Favorite SS Earth Pony

[Leave a Whisper]

Soo hard to choose, but I think Scrumptious is the cutest. Followed by Magic Star and my childhood pony Shady. I also love Sundance, Angel, Crumpet and Posey.

[TheBeatlesPkmnFan42]

Gonna have to go with Shady, since I love me some bright ponies!

[Taffeta]

I really don't know how to vote in this one!
Magic Star and Shady I automatically discount because they're not like my childhood Shady or the Magic Star I knew of and wanted as a kid.
Truly was a favourite of my sister's but not so much mine.

I do really like Angel and Crumpet but not to an obsessive degree that I'd say those over all the others.

Lickety, Posey etc are the same for me as Magic Star and Shady, they existed here but without fur and I only really think of them that way, even though I like fuzz.

I need to think on this one some more.

[tailrustedtealeaf]

I like Shady and Posey, but I think the flocking suits Posey more.

[Miniature Sheep]

It's a close one between Posey and Crumpet; Posey is one of my childhood favourites, but that was the NSS version, so I went with Crumpet. I really love her pose, her mellow colour scheme is gorgeous and the most important deciding factor: actual non-pony crumpets are delicious!!!

[ZeldaTheSwordsman]

Oof, this is a tough call for me.. I'm torn between Sundance, Lickety Split, Magic Star, and Shady. I love Sundance and want to get her So Soft version despite already having the regular one, Shady is cute and needs hugs, Magic Star is cool both in looks and being an Earth Pony who can cast spells, and I also really like Lickety Split and specifically sought out the So-Soft version of her because I love So-Softs..
I'll tentatively go with her, but I could change my mind.

[SkyCakes]

Between Crumpet, Taffy and Poesy.  I love them all equally. I love Crumpet's pretty yellow/orange colors and symbol. I love Taffy because even though mine is deflocked she looks nice. I definately love Poesy because shes my favorite garden pony and I like that she is yellow and pink like springtime.

[Skeen]

Magic Star!  I don't even like those colors in general but I LOVE that pony!

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[MysticIceDragon]

Posey for me. Love her pose and love her colors. Mine still has plenty of pink in her hair and it's her fault I adore it now

[Safflower]

Magic Star! I adore her. Her colors and symbol are perfect

[northstar3184]

Angel for me. Although I also really like Posey, Lickety Split, Crumpet, & Cherries Jubilee.

[NightGliderSA]

Again, easy breezy: Angel. I love her colours and symbol. I would like her both flocked and deflocked 

[Shy Violet]

Another tough decision, I like so many of them. In the end I chose Truly. I love her pose and she was one of my first So Softs that wasn't from my childhood collection. So sentiment is helping me decide.

[glitterball]

So many lovely ones to choose from, but...

I chose Scrumptious - because of her fabulous green hair...  so unusual. 
I do not own her (yet!)  but hope to one day!
I re-haired a Gusty with a similar colour + was most pleased 

[pinkkittywinks]

Crumpet I've got Baby Crumpet and she needs a Mum.

Love pkw xxx