Do you tell a seller when their ponies are overpriced?

[sundaygirl]

To be honest I don't think $15 for a G1 Cotton Candy in near mint/excellent condition (if that's what we talking about) is too over priced.

Yes, you could probably get one cheaper elsewhere, but it isn't that way off.

And as others have mentioned, what you are willing to pay may depend on a couple of things. If I can buy from a collector in Europe with good reputation who provides detailed pictures right away, I am happy to pay a couple of extra € for a hopefully smooth transaction without oversea shipping.

[bright rabbit 1]

Well the seller I got Gusty, Main Sail, and Caramel Crunch from had Windy, Sunspot, Sweet Tooth, and Love Letter.

Well Love Letter was placed on bidding for £12 but with make a offer, well offered £47 for all four (Sunspot, Windy, Sweet Tooth, and Love Letter).

Well the seller said that Love Letter goes for £50 (I think a near mint costs this much)

But her Love Letter had a really bad hair cut on her mane (so she won’t be worth £50) So she asked for £25 for her. Well tried to haggle the price down but she wouldn’t budge.

So had to pay £25 for her, £12 for Sweet Tooth, £8 for Sunspot, and £10 for Windy. Not going to buy from that Seller again.

That’s all my birthday money gone.

[sundaygirl]

Well the seller I got Gusty, Main Sail, and Caramel Crunch from had Windy, Sunspot, Sweet Tooth, and Love Letter.

Well Love Letter was placed on bidding for £12 but with make a offer, well offered £47 for all four (Sunspot, Windy, Sweet Tooth, and Love Letter).

Well the seller said that Love Letter goes for £50 (I think a near mint costs this much)

But her Love Letter had a really bad hair cut on her mane (so she won’t be worth £50) So she asked for £25 for her. Well tried to haggle the price down but she wouldn’t budge.

So had to pay £25 for her, £12 for Sweet Tooth, £8 for Sunspot, and £10 for Windy. Not going to buy from that Seller again.

That’s all my birthday money gone.

I'm not quite sure I get this. Why did you have to buy the ponies if they were overpriced?

[bright rabbit 1]

Well the seller I got Gusty, Main Sail, and Caramel Crunch from had Windy, Sunspot, Sweet Tooth, and Love Letter.

Well Love Letter was placed on bidding for £12 but with make a offer, well offered £47 for all four (Sunspot, Windy, Sweet Tooth, and Love Letter).

Well the seller said that Love Letter goes for £50 (I think a near mint costs this much)

But her Love Letter had a really bad hair cut on her mane (so she won’t be worth £50) So she asked for £25 for her. Well tried to haggle the price down but she wouldn’t budge.

So had to pay £25 for her, £12 for Sweet Tooth, £8 for Sunspot, and £10 for Windy. Not going to buy from that Seller again.

That’s all my birthday money gone.

I'm not quite sure I get this. Why did you have to buy the ponies if they where overpriced?

Sweet Tooth is going to be Skylark (I don’t like Brush and Grow ponies), Windy is going to be Powder (I don’t like the powder pose), Sunspot is staying the same (only sparkle pony I like), and Love Letter is going to be Quackers (because Love Melody would of took five to six coats of white airbrush paint. I haven’t got enough of it because the paint is being used for Gingerbread, and Birthday Pony who’s going to be Cupcake) I’m turning some Twinkleeyed ponies into non Twinkleeyed version (Mimic and Quackers).