Who was your first pony?

[Harmonie]

Hm... Depends on the definition. My *very* first MLP toys were the first G4 set from McDonalds. However, if we're going for the official brushable toys, my first was G3 Jazz Matazz. =)

[spottedslug]

My first pony as a little kid was Parasol. As a collector, Clever Clover.

[Rainbowrific Renia]

G2 Magic Motions Ivy. She is also my alltime favorite pony.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Oh gosh, she's pretty!  I really love the G2 ponies.  I may have to start collecting them at some point.
 

[Ponyfan]

G1 Cotton Candy was my first pony.


Ponyfan

[Ledbyrd]

G1 Peachy was my first pony. I got her with the Pretty Parlor play set when I was about 4 years old. I still have Peachy but don't know what happend to the play set

[yellowGusty]

My first pony was some pink soft fake with tricolor hair. I think I might be two or three then. After that I got Boysenberry pie as first G1 pony. She was Queen in every play I played with my friends. 

[ajmeier55]

Mine was G1 Bubbles 

[Strawberry Swirl]

G3 Strawberry Swirl!

I also got a McDonald's Sparkleworks and Pinkie Pie somewhere along the line. I'm also convinced I had a Sweetberry plushie, too, but I haven't
been able to get my paws on another one.

The rest of my childhood ponies I still have.

[Spectrum]

My first pony was a G3 Minty, and I also had a Butterfly Island version of Golden Delicious. I don't have Minty or Golden Delicious anymore, sadly.

As far as actual collecting goes, it was a G4 Rarity, who has a failed styling cut going on because I thought, at that time, I could be the true pony hair master.

[Leave a Whisper]

I don't remember which pony was my first. I grew up with the G1s but if I had to make a very tentative guess I'd say...G1 Windy maybe? idk.
My first G3s were Rainbow dash and Denim Blue though.

[Eurocoin]

G4 Fluttershy

[freyjaloh]

Mine was G1 so soft parafise and fifi but i lost them growing up. Still searching for it

[ponycake]

I got Tuneful from my older sister. She was the only one left over from their toys besides several Dream Beauties and some merchandise like the lunch box and thermos sets.

[Acherontia]

My first one was G1 Windy, french one 
And I think my second was Gusty. They remain my favourite ones, together with the collector pose 

[U2QueenBee]

G1 Cherrries Jubilee, my mom got her for both me and my sister.