Honest Pony Names - THE best game to play with non-pony people

[Taffeta]

These are so funny

My Dad renamed Cherry Treats when I was a kid. She became "Stink Bomb" literally seconds after being opened from her package in the car driving home from the mall. And it kind of stuck...

[Sky_Rocket_Sammie]

When I was a kid Speedy became Crash. Possibly for my always unsuccessful attempts at skating.

[Strawberry Swirl]

I have a G4 Twilight bank we're using for piggybank stuff. My grandparents keep saying to "Put the change you found inside the donkey." whenever they talk about it.
So aparently twilight = donkey.

Remember the G3 looking bootlegs called Demon Donkeys?
...Yeah. Now you know why.


Btw I’m having a visit today so I’m SO playing this with my dad.

[poniesthatsparkle]

I asked my sister to guess what Sweet Tooth's name was. Her answer was "Diabetes." 

Twinkle Twirl is "Starburst," TAF Yum Yum is "Sugar Crash," and Whirly Twirl is "Whirly Head" to name a few more.

[ZeldaTheSwordsman]

My mom guessed "Four of Hearts" for Sundance

[Matcha]

Tried a few with my boyfriend:
Columbian Daddy Apple Delight = Sunflower
Firefly = Lightning
Fizzy = Cotton Candy
Angel = Blue Horizon
Baby Paws = Big Jim
Apple Delight Family = David (Dad), Apple Cherry (Mom), Sunshine Apple (Baby)
Rapunzel = Princess Doozy
Gusty = Little Maple
SSN Pink Dreams = Hairless Rat (lol)

[Noasar]

I asked my sister to guess what Sweet Tooth's name was. Her answer was "Diabetes." 

Twinkle Twirl is "Starburst," TAF Yum Yum is "Sugar Crash," and Whirly Twirl is "Whirly Head" to name a few more.

I LOVE diabetes pony!!

Tried a few with my boyfriend:
Columbian Daddy Apple Delight = Sunflower
Firefly = Lightning
Fizzy = Cotton Candy
Angel = Blue Horizon
Baby Paws = Big Jim
Apple Delight Family = David (Dad), Apple Cherry (Mom), Sunshine Apple (Baby)
Rapunzel = Princess Doozy
Gusty = Little Maple
SSN Pink Dreams = Hairless Rat (lol)

Big Jim and David are inspired   and I love that he called Firefly Cotton Candy...he tried!!

[BubbleTea]

My mum calls my ponies "dinosaurs" for some reason (I have mostly G4s so it's fair I guess..they don't really look like horses )

True. When g4 first came out my first thought was: PIGS

[Olympus]

Nightmare Moon, Muffin Pony, and Applejack are the only names that my mom and dad know.  To be fair, I have a lot and they all start to blend together after a while...

[MerryAnvil]

When I was a kid Speedy became Crash. Possibly for my always unsuccessful attempts at skating.

Okay funny story that's kinda sorta related...Speedy was like one of my top three favorite ponies when I was little, I loved skating so much. I used to strap an extra pair of rollerblades to my hands and pretend to be her, skating on hands and feet. But uh...then I slammed head-first into the garage door and nearly gave myself a concussion :p Either way it was fun, I love Speedy.