Most Underrated Pegasus

[Leave a Whisper]

Hmm. I gotta go with Medley on this one. Though Heart Throb doesn't get talked about as much either.

[caseysealia]

I voted for a pony within my top 10 pony faves, Heart Throb.
I never see her get talked about and a lot of people say she's ugly, and pink on pink obnoxious but I think it works for her. When she has mint glitter she's stunning. Her hair is the most beautiful too 💗
Medley has a beautiful contrast next to Heart Throb and I feel she's waaay underrated comparing to Firefly, who seems popular especially because of FIM. While I think Firefly is iconic in her own way I think she's talked about too much.

[hilamb]

Medley for sure

[tailrustedtealeaf]

Medley or Heart Throb, it's tough between those two.

[cyberunicorn]

Honestly i link all pegasus are forgotten about to a degree for some reason they are such lovely ponies to look at. But for this i put heart throb

[bright rabbit 1]

Heart Throb is the most underrated pony.

[BubbleTea]

Medley is the most underrated.

Heart Throb isn't forgotten really because she was in more than one episode of an mlp show, had a so soft release after her regular one, and two releases of her baby, as well as being featured on tons of merchandise.

[SpacePinto]

Out of these four I'd say Heart Throb, most people remember her for being melodramatic and for her weird tastes, but she had her awesome moments too.

[brightberry]

I’d say Heart Throb.  I think the others all outshine her.

[Ponyfan]

I have been debating between saying Medley or Heart Throb but the more I think about it I think it’s Medley.

Ponyfan

[kingluke]

For me it's heartthrob. Her character in the show had only one side, which wasn't even that interesting. As a toy she is so lovely tho.

[Taffeta]

Nobody will be surprised to know I voted Meddles.

Because she is the best y2/3 pegasus. Basically.

Also though she gets unfairly overshadowed by Firefly :/

I loved her comic character and all the things she could do. She's definitely underrated, but awesome.

I am surprised so many people said Heart Throb is underrated. I have a really stunning y3 one which came from a collector who decarded (boo hiss) and so her curls and symbol are all mint and yeah, she's amazing. But she's also not only in the MLP&F animation a fair bit, she got a SS remake on which that was based...and a baby pony...(three if you're technical about it!)...

And was still on UK birthday cards as late as 1988 despite not being sold here.

[brightberry]

I think of Heart Throb as underrated by collectors and pony lovers rather than Hasbro.  I notice more talk and recognition for Medley rather than Heart Throb.

[TornadoLovesMelody]

I think Medley.

Never see her mentioned, rarely see her on wanted lists - she didnt even get to have a baby while Heart throb got to have 4! :o

Green on green is pretty when she's bright in color but she often dulls and I think a lot of people see her as "meh" .

[Leave a Whisper]

I think Medley.

Never see her mentioned, rarely see her on wanted lists - she didnt even get to have a baby while Heart throb got to have 4! :o

Green on green is pretty when she's bright in color but she often dulls and I think a lot of people see her as "meh" .

4? Dang! How many times did she visit that mirror?