Most Underrated Beddy-bye Eye Pony?

[Leave a Whisper]

Oh boy. This is gonna be a tough one due to how unpopular this set is. I was initially gonna put Baby Half-Note, but when looking at the list, I decided to vote for Sleepypie instead. Because frankly, I keep forgetting she exists. Pity, she woulda been a cutie. The only ones I like are Frosting and Lofty.

[caseysealia]

I put Baby Shady. Such a standout in the pastel-y group of gals, yet she's not talked about imo. I would of put Baby Sleepy Pie had I realized she was there at first.

[Leave a Whisper]

I put Baby Shady. Such a standout in the pastel-y group of gals, yet she's not talked about imo. I would of put Baby Sleepy Pie had I realized she was there at first.

Ive heard Baby Shady talked about...just not too kindly.

[BubbleTea]

Baby Frosting. She's sooooo cute and has an awesome (and uncommon) color scheme. She's never really mentioned by anyone probably because she's a bbe that doesn't have a parent or a regular counterpart.

[Ponyfan]

Baby Sleepy Pie for me. She is one of my childhood ponies but she is hiding somewhere. I sometimes forget about her even though I have her.   Does anyone know if the Pony Purse she came with wasn’t popular?

Ponyfan

[kingluke]

I voted baby frosting, she is just too cute and doesnt seem to be popular.

[caseysealia]

I put Baby Shady. Such a standout in the pastel-y group of gals, yet she's not talked about imo. I would of put Baby Sleepy Pie had I realized she was there at first.

Ive heard Baby Shady talked about...just not too kindly.

True. Poor gal, ages badly, never got a normal release. It seems her mother is liked enough so why not her 

[shabbychicdee]

oh i like this one it was very hard to pick just one but i picked frostings, she is one i keep forgetting about even though i owned her years ago and gosh darn those unicorns were the ugliest

[Taffeta]

I put Baby Shady. Such a standout in the pastel-y group of gals, yet she's not talked about imo. I would of put Baby Sleepy Pie had I realized she was there at first.

Ive heard Baby Shady talked about...just not too kindly.

True. Poor gal, ages badly, never got a normal release. It seems her mother is liked enough so why not her 

Baby Shady is my most wanted baby pony that never existed. Sigh. She had such a fun character in the comics and I know she would have been so loved here if she had been released in that Play & Care Set. I mean, why did we have Baby Heart Throb when we never had adult Heart Throb, but not Baby Shady when we had adult...? No logic...

Not to mention Baby Fifi and Baby Quackers when we never had their mothers either. Or Ribbon, actually.

In answer to the main question, for me it's Baby TiddlyWinks or Baby Half Note, though.

Reasoning...Baby Half Note was out here with BBE but they never advertised her like that in the comics. They never even talked about it. It was on leaflets and stuff, and on her box, but a lot of the ones sold were regular versions. They made a huge deal about the "lullabye eyes" of Baby Cuddles, but not one peep about Baby HN.

And Baby Tiddly Winks because people always seem to forget she existed too, even though she did.

I think the UK only officially had Baby HN and Baby Cuddles with BBE (though I have found Sleepy Pie here, so maybe she got here too somehow, in which case that would make her even MORE underrated...)

I think for all they're quirky and unpopular as a set, the others all get a lot of discussion. Not least because they are the cause of people calling the PaCS ponies NBBE. So long as that name exists, the BBE pony set cannot be underrated, since it suggests that the BBE are the main standard and that makes them rated.

[Leave a Whisper]

I put Baby Shady. Such a standout in the pastel-y group of gals, yet she's not talked about imo. I would of put Baby Sleepy Pie had I realized she was there at first.

Ive heard Baby Shady talked about...just not too kindly.

True. Poor gal, ages badly, never got a normal release. It seems her mother is liked enough so why not her 

Yeah...isn't she prone to mismatch?

[mlp4me]

I chose half note.

[caseysealia]

I put Baby Shady. Such a standout in the pastel-y group of gals, yet she's not talked about imo. I would of put Baby Sleepy Pie had I realized she was there at first.

Ive heard Baby Shady talked about...just not too kindly.

True. Poor gal, ages badly, never got a normal release. It seems her mother is liked enough so why not her 

Yeah...isn't she prone to mismatch?

She's the queen of mismatch 

[pinkkittywinks]

Hands down, Baby Frosting!

Love pkw xxx

[tailrustedtealeaf]

I consider this whole set underrated so I just picked my favorite, Baby Frosting. The unicorn pose is so doofy especially with eye rust, and Frosting is just perfect for the set.

[Loa]

All of them?!