Wilton Cake Pan poll

[Butterscotch1]

Which would you prefer? The original unpainted Wilton Cake Pan:
 visitors can't see pics , please register or login


or one like this?
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[kittybethy]

I've never seen that before!

 How cool!

[Butterscotch1]

It is pretty cool.

[hathorcat]

I ll jump on the "very cool but no idea of price bandwagon" I am afraid.

Cant say I have ever seen something similar - there are so many merch collectors on here though someone with much more wiseness than me will hopefully be along soon

[fingerpaints]

I think this would be a pretty hard item to put a price on because it is so unushual, unfortunately, unushual & saught after are two different things. I would put it up for a starting bid of what you are willing to let it go for and hope for the best

[Summer-blade]

wow it's weird but it's kinda cool I'm not sure what it might go for...I like it

[Butterscotch1]

Thanks. I know it is unusual and it is sought after by some people trying to complete their collection. I was just hoping someone here may have bought one before so I could give the people asking about it a price. I guess I will just have to let the one listed on eBay establish a price.

[wiccanpony1]

I want it,no idea of a price though sorry:)

[Butterscotch1]

Which would you prefer?

[FantasticFirefly]

Since I can't have cake, I'd prefer the one to hang on the wall and look pretty!

[01mlplover]

I love the painted one! I think it would look awesome hanging on my wall

[PrincessLuna]

the second...DUH!

[Butterscotch1]

the second...DUH!

I wholeheartedly agree with you but some people don't like to see MLP altered unless it is severely damaged. Also, it is really interesting, I listed a regular unpainted pan on eBay a couple of days ago that got bid up to $25 in less than 24 hours from the opening bid of $9.99 while this one has been up for over 24 hours and is sitting at $10.49!

[hathorcat]

the second...DUH!

I wholeheartedly agree with you but some people don't like to see MLP altered unless it is severely damaged. Also, it is really interesting, I listed a regular unpainted pan on eBay a couple of days ago that got bid up to $25 in less than 24 hours from the opening bid of $9.99 while this one has been up for over 24 hours and is sitting at $10.49!

I think I understand that - for aesthetic reasons the second one is clearly gorgeous but if its about collecting original people will go for the first! Personally, I am not a merch collector but the painted one is gorgeous.

[FantasticFirefly]

Isn't this a "precious pony" cakepan? Correct me if I'm wrong, but technically not licensed by Hasbro? If it was official merch, or a rare item I'd agree with the unaltered being more collectible. For this, perhaps it depends on which pony is featured and the people wanting to bid for that pony.  Did you customize the pan yourself? It's a beautiful job.