First two of each Species?

[Leave a Whisper]

Who are/were your first two of each species?

Unicorns:
Windy
SS Gusty

Earth Ponies:
Shady
Salty I think? Or maybe it was Sweet Stuff?

Pegasus:
Sweet Pop
Princess Tiffany

Sea Ponies:
Baby Wavedancer
Baby Sea Star

Flutter Ponies:
Yum Yum
Tropical Breeze

Winger:
High Flier

Unipegs:
Princess Luna
Princess Celestia

Merponies:
Baby Lily Drop
Princess Skystar

[Ponybookworm]

First two Earth are easy: Butterscotch & Blossom.

First two Baby Sea Ponies aren't hard: Surf Rider & Sea Shimmer.

First two unicorns: Galaxy & Buttons.

First two Flutters, Hmmm. I think I acquired Rosedust, Lily, Peach Blossom, Wing Song & Tropical Breeze at the same time

First two wingers: Glow & High Flyer (I only used to have those two)

First two pegacorns: Celestia (big pink talking) was definitely first there. Second??? Possibly Cadence or Nightmare Moon

First two Merponies: deffo two of the three Fancy Mermaids, since I got back into collecting. No idea who was last but do know i had all 3 before Princess Skystar & G4 Sea Pony TS

[Carrehz]

Earth - no idea, as I said in the other thread, I have no idea what order I got my original couple of G3s in x)

Pegasus - Baby Honolu-loo and Twirlerina. I wanna say Honolu-loo was first?

Unicorn - Dollymix Sweetie Belle, then Gusty. But if we're just counting full-size ponies, Baby Ribbon and Glory/Moondancer/Twilight/Windy (got these four all together in a lot)

Winged Unicorn - Nightmare Moon and Princess Cadance/Queen Chrysalis (got Cadance and Chryssie at the same time... does Chrys count as a WU? I know she's a Changeling and all, but she still uses the WU mold...)

Winger - Cool Breeze. I only have one! It's weird, since CB was my first G1. Gotta get her some friends sometime.

Flutter - Rosedust and Morning Glory

Sea Pony - Wavedancer and Seawinkle

Breezie - again, idk for G3... for G4 it was Sunny Breezie, Sea Breezie and Sunset Breezie (I *think* I got Sea and Sunset at the same time...)

Merpony - if we're counting licensed figures, then Egmont Princess Skystar and then Busy Book Haven Bay/Skystar/Novo/Salina. otherwise.. let's see.. Princess Skystar and then Sea Foam/Ocean Gem/Crystal Pearl/Sun Twist, I think I got all of that wave at the same time.

Hippogriff - Flash Feather and Flutter Cloud. I reeeeeally want Silverstream!!

Equestria Girl - Rainbow Rocks Trixie and then the CMC set

[RoseNoire]

Oof, that's a hard question, lol. I think I only know that my first pegasus was Honolu-loo and first flutter pony was Morning Glory. I also know my two first sea ponies, but I forgot their name.

[Leave a Whisper]

Earth - no idea, as I said in the other thread, I have no idea what order I got my original couple of G3s in x)

Pegasus - Baby Honolu-loo and Twirlerina. I wanna say Honolu-loo was first?

Unicorn - Dollymix Sweetie Belle, then Gusty. But if we're just counting full-size ponies, Baby Ribbon and Glory/Moondancer/Twilight/Windy (got these four all together in a lot)

Winged Unicorn - Nightmare Moon and Princess Cadance/Queen Chrysalis (got Cadance and Chryssie at the same time... does Chrys count as a WU? I know she's a Changeling and all, but she still uses the WU mold...)

Winger - Cool Breeze. I only have one! It's weird, since CB was my first G1. Gotta get her some friends sometime.

Flutter - Rosedust and Morning Glory

Sea Pony - Wavedancer and Seawinkle

Breezie - again, idk for G3... for G4 it was Sunny Breezie, Sea Breezie and Sunset Breezie (I *think* I got Sea and Sunset at the same time...)

