If Basic Fun made a set of four TE ponies, who would you want them to be?

[LadyMoondancer]

Basic Fun seems to be shifting towards sets of four ponies, perhaps because of increased costs due to the recent tariffs, perhaps because it's what the stores are requesting . . . who know!

Anyway, if (IF) they ever made a set of just FOUR of the Twinkle Eye ponies from Year 4, which ones would be your picks?

(I only included Year 4 ponies because BF seems to like going in chronological order.  Maybe I'll make a separate poll for Year 5 TEs. )

One of mine would surely be Fizzy.  The only TE I had as a kid.   Also probably Gingerbread because it's so hard to find a nice one.

[Adarkdraconis]

I voted for Fizzy, Gingerbread, Galaxy, and Masquerade.  I love their colors, they are so vibrant and pretty, their symbols are very unique, and we like their characters in the show!  I never had a twinkle eye so it would be nice to be able to get a new one.

[Goanna]

Definitely Fizzy, I adore her! I also voted for Gingerbread, Galaxy (she's such a classic!), and Sky Rocket. Just cos I think they're the prettiest

I would like best of all, a repro of Quackers, cos it's so hard to find one without age spots ;; And she's so pretty.

[starbritesprinkles]

I went with Fizzy, Masquerade, Gingerbread, and Sweet Stuff because I think being featured in the show would help them sell well with adults who are feeling nostalgic, not just collectors. Ideally, though, I'd like to see a set of six with Galaxy and Whizzer added to that list.

[SkyCakes]

Whizzer, Speedy, Gingerbread, Sweet Pop. Not that I would actually find them up here in the wild. :/

[Leave a Whisper]

I picked 2 and let my kid pick 2.

I went with Sweet Stuff and Gingerbread and she picked Galaxy and Speedy.

I was all set to pick Mimic and Locket but you scuppered my plans.

[caseysealia]

I voted for Masquerade, Gingerbread, Sweet Stuff and Speedy, since they seem to age the worst of the set (really, they all do) But I don't see too many nice ones come up so it'd be great to have them

[Mewtwofan1]

Fizzy, galaxy, sky rocket and speedy for me. I think fizzy is a fan favourite like g3 minty, and I like galaxy. I also kind of like speedy. I like the colours of her hair, but I don’t really like the orange that her body is. It just doesn’t go well together if you ask me, but I still like her. And finally, sky rocket. I like her colours, and I enjoy the firework theme going on.

[Tropical_Sunset]

I'd love an opportunity to get Fizzy. And seeing crisp new Gingerbreads would be amazing!

[nhal039]

unicorns always win my vote, also gingerbread scraped in cause she is always in terrible condition

[mlp4me]

Fizzy, Whizzer, Galaxy, & Sweet Pop got my votes.

Who would I really like to see, a super duper nice white Quackers...

[Artemesia's Garden]

I'm going with these four:

Whizzer
Gingerbread
Masquerade
Sweet Stuff

Purely because these four are really suffering with plastic issues nowadays, however Sweet Stuff and Gingerbread are in the same pose and I'm sure everyone would want a Unicorn as well, in which case I vote for Galaxy.

[HollowZero]

Sweet stuff, gingerbread, and sweet pop for their known brown age spot issues. Speedy because she's one of my favorites

[Ponyfan]

Sweet Pop, Fizzy, Gingerbread and Galaxy


Ponyfan

[MerryAnvil]

Speedy, Fizzy, Masquerade and Galaxy!

Can't tell I like the Buttons pose huh