Ponies you thought exsisted but don't

[TheBeatlesPkmnFan42]

One day my friend wanted to give me a pony she knew she had but couldn't find it. I asked what she looked like and described her as the size of a G1 looking shyly off in to the distance with a yellow body, orange hair, and butterflies for a symbol. I had no idea who it was, and in high hopes but not quite expecting it, I pictured Butterscotch in the shy pose as a nirvana. She then gave me a G3 McDonald's Rainbow Dash. Little disappointing that the pony didn't exist, but it was still funny

I'm amazed at how she managed to get every detail of information wrong when describing Rainbow Dash!

[Stormness_1]

For me, I swore Dancing Butterflies wasn't yellow. I can't remember what colour she was 'meant' to be... but I just know it wasn't yellow! I did have a colouring book with her in as a child, so unless I made up colours for her, and they got into my brain as a headcanon, but that's all I can think of... so for me it's wrong-coloured Dancing Butterflies!

[Ringlets]

For me it was mostly the other way around as I thought ponies didn't exist (Scoops, Truly, Cupcake) and then it turned out they did xD.

This so much! there were so many ponies we didn't get in the Uk I never knew they existed really until I was an adult collector, Molly too. And then there were all those pics of  NSS paradise that was never released with the Paradise estate but it was advertised in the Uk comics *siiigh*   
I remember having stickers of molly and the other molly type dolls with their non pony friends in an MLP sticker set (I must still have that somewhere... either stickers or transfers.. something like that.  I thought they would exist but only molly did (although she didn't here in the UK so I thought she didn't exist either at the time) , not the others.   
Oh and then there was .. ugh forgot the name!!   ....the pink pony with white hair and glasses that was the school headmistress pony for the UK pony school  in the UK comics. I thought she existed because the other school ponies did... but nope  . All we got were her glasses with the school play set!!  

[Dragonflitter]

Human memory is a funny thing! I don't have a pony story, but I distinctly remember watching a movie as a kid, and the ending happened a certain way. Years later as an adult I saw the movie again and the ending was totally different! I did a lot of research online to find if there was an alternate version of the movie, but nope, no one else remembers this ending like I do. It was all in my head.

[Taffeta]

@Ringlets - Lady Lessons I imagine she was going to be sold with the school and they decided it was too expensive to do it with the set :/

[invaderhorizongreen]

I could have sworn that I saw a set (like the slumber party gift pack) that had a boy pony in it.  He was orange but wasn't Wigwam. 

You are  somewhat correct in that that would be party time who came with the birthday set, they are a twinkle eyed pony. Not the same mold, but close to the same color.

[shabbychicdee]

i seriously thought there was a moondancer in glorys pose, that is what i thought when i was a kid and saw them in the shops, we only ever had hong kong made ponies here in new zealand so it wasn't the mexican one, it wasn't until i started collecting as an adult i found out she was in a different pose to glory

i could have sworn there was a regular unicorn cheeralie

there is, its a giant styling purple G3 pony with pink hair, i have her

[Leave a Whisper]

I thought Twilight would have black and white hair, because she looked like she had it in the cartoon. Imagine my disappointment to find out she didn't. Still a lovely girl though,

I used to think Lickety-split and her baby were pale purple. Then I recieved her from my friend and discovered she was very much a pale pink.

[Taffeta]

I also thought Minty was purple. That wasn't my fault, though...

Spoiler

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

...Thanks, Fact File.
She was never in the comic, so for that reason, when I found the real one, it took a while to work out who the heck she was

[Leave a Whisper]

I also thought Minty was purple. That wasn't my fault, though...

Spoiler

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

...Thanks, Fact File.
She was never in the comic, so for that reason, when I found the real one, it took a while to work out who the heck she was

That would have been so pretty!

[NightGliderSA]

I also thought Minty was purple. That wasn't my fault, though...

Spoiler

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

...Thanks, Fact File.
She was never in the comic, so for that reason, when I found the real one, it took a while to work out who the heck she was

Oh she would have been stunning!

[kestral_kitsune]

I could have sworn I had an AppleJack that had a dark brown body, and the same golden mane and tail, dark red symbols with freckles,was in the collector pose, and looked like she could have been a piggy. 

[bluerose9978]

NBBE Baby Lofty. I swear I saw one somewhere, but I have been scouring eBay and she hasn't shown up.

[Haruna]

Baby Sugarcake -- oh, wait, she does apparently exist; I just can't find one for the life of me. I will believe she exists when I hold her in my two hands, lol!
 

NBBE Baby Lofty. I swear I saw one somewhere, but I have been scouring eBay and she hasn't shown up.

Oh, but she does exist, though! She was a grail of mine for years. She was produced in Brazil. Here's the picture from My Little Wiki:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


She's too expensive and rare for me, so I ended up buying a lovely custom from Pandabear_chan instead.

[Leave a Whisper]

Baby Sugarcake -- oh, wait, she does apparently exist; I just can't find one for the life of me. I will believe she exists when I hold her in my two hands, lol!
 

NBBE Baby Lofty. I swear I saw one somewhere, but I have been scouring eBay and she hasn't shown up.

Oh, but she does exist, though! She was a grail of mine for years. She was produced in Brazil. Here's the picture from My Little Wiki:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


She's too expensive and rare for me, so I ended up buying a lovely custom from Pandabear_chan instead.

OMGS she's so cute!