i haven't looked that close at this 2 for 35 sale, but I have shopped others. You can mix and match. You can get two MLP or a MLP and something else. Last BOGO that I bought something I got the Finding Dory bear for me and Grumpy Bear for a friend. Usually all the ones that are included in the sale are marked 2 for $35. If you're not sure, just try adding it to your cart and see what happens.
sailorstitch