Price Check G1 Chocolate Delight with sundae, brush, and box

[LauraMLP83]

Hi all!  I have Chocolate Delight from my childhood collection, still in excellent condition, along with her sundae, brush, and box.  They are all in near perfect condition, even the box (I can't find the barrette that she came with, though).  Any idea how much approximately she is worth?  I have someone who wants to buy the box only, but I am hesitating because I can't help but wonder if I try to sell the box alongside the pony I will get more money for her. What would you do? Thank you! 

[Taffeta]

Speaking as someone who obsessively collects pony boxes, and who would probably be the kind of person to ask you to sell the box separately...I actually think you should probably keep them together as a set. Although I don't know how much you'd make on separating out the accessories, you'd probably drop the value of the pony herself somewhat...? I dunno. It's a calculated risk? I mean, you'd probably do ok selling the pony and soda together and the box on it's own...but I guess it depends on how much you are considering selling the box for.

[LadyMoondancer]

The soda accessory is worth a ton.

I actually wonder if you would make more money by selling things separately, since there will be a lot of people who have the pony and want the soda.

That said, there is something nice about keeping everything together since it's a childhood pony.

[Stiletto]

I recently sold a pretty much mint condition Chocolate Delight w/o any accessories for $24 on eBay.  With the float they've recently gone for $60-90.  But an MIB went for like $100 if I remember correctly.  Regardless how you sell it, the soda float, is the gem of the set because *everyone* wants it where as far less people care about the box or brush.