Favorite Collector Pony

[NightGliderSA]

This was a hard vote - I love them all actually. Voted Blossom and Lemon Drop, but would have voted Cotton Candy if possible

[brightberry]

This was hard!  I love all these ponies.   I put Minty and Lemon Drop.  But Snuzzle is really close.

[Shaiyeh]

Lemon Drop and Minty are my favourites

[Foxtale]

They make such a lovely group! I picked Minty because she was my first and Butterscotch because I love yellow ponies

[SeashellnBubbles]

My favourite isn't on the list....it's Macau's Jenny that I love most of all!

[HelloGoodbye]

This is one of my favorite sets so I like all of them!  My favorites are Snuzzle and Lemon Drop, though.  If I could have chosen a third I would have picked Peachy or Cotton Candy.

[Brightglowpony]

Blossom-  She's been a fav since childhood.

[BuckinghamAlice]

Cotton Candy and Minty

[Einhornbaby]

Peachy <3 I just love her, loved her as a kid (always wanted her, never happened though). I have a little collection of variants and merch <3

[Taffeta]

I genuinely don't know how to vote on this. I only had Lemon Drop and Peachy as a child. I only really knew about Cotton Candy and Blossom out of the others, as they were the ones in stories. The other four didn't really appear in stories in the comics. I guess probably Cotton Candy in terms of story character, although Blossom was sweet too, Lemon Drop was quite fun and Peachy has a nice story in one of the &Friends comics.

But in terms of the toys...I actually really like the ones I got recently from the US which may be MO or may not, because of their vibrant colours. Snuzzle and Minty especially. But it means I genuinely don't know how to vote here. I don't love any of them above the rest, but I can't pick out two...

[Tulips]

I voted Cotton Candy and Snuzzle, but that's only because UK/European Bow-Tie and Argentinian Posey aren't on the list - they win hands down in my mind.

[FlickaFriend]

Oooh, this is a tough one but a really good one!!!  I absolutely love Collector's Pose - to the extent that I'm not really interested in any other poses right now, apart from Posey pose perhaps - and I am trying to complete my CP set at the moment.

Very difficult to pick just two, but if I have to it would be Blossom and Bluebelle.

Blossom because she was the (one) pony I had as a child, and Bluebelle because I love her colours and her stars and her eye colour.

I'm interested to see not many other pony people picked these two as their faves.  I think they are gorgeous classics, I also love how the two of them look together as their manes & tails match but their body colours complement.

I don't have Minty or Butterscotch yet but they are on my list.  Perhaps Minty could usurp Bluebelle.

The ponies I remember most vividly from my childhood are Blossom, Butterscotch and Minty.  I absolutely love them all.

My 5-year old daughter would choose Peachy as her favouite (she's currently her favourite pony) and probably CP Bow Tie as well.  She does love Bluebelle though and keeps trying to pinch mine but I am resisting (I already had to swap Peach for my daughter's Music Time, have to draw the line somewhere)

ETA: I just bought Lemon Drop!!!

[lunar_scythe]

One guess who I picked...



Bluebelle, of course!  My obsession with her started with my first 'white' one, she was actually my very first Bluebelle.   Whether it's some super strange fading, color leaching out like regrind, plasticizer, or factory error, I just love my weirdos, and then I fell for the normal ones, too!

[Broken Irishwoman]

Lemon Drop! She was a loved childhood pony.

[Gingerbread]

Cotton Candy Couldn't just pick one out of the remaining ponies so left it at that. I would have voted for Bow Tie too but she's not on there. Cotton Candy and Bow Tie were my very first ponies