The pony you've been meaning to get...

[MoonStars]

Tickle. She's not a #1, top of the list, grail, but I like her. But every time I see one (I'm not actively looking, so she sometimes just shows up in a random search) she's not in very nice condition. I'm not a fussy collector, but her symbols are so lovely, and I don't want them faded or messed up or unglittery or "rusty" if she ever falls into my hands.

[STLGusty]

NBBE Gusty...one day

I'd also like to get a Parasol considering I thought I had her for YEARS - and apparently I don't, lol.  At least she's not hard not find, eh?

[Kitkumi]

This is really recent, but the Shine Bright Luna. I never wanted to buy the entire castle set at full price, and when it went on a massive sale I missed out. And I can't make myself pay ebay prices for an FiM pony thats fairly new, lol.

[Chi]

Baby Glory and baby Moondancer.
Can't seem to find one that I like enough. Blah, so picky.

[Ember1]

All the twinkle eyes.

[toralei]

G3 Fluttershy springs to mind. Since I'm new to collecting the G1s, I feel like none of them really qualify yet?? I have been wanting to get Bubbles for a looooooong time, though.