascade or Kitchen Playset? Kitchen
27. Peppermint Crunch or Raspberry Jam? Peppermint Crunch
28. G3 SLH Rarity or SLH Sunny Salsa? Sunny Salsa
29. G2 Miss Painter or Hip Holly? Hip Holly
30. Clover or Patch? Patch


31. 3 foot Frilly Frocks or 3 foot Star Shimmer? Frilly Frocks
32. Sugarberry/Strawberry Fair or Sweet Tooth/Lollipop? Sugarberry
33. TE Bright Eyes or Tales Bright Eyes? TE
34. G4 Songbird Serenade or Tempest Shadow? Songbird Serenade

[Duenia]

1. Night Glider or Munchy
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)

[otocolobus_manul]

Edit because I can’t read and didn’t see you’re supposed to pretend you don’t have either lol

1. Nightglider
2. Mimic
3. Snowflake
4. A truly mint Feathermay (without the head-body mismatch) is unheard of, so definitely Feathermay
5. Copper Glow if she has her wings. Water Lily if they have no accessories.
6. Baby Ribbon
7. Sweet Scoops
8. Wind Whistler, as I feel like a mint version would be harder to find
9. Princess Pristina, as I hear she’s quite hard to find with good tinsel
10. Red Roses

I have some new ones:
Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?
pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?
TAF Ribbon or MGR Sparkler?
Study and Play or Nosy and Click?
Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?
prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?

[cyberunicorn]

1. Night Glider or Munchy - night glider
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE - mimic as i do not like the pose of the other one
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake - snowflake
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz - honey buzz as is nicer pony
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow - water lilly
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE) - gusty
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops - sweet scoops again prefer the ponyy
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS) - fizzy
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets - blueberry baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version) - red roses that hair

[slyons]

Oh I like this...hard, hard choices to commence...

1. Night Glider or Munchy
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets
10. Red Roses or Starglow (G1)
11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?
12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?
13. TAF Ribbon or MGR Sparkler?
14. Study and Play or Nosy and Click?
15. Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?
16  prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?
17. Watercolor Misty or Pearly Tiny Bubbles

[milkywaymochi]

1. an agonizingly hard choice, since I want both of them in my herd so bad, but I think night glider narrowly wins
2. Mimic
6. Baby Gusty
7. Rapunzel
8. Fizzy (I already have NSS wind whistler)
9. Blueberry Baskets (one of my top grail ponies! 😍 )
10. Red Roses (love the glow n shows, but red roses is also a grail pony of mine)

[brightberry]

This is fun!

1. Night Glider or Munchy

I've never really wished for either, but I like Night Glider better.

2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE

Mimic! I'd love to find her one day.

3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake

I like Minty.  She'll work.

4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz

These two are both cute.  It was hard to choose.

5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow

I love Water Lily's symbol.

6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)

Love them both! But I'll keep BBE Gusty and get Baby Ribbon.

7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops

I'm not excited for either but I do like Sweet Scoops.  I don't care for Rapunzel's symbol.

8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS)

Fizzy.  Love her dark colors.

9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets

I guess Blueberry.  They're both ok.


10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)

I'd really love to have a Starglow!

[Taffeta]

I will go up and add them when I have the pc on in a bit...policing family shopping orders now...

And a reminder - it only works if you imagine you don't have either pony

Edit - I added the suggestions, feel free anyone to add more and I'll include them in the first post.

[Leave a Whisper]

1) Night Glider
2) Bright Eyes
3) Snowflake
4) Honey Buzz (this is hard because i don't like either of them)
5) Copper Glow
6) Baby Ribbon
7) Sweet Scoops
8) Wind Whistler
9) Blueberry Baskets
10) Star Glow

[IceCrystal02]

1. Night Glider or Munchy
2. Mimic or Bright Eyes TE
3. Christmas G3 Minty or G3 Target Snowflake She's on my wish list!
4. G4 Feathermay or Honeybuzz none, I'm not interested in G4
5. G2 Water Lily or G2 Copper Glow none, I'm not interested in G2
6. Baby Gusty or Baby Ribbon (play and care, not BBE)
7. Rapunzel or Sweet Scoops
8. Fizzy or Wind Whistler (SS) I own her, she's lovely
9. Princess Pristina or Blueberry Baskets I have her, she's beautiful
10. Red Roses or Starglow (any version)

[brightberry]

ROUND TWO (Suggestions from Otocolobus_manul)

11. Diamond Dreams or Lemon Treats?

Lemon Treats for sure.  I love her colors.

12. pure white Taffy or pure white Quackers?


Quackers! I love her name and symbol.  I think of her as the eccentric crazy pony.

13. TAF Ribbon or MGR Sparkler?

Well, I don't care for MGR ponies.  So, Ribbon?

14. G2 Study and Play or Nosy and Click?

I like the color combo on these two.

15. G3 Bay Breeze or Rosey Posey?

I probably wouldn't pick up either.  But Bay Breeze is ok.


16 G4 prototype Minty A or prototype Sweetie Blue?

Minty is cute no matter the generation.