Most Underrated Twinkle Eyed Earth Pony?

[Leave a Whisper]

I'd saaay Tic-Tac-Toe, with Sky Rocket second.

[Kazzellin]

I say Sky Rocket--her body/hair colors are interesting, but her symbol is so plain, and it tends to fade into her body color, as well. Poor girl.

[otocolobus_manul]

Definitely Sweet Stuff - I see her so infrequently I can’t even remember what she looks like. Though I may be biased against choosing Sky Rocket since she was a set completer that took me years to hunt down, so she definitely stands out in my mind 

[Ragamuffin]

Sky Rocket... I never see anybody talk about her!

[kingluke]

I voted sweet stuff, she was so cute in the show. my second is skyrocket, she gets covered up by the pony naut outfit more often because she modeled it.

[pinkkittywinks]

Party Time, I think it is the fact she is so prone to regrind though

Love pkw xxx

[Ponyfan]

Sky Rocket or Bright Eyes



Ponyfan

[brightberry]

I voted Bright Eyes because she isn't really known outside g1 collectors.

[Taffeta]

I would say Sky Rocket or Party Time. PKW is right about the regrind but also she gets forgotten from being in a separate set. Sky Rocket is criticised way more than is necessary IMO.

I don't think Bright Eyes is underrated, I think she still has a higher price than a regular common pony, but that set in general are overshadowed by Mimic's rabid popularity...

I adore Tic Tac Toe so cannot possibly be objective. In my opinion she cannot be overrated...but I am not sure that means she's underrated...

[SpacePinto]

I'm so glad Sweet Stuff is winning!

[tailrustedtealeaf]

This one I have to think about.
Quackers and Tic Tac Toe are out. I think Bright Eyes gets out too.
Party time is certainly talked about, but no one ever talks about her colors? I think they're delightfully fun, and I actually don't mind regrind on her. I'll go for her.

[Minty_Magic]

This is a tough one! I voted Bright Eyes, I know she tends run run more expensive than the others but I don’t feel like she is often talked about or mentioned on want lists! I tend to forget about her sometimes, but I think she’s really pretty!

[Shaiyeh]

Sky Rocket, I'd say. I used to think she was super boring. Then I actually got her and realized she's really pretty IRL! One of those ponies that tend to look bland in photos, plus she's in a pose that's not too popular.