Most Underrated Magic Message Pony?

[Leave a Whisper]

Not sure. Maybe Cloud Dreamer?

[caseysealia]

I put floater. 🤔 She seems different than the rest and unique but not in a...Bad way? Not that any of the ponies are ugly persay in this set they just don't either age well or like Windy, don't have the best schemes. I kinda wanna draw them but with more suitable colors. Mirror Mirror is talked about the most it seems. I feel like everyone is forgotten in this set besides her and maybe Cuddles.

[Taffeta]

I had a think about this and I think Magical Breeze (Windy).

I think it because she had such an odd status here as this mail order pony, even though we had had the full set on cards already, so those ponies must have been left overs Hasbro wanted to get rid of.

So that suggests to me she didn't sell as well as her companions or as they expected her to?

I dunno.

Also Mirror Mirror because when I first found her at the carboot sale years ago I didn't know who she was, despite her being in the pony comic occasionally. Whereas I vividly remember Magic Hat, Cloud Dreamer, Teddi (Cuddles) and Floater being in the comic.

Hasbro US cheated Magical Breeze (and Teddi!) out of original names, though, so that's also a factor for me.

Personally I really like both Magical Breeze's name and her colour scheme, and I loved her really curly hair. I think she should get more love and appreciation because she was singled out here, yet she doesn't seem to have made a bigger overall impact even in spite of that fact.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Also I really wanted to do that mail offer as a kid but wasn't allowed to

[Leave a Whisper]

I like Magical Breeze better as a name too. Even though I don't care for her colors.

Cuddles could be an easy choice as a mom for Baby Cuddles.

[caseysealia]

I like Magical Breeze better as a name too. Even though I don't care for her colors.

Cuddles could be an easy choice as a mom for Baby Cuddles.

Headcannon accepted.

Magical Breeze does sound better since we already have a windy   
 
I think they're all ponies I liked better seeing them IRL? Like before I got Cloud Dreamer she wasn't pretty to me but when she came to me in a lot I loved her.