Is this Ebay seller the infamous Brooke Kutik?

[kellyponyfeathers]

Ummmm, my profound appologies if I'm accusing a perfectly good and honest seller, but I saw some listings on Ebay for "ponyknott" and thought the countertops in the pics looked familiar.  The last time I (think I) saw them was when Brooke Kutik listed some ponies and we had a whole conversation about it here.  I checked the ship from location, and sure enough, it says Florida.  Red flag???

[ponylady]

I am going to assume you are probably right. She has been off and on for the last year or so.

I don't think anyone has been taken by her this time around but I would definitely proceed with caution 

[lovesbabysquirmy]

Thank you for the update!    She always returns after a bit of time... ponies are addictive for all the WRONG reasons with her!

[kellyponyfeathers]

The feedback for this ID is great too, but it looks like it's all from buying, not selling.

[Shiromisa]

Sorry, but who's that? :x Someone to be wary of?

[lovesbabysquirmy]

Sorry, but who's that? :x Someone to be wary of?

Oh gods yes.  She has stolen thousands of dollars in money and stolen ponies by opening chargebacks and not paying for them.  And she's been up to this nonsense for at least ten years. 

Here is more info: http://mlparena.com/mlp/index.php/topic,283452.0.html

[PinkRosedust]

How does this woman keep getting new Ebay accounts?

[babylicketysplit]

its like the stephen king novel sometimes they come back...  OVER and over LOL.    stay clear of her if you can.

[Stormness_1]

She's dealt with another of her ID's Technologicgirl, with positive feedback, so probably yes.  Too much of a coincidence otherwise!

[Ringlets]

It seems very probable! ugh! she just keeps coming back    Thank you for the heads up   Like the others said, steer clear of her if you can! she is nothing but trouble!

[RockinPrettyBeats]

Does anyone have any photos on their computer that Brooke took? If so, we an compare them.

Maybe I'm thinking of someone else, but I thought Brooke took photos on a kitchen counter? Or am I confusing her with another person on the bad trader list?

In any case, this ponyknott ID has existed since 2005. Also, it says she is located in Milton Florida. Does this add up with what is known about Kutik.

Edit to add:

Also, according to her feedback, she has been selling ponies since 2008 and has positive feedback for it. Actually, she has no negatives or neutrals. Maybe it's not her?

[Sea_Breeze]

Perhaps if someone recognised the artists of those custom ponies it might shed some light on who the seller is.

[Galactica]

Wow- what a scammer!  Good thing you recognized her kellyponyfeathers- yikes!

[maycrestmom]

good golly I was watching several of those auctions, too... I had no idea = so what's the MO?  The buyer for the macau put in a brag thread - so if the item goes high she scams?  I feel sorry for the birthflower, big brothers and others over the $100 mark if those are scams

man, good eyes kellyponyfeathers!

[lovesbabysquirmy]

She typically scams as a buyer but I believe she has been known to do it as a seller as well...