Pony Urban Legends

[cesprins]

Purple sugarberry. It ended up being a doctored photo, but was still urban legendary whilst it lasted. 

i saw a sugarberry once on ebay with lavender strawberries. I was going to snipe bid but forgot about it.... and now she haunts my dreams

[hathorcat]

Oh these are great! Lol...I forgot about that purple Sugarberry and I think White Windy counts as "urban legend" until we find her on card!

[pinkkittywinks]

The only thing i can remember is about a Greek Bride Firefly and the Prototype Toola Roola in the diva pose with a G1 Brush.

the greek bride firefly is real

there have been found a couple of greek bride ponies, peachy and firefly are two i can name!

we have a picutre of peachy in the nirvana gallery peachy came with clothes were as firefly was with out clothes, but boxed in the bride pony box.

here is a link to peachy ~

http://mlparena.com/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.ShowItem&g2_itemId=452469

love pkw xxx

[BrightIdea]

I remember some person coming into the arena a while ago and bragging about having unreleased G4s.


She went on about having G4 Minty in its package, and having the Applejack and Star Dreams set, when I think it had just been leaked/announced. Also she talked about having many other sets that were going to come out (but gave no details).


She also said "I'll post pics when I have my own account," and things like "oh, I've had that Applejack and Star Dreams set for a while."


Sure... I totally believe you    That was hilarious and awesome that SoSilver got unreleased merch though, so it must happen sometimes!


But seriously, even bizarre claims like this might get you thinking, and add fuel the rumor mill.

[Gingerbread]

I thought NSS Fifi was real, as one of the small things I do remember as a child was wanting the blue pony with the pink dogs on it. If I saw a prototype in a leaflet or something I don't know, heck it could have been a convincing fakie I guess. Or just the SS version.

[Mermaid]

BBE Sunlight? Need I say more? To this day I loose sleep over her!

I did not know that lil' tot was toys for tots! I remember WAY back in the day at dream valley she was posted for a children's hospital/cancer pony! I still thought that! Thanks for clearing that up!

[kittybethy]

I thought of the NBBE baby sundance too!

 Instead I have a custom by Ardid!

[BabyIceCrystal]

How about TJ? He was brown with white hair and hearts symbol like Peachy. Way back before there were very many people on the internet from outside North America he surfaced and there were numerous theories about him. I believe he may have been the first "Nirvana" to show up and everyone was confused. Some thought he was a custom but there were others who thought prototype or limited release or exceptionally rare or something like that. He was named TJ because he looked like Megan's (not MLP) horse from the beginning of Firefly's Adventure and there was a theory that he may have come with some editions of the Megan's Place playset based on that similarity.


Of course now we know she's a Macau pony.

[Chi]

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

And there's this. It took me forever to come to the conclusion that it was the lighting, judging from all the other photos from this seller.
I wish she was really white, though. Seems like just a bad photo can make a pony appear like something we've never seen before.
;~;

[StoryDreamer]

I still swear to this day that there was a North Star plush, but nobody in the community has seen one so I'm probably crazy.  I know I saw it at a thrift store once!! 

[CrystalCrown]

BBE Sunlight? Need I say more? To this day I loose sleep over her!

i remember seeing a picture of her somewhere! and i think a posey too? not sure. it was a while ago that i seen pictures/ heard of this so details are fuzzy.

purple sugarberry? O.o sounds AWESOME!

[Sebby6]

The Lullabye Nursery coming with a bar of soap.
I still see that soap on peoples want list.

Also - someone once told me there were Mountain Boy erasers. Much as I'd like that to be true I've yet to see one.

[Pixelchu]

I heard that if you go to Vermillion City's docks and use Strength on the truck you'll find a MIB Rapunzel underneath.

This made me laugh, think I'm still a huge Pokenerd at heart!

[BlackCurtains]

BBE Sunlight? Need I say more? To this day I loose sleep over her!

My favorite! It wasn't just the pony for me though, but the thread on the Arena Archive™
I read the whole thing, fascinated. It has everything! Mystery, drama, weird sellers! What a ride!

And... I has a sad. I never bookmarked it and the search no longer works. Guess I have to find it the hard way

ETA2: Found it. Get some popcorn!

ETA: I thought I had snagged the pic the last time she was brought up-

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[lunar_scythe]

And... I has a sad. I never bookmarked it and the search no longer works. Guess I have to find it the hard way

use google advanced search, and specify the arena for the website.