Who is your impossible pony?

[MintySocks]

I actually HAD a mint Sweet Stuff and sold her a few years ago!! *facepalm* Now I can't find her anywhere.

But the ones that elude me most are Muchy, all the baby TAFs, and Hollywood's Spike. But now that I've read the woes of other collectors, it's making me more appreciative of the Galaxy, Bubbles, Seashell, Nightglider, Butterscotch, and Confetti I DO have. 

[Leave a Whisper]

Rare/Elusive-wise-It's always:
Starglow
SS Gusty
Alphabittle

[scarletjul]

Italian Blue Posey with bright pink hair. 

[Broken Irishwoman]

Dutch Baby Cat! I'm sure she comes up regularly on eBay and such, but I never look there because she's way out of my price range anyway. Every year I hope to find her at the big kingsday fleamarkets, I usually find some Dutchies, but never her. And I don't even like the rest of the Dutchies.

[LNS]

Barnacle ... without fail he always seems to be discolored, spots, hair cut, horrible marks ... something.  I'm sure there have been many decent ones but if I'm not supposed to be buying any at that point much easier for me just not to look than to be all "ah man!" with what is available.

Argentina NorthStar is the other big one. Have come close a couple of times but she seems to slip through my fingers every single time when I manage to find one in good condition.  One day, I hope.

[HoustonCollector72]

G4 Sweetie Blue and Minty A

G2 Magic Star Swirl Moc
G2 Magic Diamond Glow

[Einhornbaby]

My Impossible Girl, eerrr I mean pony, my impossible pony

Ha ha, I had the same thought! Whovians FTW.

  *thumbsup*

[hilamb]

I have 3 ponies right now, they are my grails too. 

G1: Felicidades

G2: Blondie aka White Pearl and Blue Pearl.

[Duenia]

So because of this thread I ended up looking around again for my impossible pony again and she's now happily sitting on my bookcase lol.

[SummerSkye]

CP Bluebelle.

Apparently, FF is way more common. Seriously, I've been collecting on and off since around 2000 and I haven't managed to get a decent one.

 

[cricket]

SS Taffy.  Mine is in terrible condition and I have been hunting Ebay for YEARS now for one in mint condition but she hasn't appeared.  It's made worse by the fact that I have her MOC and looking at all that perfect flocking and minty whiteness makes my fingers itch to open her....and I am very against opening MOCs!   

[BethyVic]

I have been collecting for 16 years, and I have a few that are very hard for me to find.  Baby Sea Shimmer and Baby Sea Princess, as well as one I have been searching for since I started: MOC Starflash, the US version that is on a card and not in a box.   

[CactusBloom]

I'm pretty laid back about the ponies I want, but the one I really wanted and could never get was G4 Fashion Style Applejack. They only sold a few of them and never made more! I love the Fashion Style ponies because they're really soft and smooth feeling.

I've accepted that I'll never have a Fashion Style Applejack, but it's still kind of sad. She's my favorite G4 pony.

[littlepinkstardust]

I don't know why but no matter how hard I try I can never get my hands on a good Peppermint Crunch :/. I was so close to getting her before but lucked out last minute and now I can only find overpriced and baity versions of her. Makes me cry inside.

[glitterball]

SS Taffy.  Mine is in terrible condition and I have been hunting Ebay for YEARS now for one in mint condition but she hasn't appeared.  It's made worse by the fact that I have her MOC and looking at all that perfect flocking and minty whiteness makes my fingers itch to open her....and I am very against opening MOCs!

Arrrgh, the temptation!! 
Have you thought about trying to restore her? Or is it too far gone?