First two of each Species?

[The_Loner]

Merponies:
The G3.5 ponyville ones

I completely forgot about those! That means my two first mermaid ponies were actually Starsong and Rainbow Dash from the Mermaid Dolphin Carriage.

[milkywaymochi]

First 2 unicorns- windy and majesty

First 2 Pegasus- starshine and medley

First 2 earth ponies- parasol and applejack

[Mysticmints]

my first pony in general was heartthrob, but my next were all in a big lot.. huh. ill just list my faves from that lot (just the standard 3 were in it, hhsjdkagd) i still have no seaponies or wingers.

earth: sugarberry and lickety split

unicorn (only 2 in that lot so!!): baby glory and bouquet

pegasus: heartthrob and curly locks

flutter: i only have yum yum!

[LadyAmalthea]

Unicorns:
Sparkler
Baby Ribbon

Earth Ponies:
Baby Blossom
Tootsie

Pegasus:
Baby Surprise
Surprise

Sea Ponies:
I never actually owned a Sea Pony, but I'll name my sister's ponies, since all the ponies from my childhood household are in my possession now.
Tiny Bubbles
Celebrate (from the birthday party pack)

Flutter Ponies:
Pink Dreams from the slumber party pack
Yum Yum from the birthday party pack (my sister's)

[BlushingBlue]

Ah, memories...

Earth pony: Cotton Candy and Parasol

Unicorn: Glory and Windy

Pegasus: Skydancer and Heart Throb

Sea pony: Wave Dancer and Baby Splasher

Flutter pony: Never had or wanted any flutters as a child, I thought they looked weird They've slowly infiltrated my adult collection via lots, but I couldn't tell you who was first.

Winger: High Flyer and Glow

Mer-pony: Seapony Rarity x2 (pearly brushable and styling size) I still don't like G1 or G3.5 merponies, but Rarity finally won me over. Now I have more seapony G4s than the four-legged kind!

Unipeg: If sea-alicorns count, then Seapony Twilight Sparkle. Otherwise, Princess Luna and... another Princess Luna

Breezie: Tra-la-la and Tiddly Wink, I think... Although I must've gotten the Petal Parlor with Zipzee around the same time 2006 is kind of a blur...

[Leave a Whisper]

Ah, memories...

Earth pony: Cotton Candy and Parasol

Unicorn: Glory and Windy

Pegasus: Skydancer and Heart Throb

Sea pony: Wave Dancer and Baby Splasher

Flutter pony: Never had or wanted any flutters as a child, I thought they looked weird They've slowly infiltrated my adult collection via lots, but I couldn't tell you who was first.

Winger: High Flyer and Glow

Mer-pony: Seapony Rarity x2 (pearly brushable and styling size) I still don't like G1 or G3.5 merponies, but Rarity finally won me over. Now I have more seapony G4s than the four-legged kind!

Unipeg: If sea-alicorns count, then Seapony Twilight Sparkle. Otherwise, Princess Luna and... another Princess Luna

Breezie: Tra-la-la and Tiddly Wink, I think... Although I must've gotten the Petal Parlor with Zipzee around the same time 2006 is kind of a blur...

All ponied out in 2006 huh? 

[Artemesia's Garden]

I can remember a few firsts:
Earth - Sunlight
Pegasus - Wind Whistler
Unicorn - Gusty
Winger - Glow
Sea Pony - Tiny Bubbles
Boy - Daddy Sweet Celebrations

[goddessofpeep]

Earth Pony:
Lemondrop
Not sure - could be Cotton Candy, Blossom, Bowtie, or Applejack

Unicorn:
Moondancer
Sunbeam

Pegasus:
Firefly
Medley

Baby:
Baby Moondancer
Baby Surprise

Flutter:
Yum Yum
Lily

So Soft:
Northstar
Posey

Twinkle Eye:
Party Time
Gingerbread

Sea Pony:
Wave Dancer(x2)

Baby Sea Pony:
Baby Surf Rider
Celebrate

Winger:
Sky Dancer
Little Flitter

[Moonbreeze]

Unicorns:
Silver Swirl G2
Moonstone or Windy

Earth Ponies: Both G2
Ivy
Sundance

Pegasus:
Twinkle Star (it COUNTS )
Baby Firefly

Sea Ponies:
Watercolour Sealight
Italy Wave...breaker I think?

Flutter Ponies:
Morning Glory
Rosedust

Winger:
Buzzer
...Can't remember... Maybe Cool Breeze

Unipegs: Both G2
Silver Glow
Copper Glow

Merponies:
Princess Skystar, but none other than that

[Broken Irishwoman]

Earth Ponies:

Kisscurl
Squirmy

Unicorns:

D.J.
Baby Explorer

Pegasus:

Bluebell
Baby Bouncy

Flutters:

Forget-Me-Not
Morning Glory/Rosedust (got them at the same time)

Wingers:

Buzzer
Glow

Sea ponies:

Surf Dancer (Italy)
Baby Sun Shower

[HollowZero]

All I can tell you are:

Earth: Bowtie and Applejack
Unicorns: Glory and Sparkler
Pony friends: Icicle and Zigzag
Unipegs: Queen Chrysalis and Nightmare Moon

Can't recall the other firsts, they were spaced too far apart

[LivioKelem]

Unicorns:
G3 Whistle Wishes
G3 Rarity (Favorite Friends)

Earth Ponies:
G3 Good Morning Sunshine (So soft)
G3 Daisy Paisley

Pegasus:
G3.5 Starsong (TAF)
G4 Rainbow Dash (w/bangs)

Boys:
G1 Steamer
G1 4-Speed

Sea Ponies:
G1 Sea Shimmer (She is going to me now, and this is my first seapony)
-

Flutter Ponies:
G1 Hollywood
G1 Yum Yum

Winger:
G1 Cool Breeze
G1 Buzzer

Twinkle Eye:
G1 Bright Eyes
G1 Party Time

Merponies:
G4 Skystar
G1 Baby Sea Princess

[FernMariposa919]

Earth Ponies - I got Applejack, Bow Tie, Cotton Candy, and Lemon Drop all at the same time, so...

Pegasus: Medley and Sprinkles

Unicorns: Sparkler and Majesty

Flutters: Hollywood and Forget-Me-Not

Sea ponies - Ripple and Celebrate (they were the only two sea ponies I owned)!

Baby ponies: Baby Moondancer and Baby Glory

[Ribbs]

My first two of each species:

Unicorns:
Windy
Pinwheel

Earth Ponies:
Minty
Applejack

Pegasus:
Heart Throb
Flutterbye

Sea Ponies:
Wavedancer
Baby Beach Comber

Flutter Ponies:
Morning Glory
Cloud Puff

Winger:
Little Flitter
Sky Dancer

[Mermaid]

Hmmm hard for me to remember most, but here’s what I do remember:
First two sea ponies: sea light and water color baby sea winkle.
Flutters: tropical breeze and morning glory.
First wingers: sun glider and lady flutter.
First babies: baby firefly and baby Sundance.

What a fun thread! I love reading everyone’s responses!