Edited mah list, been some time and my tastes have changed!
I've really minimized and streamlined my collection due to lack of space and a general maturity in the requirements for the ponies I collect. I prefer great to near mint condition ponies with no large stains, age spots, cancer, or large rubs to the symbols. Haircuts are ok only in ponies without mechanisms. For brush n grow, mechanisms must work, other ponies with mechs, it doesn't really matter. For more rare ponies, these rules can be broken.
On to the list!
G4:Brushables:
Minty, Silver Spoon, Twist-a-loo,
Pony, non glimmer wing Ploomette, SweetsongBlind Bags: Would prefer they come with their cards, the bag's not needed, I usually toss those anyway.
Wave 1: Sugar Grape, Minty, Roseluck, Pepperdance, Sweetie Swirl, Lucky Swirl, Sweetcream Scoops. Wave 1 is lowest priority, I'm pretty sure I have them all in storage but these weren't in the pile of cards I keep as inventory for some reason.
Wave 2: All.
Wave 3: All but Lovestruck and GITD Twilight Sparkle.
Wave 4: All but crystal Rarity, metallic AJ, crystal Rainbow Dash, Amethyst Star, and Twilight Velvet.
Wave 5: All.
Wave 6: All.
Wave 7: All but Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, Banana Bliss, and Lily Blossom
Wave 8: All but Royal Riff, Gilda, Flam, Flim Skim, Comet Tail, and Gardenia Glow.
Wave 9: All.
Anything Fluttershy, other than her brushable/FS. I collect merchandise with her on it <3
G1:FF and CF Minty
NBBE Babies: Blossom, Surprise, Half Note, Fifi, Bouncy, Quackers, Nightcap,
RibbsBBE Babies: Frosting, Sleepy Pie
Newborns: Rattles/Tattles, Doodles/Noodles, Dibbles/Nibbles, Sleepy Head/Sleep Tight, Sticky/Sniffles, Puddles/Peeks, Sandcastle/Shovels, Speckles/Bunkie, Big Top/Toppy,
Jebber, Shaggy, Yo-Yo, Squirmy, Wiggles
SS: Gusty, Truly, Skippity Doo, Hippity Hop, Crumpet, Twilight, Angel, Taffy
TE: Whizzer,
Galaxy, Mimic, Tic-Tac-Toe,
Bright Eyes,
Quackers, Party Time with minimal or no regrind
Flutters: Peach Blossom, Hollywood, Wind Drifter,
Pink DreamsPrincesses: Sparkle, Starburst, Taffeta, Pristina, Moondust
Boys:
4-Speed, Salty, Quarterback, Chief, Slugger, SteamerTAF: Buttons, Yum Yum
Pony Friends:
Zigzag, Creamsicle, Oakley, Cha Cha, Edgar
Wingers:
Glow, Buzzer, Sky Dancer, Whirly, Sun Glider, Flurry, Starry WingsSunshine Ponies: Sand Digger, Seaflower, Shoreline, Wave Runner
Perfume Puff: All
BnG: Skylark, Star Gleamer
Loving Families: Brother/Sister Bright Bouquet, all of the Apple Delight family
Sparkle Ponies: All MO versions (except Napper and Twinkler) and store version Star Hopper
Fancy Pants: Dots n Hearts, Sunnybunch, Glider
All Baby Brother ponies but Paws
SHS: Flowerburst
SeashellAny MIB/MOC variations of North Star
Nirvanas: I want a ton, but I'll need to go through them all and pick more, but I definitely want the 2 nirvana versions of North Star (Argentina South Star, and Brazilian North Star) and any of baby North Star.
Any nirvanas of the second set of Rainbow Ponies (Tickle, Trickles, Pinwheel, Confetti, Starflower, Flutterbye)
I currently have NC/Spain Pinwheel and Trickles
Other items:
North Star's accessories from all forms, back cards, sticker.
Any variants of Princess Tiffany, and her accessories: wand, hair pick, bushwoolie (Friendly) I have her hat, still need the other stuff

Swap Question Answers - Culture Swap
Sorry but you are not allowed to view spoiler contents.
Twisted Fairytale Questions
Sorry but you are not allowed to view spoiler contents.