Merpony - if we're counting licensed figures, then Egmont Princess Skystar and then Busy Book Haven Bay/Skystar/Novo/Salina. otherwise.. let's see.. Princess Skystar and then Sea Foam/Ocean Gem/Crystal Pearl/Sun Twist, I think I got all of that wave at the same time.

Hippogriff - Flash Feather and Flutter Cloud. I reeeeeally want Silverstream!!

Equestria Girl - Rainbow Rocks Trixie and then the CMC set

Size doesn't matter.

[The_Loner]

That's a fun question.

Earth ponies: Cotton Candy and Liljekonval (alt. birthflower Lily of the Valley), my first two ponies ever

Unicorns: Milky Way and Sail Away

Pegasus: Baby Bouncy and Baby Northstar

Butterfly ponies: Sun Glider and Moon Jumper

Flutter Ponies: Wind Drifter and Morning Glory

Unicorns with wings: A fakie I call Magical Nights and Copper Glow

Sea ponies: Splasher and Whitecap

Breezies: The set with Purple Petunia, Darling Dayflower and Zippy Zinnia

Mermaid pony: Pinkie Pie from the Seashell Lagoon playset (she's the only one I got)

[Safflower]

Earth: Baby Ember (blue one), DJ, and Magic Star, all gotten at the same time.

Unicorns: I think Starflower and Moonstone.

Pegasus: Sprinkles and Nibbles and Dibbles? Lofty too? I all got them from Goodwill at the same time.

Wingers: Little Flitter, High Flyer

Flutters: Forget Me Not, Hollywood

[Taffeta]

Unicorns - Windy and Majesty.

Pegasus - Masquerade was first. Second is more difficult to remember. Maybe Dancing Butterflies.

Earth: If we're including babies, Baby Blossom and Cherries Jubilee. If not, Cherries Jubilee and Snowflake.

Flutter: First was Tropical Breeze. Second miust have been Cloud Puff as she was one of my friend's ponies I received when I started recollecting. I only had one in my own childhood herd.

Wingers: High Flyer was the first. I am not sure who the second was, but it was another Summer Wing. It would have been a carboot find.

Sea Ponies: Sunshower and Ripple (UK versions), in that order, as childhood ponies.

I don't remember with the G3s or G4s. But I would say my first alicorn/pegacorn/ponies with horns and wing facilities would be two out of Copper Glow, Silver Glow and Golden Glow, if they count, because I had all 3 of them together.

Equestria Girls - my first was the through the Mirror Sunset Shimmer. I don't know after that. I just know there are quite a few Sunset Shimmers >.>

[Leave a Whisper]

Unicorns - Windy and Majesty.

Pegasus - Masquerade was first. Second is more difficult to remember. Maybe Dancing Butterflies.

Earth: If we're including babies, Baby Blossom and Cherries Jubilee. If not, Cherries Jubilee and Snowflake.

Flutter: First was Tropical Breeze. Second miust have been Cloud Puff as she was one of my friend's ponies I received when I started recollecting. I only had one in my own childhood herd.

Wingers: High Flyer was the first. I am not sure who the second was, but it was another Summer Wing. It would have been a carboot find.

Sea Ponies: Sunshower and Ripple (UK versions), in that order, as childhood ponies.

I don't remember with the G3s or G4s. But I would say my first alicorn/pegacorn/ponies with horns and wing facilities would be two out of Copper Glow, Silver Glow and Golden Glow, if they count, because I had all 3 of them together.

Equestria Girls - my first was the through the Mirror Sunset Shimmer. I don't know after that. I just know there are quite a few Sunset Shimmers >.>

I counted babies so why shouldn't you be able to? 

[Taffeta]

Unicorns - Windy and Majesty.

Pegasus - Masquerade was first. Second is more difficult to remember. Maybe Dancing Butterflies.

Earth: If we're including babies, Baby Blossom and Cherries Jubilee. If not, Cherries Jubilee and Snowflake.

Flutter: First was Tropical Breeze. Second miust have been Cloud Puff as she was one of my friend's ponies I received when I started recollecting. I only had one in my own childhood herd.

