I'm a bit late to the party but I would definitely choose Red Roses! While I don't personally collect MOC/MIB stuff, I've always loved her color combo, and Perfume Puffs are just a lovely set in general IMO. Also I'm not a huge fan of Punzie. I don't dislike her, of course, but she's just not my thing <3 I'd pick her up if I got a good deal on her, but otherwise, she's a pass for me ^u^