Your top 5 ponies?

[Kiwi]

Not sure I could narrow it to 5 (especially since just childhood ponies is 6), but all my specials are in one space so I could sweep them into a bag in one motion - top shelf of my china cabinet. Has my childhood ponies, and other specials/rares/nirvanas.

[Miniature Sheep]

Fortunately, I only have a small collection, so this is a fairly easy one.
I would take...
Posey
Windy
Majesty
The MacDonalds version of Princess Silver Swirl (all of those are replacements for my favourite childhood ponies so I'm very attached to them)
and Moondancer (because she was a challenge and a half to find and she's in beautiful condition!)

Any of the others would be easy as pie to replace, thank goodness!

[Sweet_Stuff]

Not sure I could narrow it to 5 (especially since just childhood ponies is 6), but all my specials are in one space so I could sweep them into a bag in one motion - top shelf of my china cabinet. Has my childhood ponies, and other specials/rares/nirvanas.

I could sweep them all into a bag if I wanted to as well. If I had to pick five though it would be:

1) Medley (first pony)
2) Paradise (SS in minty condition!)
3) Magic Star w/stand (He's in Minty condition!)
4) Twinkler (sparkle pony) - all the sparkle ponies actually, in one swoop of the hand!
5) Munchy and all the TAFs I could get..

It's a tough one though!

[jrr74]

Let's see...

No. 1-Firefly-she is not only a childhood pony, but she was also the first mlp I ever bought
No. 2-Glory-my second childhood pony, and one of my favorites
No. 3-Applejack-another childhood pony, and another favorite

After that, it's a toss up.  Ponies that come to mind are Bubbles and Fizzy-I had them both as a child but have no idea where they have ventured off to.  Have since then replaced them.  I also like Posey and CJ.  These are all comfort ponies 

[BuckinghamAlice]

I don't have any valuable or hard to replace ones tbh, so I'll stick with favorites/sentimental value.

1. Sparkler
2. Sugarberry
3. G2 Sundance
4. G3 Rainbow Flash
5. Power Pony Rarity as Radiance

Although since G4's are soo small, and Sparkler and G1 Applejack are kind of a package deal... I do feel she'd jump into the backpack too, and frankly who am I to stop her?

[Ledbyrd]

Ack! So hard to choose! But if I had to I would go with:

1. G1 Nightlight - cause she's my fave pony ever
2. G1 Princess Sparkle - beloved childhood pony
3. G1 Nightglider - because Nightglider
4. G1 Dazzleglow - I love the glow and shows. So pretty!
5. Can't decide between Dutch Heart Pony or one of my TE's. TE's are my fave set but I really love my Dutch Heart and she may be harder to replace.

[Rachel8125]

Mine are all G1s:

1. SS Bouncy
2. SS Fifi
3. Ringlets
4. Raincurl
5. WW Moonjumper

[ickykitana]

Ooh good question...

Hmm here goes

1) Seashell - my first childhood pony
2) Starshine - my fav through childhood
3) Italian Applebelle - my first Hybrid
4) Italian Magenta Bow Tie - so gorgeous
5) Lemondrop - from childhood, my dress up girl

[pickwick_pirate]

I think, if I had to choose I would go with

G1 nss Shady
Argie Shady
Piggy Snuzzle
G3 Seaspray
Pretty and Pearly Baby Beachcomber


I think


As it currently stands ...

Tough question!_

[gullideth]

All G1
1. Whizzer (have)
2. Applejack (have)
3. Night Glider (wish!)
4. Tootsie (have)
5. Dancing Butterflies (have)

These are all the ones I either loved most as a kid or wanted most as a kid.  The only one I didn't have was Night Glider and I wanted her so bad, still do.

[Heart891011]

1) G4 Fluttershy
2) McD G4 Lily Blossom
3) normal G4 Lily Blossom
4) G4 unicorn Twilight
5) G4 starlight glimmer
I know none of them are rare, but they have sentimental value to me

[applejackbunny]

G1 collector's pose AJ
G1 Sunlight
G1 Lemondrop (any version)
My August alt birthflower
Mimic


Post Merge: March 19, 2016, 05:13:16 PM

Oooh wait! There's Gypsy...might have to swap her with the alt birthflower. Aargh...this is too hard! 

[nemubones]

1)Wind Whistler
2)Firefly
3)Brazil Sunlight
4)Galaxy
5)Sunburst

[vira]

mmmmm, thats a hard one!!

going with my heart:
- g1 cha cha
- one of my g1 sundances
- g1 medley
- g3 desert rose
- and g1 ember's dream

[PJSparkles]

oh no!! I have too many great ponies to make this an easy decision.

1. Bouquet (she's my icon after all, and I love white unicorns)
2. Baby Ember (my favorite as a child)
3. Honeybuzz
4. Feathermay (has to be by honeybuzz forever!! they're a pair )
5. Nightmare Moon (she was a gift from my sister...maybe she can use her ability to make the moon rise to smack it into the spaceships and nullify the problem )

As I type this I just keep seeing my childhood Bowtie peering at me from the shelf with her droopy eyes and I feel awful  I'm sure whatever havoc nightmare moon would wreak on my ponies wouldn't be nearly as bad as the alien invasion