Wingers: High Flyer was the first. I am not sure who the second was, but it was another Summer Wing. It would have been a carboot find.

Sea Ponies: Sunshower and Ripple (UK versions), in that order, as childhood ponies.

I don't remember with the G3s or G4s. But I would say my first alicorn/pegacorn/ponies with horns and wing facilities would be two out of Copper Glow, Silver Glow and Golden Glow, if they count, because I had all 3 of them together.

Equestria Girls - my first was the through the Mirror Sunset Shimmer. I don't know after that. I just know there are quite a few Sunset Shimmers >.>

I counted babies so why shouldn't you be able to? 

Guess I wondered if baby earth, peg, uni were separate or collective xD. But I saw you included them so I gave both options

[flutterscotch]

So as my mother really brutally harshly threw out my ponies in 1987 or 88, I am going to count both my original ponies and what exists in my current collection that I started in 1995.

Unicorns:

• Twilight + Glory (as a kid)
• Twilight + Skyflier (current collection)

Earth Ponies:

• Cotton Candy and Applejack (as a kid)
• Butterscotch and Tootsie (current collection)

Pegasus:

• Firefly and Sprinkles (as a kid)
• Medley and Heart Throb (current collection)

Sea Ponies:

• Tiny Bubbles (as a kid) my only sea pony.  I was kinda confused by the sea ponies as a kid.
• Tiny Bubbles and Seawinkle (who is really baity and is being rehaired to look like her Surf Dancer

Flutter Ponies:

• Honeysuckle and Peach Blossom (as a kid, I only had them for long enough to lose their wings before they got thrown out
• Morning Glory and Honeysuckle

Winger:

• Didn't have any as a kid
• High Flier and Glow

Unipegs:
Celestia (that first one with molded hair) and Nightmare Moon.  I got rid of Nightmare Moon for some reason.

Merponies:
Princess Skystar is the only one I have ever had.

[Tropical_Sunset]

Ooh, good question. Let me think.

Unicorns:
Sugar Sweet
Baby Lucky Leaf

Earth Ponies:
Sugarberry
Merriweather

Pegasus:
SS Heartthrob
Twinkler

Sea Ponies:
Baby Surfy
Baby Seabreeze

Flutter Ponies:
Morning Glory
Forget-Me-Not

Winger:
Sky Dancer
Buzzer

Unipegs:
Princess Celestia
Princess Luna

Merponies:
The G3.5 ponyville ones

[Sparkle Pony]

I honestly never really kept track of this, so I have NO idea.

[dragonfly]

oooh I'm. not sure if I remember everyone. Let me think...

Unicorns:
Windy
Baby Moondancer

Earth Ponies:
Bowtie
Water Lily

Pegasus:
Firefly
Baby Bouncy

Sea Ponies:
Baby Sea Star
Wave Dancer

Flutter Ponies:
It would have been Rosedust but my mom wouldn't let me...she said the wings would break off and I wouldn't play with her anymore lol

Winger:
Little Flitter - Mom thought a winger would cure my ache for a flutter pony. I did love her xo naturally I chose the one who looked like Rosedust

Unipegs:
none yet!

Merponies:
I bought all 3 G1 merponies on eBay around the same time

[Ponybookworm]

That's a fun question.

Earth ponies: Cotton Candy and Liljekonval (alt. birthflower Lily of the Valley), my first two ponies ever

Unicorns: Milky Way and Sail Away

Pegasus: Baby Bouncy and Baby Northstar

Butterfly ponies: Sun Glider and Moon Jumper

Flutter Ponies: Wind Drifter and Morning Glory

Unicorns with wings: A fakie I call Magical Nights and Copper Glow

Sea ponies: Splasher and Whitecap

Breezies: The set with Purple Petunia, Darling Dayflower and Zippy Zinnia

Mermaid pony: Pinkie Pie from the Seashell Lagoon playset (she's the only one I got)

Totally forgot about the G2 Unicorns wi magic wings, plus if I had Copper Glow, Silver Glow & Golden Glow before 2010!!! Also can't recall which of the 3 G2s was last...